4.7 (140)
324 Pittsburgh St, New Derry, PA 15671
(724) 694-2560
Service options
Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.
Greg Thatcher
2023-09
What a fantastic place. It's different from a traditional restaurant. If I have this correct Rosemary started by her love to cook and feed family and friends. It took off from there and really never lost the charm of cooking for family and friends. This was my first time there and everyone working there is family. Mike cooks the pizza in a wood fired oven seen in the picture. His cousins Nadine and Kristen are the most wonderful waitresses. Also in the pictures are a picture of the front and back of the menu. We sat in the barn as you see in the pictures filled with round tables and a couple booths. It was so cool and it started to rain and the metal roof sounded so nice and cozy. There's tables outside in the lawn so on a nice evening you could sit there and there's a couple tables outside of the barn under the porch roof. There's also another separate pavilion area in between the barn and the wood fired oven that you can sit at. I'm not sure about indoor dining. I think they have it but I'm not sure because this was my first time. The pizza was excellent. We had the margarita which was delicious and I got the diablio which was sweet and spicy. It was so good! However, my wife liked the margarita better and didn't really care for the sweet and spicy.We also tried the chicken wings which are done in olive oil, rosemary and garlic and we're excellent. We saw others getting family salads which is just what it is, a big salad for the table to share and meatball parmesan which I was told is really good. We will definitely go back. It's cash only. And BYOB. They do not charge a corking fee and you can bring your own dessert. And I think you're allowed to bring your own non-alcoholic beverage (water,soda) They don't want you bringing other food. Just dessert is allowed. Also, if you bring a bottle of wine, bring your own glasses. They had some clear plastic cups to accommodate us but said sometimes they run out. It's paper plates and plastic utensils which don't bother me. It's all part of the charm of the place. However, I read a review before we went and a gentleman was disappointed with the atmosphere.It is seasonal for eating there. However, I believe they still do takeout all year around, but I would call first. It also gets quite busy. However the night we were there the weather was calling for rain so it wasn't quite as busy as normal. You can make reservations by calling them at 4:00. I hope you give it a try and I hope you enjoy it as much as we did.
Peg P
2022-05
Fabulous Florentine pizza! Drove almost an hour to come enjoy it. All of their dough is homemade and cooked in a wood fired oven. Adorable outdoor setting great for the whole family BYOB.
James Durstine
2023-09
…More
Mike Rager
2023-10
…More
stacey halloran
2023-06
Pizza is out of this world. I don't live close by but I'll be back! The only problem was the fuzzy carpenter bees flying around in the one pavilion we were under (a crumpled up brown bag hanging up where they bore their holes usually scares them away...it works for me!) My daughter has a huge fear of bees...but aside from that she also thoroughly enjoyed the pizza.Parking: Lots of parkingWheelchair accessibility: There's no steps anywhere that I saw so I don't see why a wheelchair would be a problem.
Jim Lovejoy
2023-10
…More
Beth Emmett
2023-06
…More
Amy Steele
2022-05
Our family really enjoyed our meal and outdoor dinning with live music , room for children to dance and romp, and good service! The outdoor bee hive oven pizzas were really delicious! I was especially pleased with the gluten free, dairy free pizza!! We'll definitely be going back and sharing with our family and friends!
Marie Stawarz
2022-05
I booked this place months ago for my sons birthday party! Was told I would be able to come the day before to decorate, we would be called beginning of the week for the final details of how many people and what food we wanted, I gave a deposit to hold our spot and were told they would give us a total the next day! Was think it would be around $250… no it was $700!!! I couldn’t get my deposit back! So the week came for my sons party and never got a call and I called them to see when I could decorate and they told me not till 9 at night or the next morning.Then I had to cancel because my husband tested positive for Covid and I was told I can’t get my deposit back because he was only two days. Not my fault my husband got sick! I didn’t get a I’m sorry, or nothing or even feel better. I have had horrible costumer service!! Oh and when you call to book the gentleman is very quick and doesn’t answer questions!Very disappointed!
Kathleen Dobbin
2017-05
I hesitate to write a review as this is the best pizza I have ever eaten and I don't like sharing. This is in a rustic outdoor setting-BYOB. We have taken many friends here and all agree it is wonderful wood fired pizza in a relaxed atmosphere. On weekends, reservations are a must-we frequently get take out and we live more than 30 minutes away-well worth the travel for the freshest and tastiest pizza I have eaten!
Steve Prosdocimo
2020-05
It's a hidden gem in Derry township. For years we'd take our kids to keystone lake to swim and then have to figure out dinner when we got home. Little did I know this place was 5 minutes from the lake! Outstanding pizza at affordable prices, family friendly. Absolutely great place to eat pizza!
Brandon Fick
2023-09
…More
Tony Kovatch
2023-05
…More
Jay Court
2019-05
If you love home made pizza wings and salad well you have definitely got to try this place. The atmosphere is awesome from the out door seating to the quaint barn with Tv's to the friendly staff this place is one of a kind and NO place like it around. Go there oncecand your hooked!!!! We were :)
Connie Baluh
2023-08
…More
Allen Razza
2023-07
…More
Robb Luther
2022-05
What a cool place. The outside dinning is in a barn(ish) type building Huge roomy tables and great food.I don't think they take a credit card so bring cash.
Christina Wuchina
2023-06
The waitress we had is so sweet and hard working. She does a fantastic job!!Kid-friendliness: Kids can play in yard while you wait for food.
John Evangelist
2020-05
Quoted one price for a party but when we went to pay the owner increased the price by several hundred dollars. Terrible service, owner swore up and down in front of several guests. What a joke. Would not go back. Beware if he does not offer a contract, he uses this as a tactic to increase the price. Get everything in writing. The food and workers were good, but the owner is pathetic.
Dave Frycklund
2023-08
…More
Scooby Doo
2022-05
Ordered A few🍕's. And a Hoagie and a Salad. VERY 👍GOOD. And the all the workers,or waiters and waitresses were very polite and friendly people.And they provide great entertainment!
Marcella San Miguel
2018-05
The relaxed nature of the place. Slower service and not a wide selection of pizza or knowledge of how you could personalize your choices. But good was really good.
P S
2017-05
Food was good but the atmosphere left something to be desired. I was expecting a cow to wander out around the corner. If you like that kind of thing then you might like this place. Me, I'd order out myself.
Sheila M. Jackson
2019-05
Superb pizza with fresh, quality ingredients. Excellent customer service! Always friendly smiles! Great selection.
Joe Pro
2021-05
Very good pizza and great environment to eat and have a good time!
Lucy Vallana
2021-05
Best pizza in western PA! Wonderful atmosphere and staff. Would give more stars if I could.
Fred Jackman
2022-05
If you like sitting out doors eating great pizza (byob) drinking your beverages listening to live music . Rosemary's might be for you .
James Fannie
2017-05
If. You want some of the best pizza in this area. (Maybe anywhere) Look no further. All variety is great.
Jim
2021-05
Very nice outdoor dining. Pizza was amazing. Staff did great.
Jonelle Dongilla
2019-05
The best wood fired pizza! Outside space for kids to run around until food arrived. Diablo is to die for! Byob
| Monday | Closed |
|---|---|
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4-9 PM |
| Thursday | 4-9 PM |
| Friday | 4-10 PM |
| Saturday | 4-10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Scan the QR code to leave a review.
Powered by bulkqrcodegenerator.com
Pet Stores in the USA
Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.
Broswe by Population