Fensty's Flea Market

Big Wally

2024-03

Something for everyone. Dig through all of the stalls and you will find hidden treasures. Friendly staff can answer questions and help guide you.Great selection of vintage toys and comics, horror movies, sports memorabilia, and other goodies.This is an amazing antique shop with a large variety of vintage and collectible items. There is a huge section of vintage vinyl records.We spent over three hours and didn't get to see everything. Definitely will come back for another visit.

Angela

2023-10

Great flea market/thrift shop. Nice selection of items to choose from. Worth a stop when in the area. Lot's of unique items too!!👍👍👍

Krista Marie

2023-11

My all time favorite flea market place. They really have everything here and everyone is so friendly. I’ve gotten some of my favorite things I’ve ever owned here over the years. A little bit of something for everyone and I’ve never left here unhappy.

Florence Betteridge

2024-04

Bit pricey in places but always something to buy,, super friendly people work there

Joe McNeil

2021-05

Great experience as always. It's not just the amazing treasures I always find, it's the people. Scott and all the staff/vendors always treat you like family. Taking a family trip to Fentsy's on Easter before dinner might become a new tradition.

Emily Boyle

2024-01

Really cool flea market! Lots of neat stuff. Employees are nice, good experience overall.

mia

2023-05

overall not bad, lots of little things to treasure hunt through. also great that it’s indoors. i did think the aggressively pro-gun shirts were distasteful/uncomfortable in the wake of recent events.

C C

2023-06

Didn’t buy anything, but I did see some fun stuff

Abigail Levengood

2018-05

My dad took me here while I was home for Thanksgiving and the place is big and has a lot of wonderful stuff. I was able to find the book pictured, Story of the Wild West and Campfire Chats by Buffalo Bill, it's dated 1902. It's not in the greatest condition but better than expected and at a cost of only $3 well worth it. I gave 4 stars due to the lack of organization. None of the records, comics, or books have an order which makes it hard to siphon through. We were still able to find great stuff though. Definitely would recommend to those who like antiques, old records, and old books. Just give yourself plenty of time to sift through it all.

Rob Moffett

2024-04

lots of fun great finds very nice vendors

Greg Pepe

2023-06

Been there multiple times. Great place to check out, never know what you might find. The people are super nice & you can always take a break & grab some food.

MorganHendrickss

2022-05

I come here almost every week and throughly enjoy the many items they have there. The staff are all welcoming and always willing to start a friendly conversation. It’s always fun to find some cool and well priced finds. I cannot recommend this place enough, though it can get hot inside in the summer it doesn’t change the fact that the business is well kept and always a happy and friendly environment. It’s also nice when they have the food stand running for the customers. For any people who love records this is for sure the place to go!

Heather Rossler

2023-05

Decent place but not a place I’d drive 45 minutes to again. Pretty average stuff for what seemed like high prices. Wasn’t a bad way to spend an hour or so.

Lazarus Diaz

2023-05

Absolutely love it here!! I take the whole family every weekend now and sort through records to add to our collection!! Food stand has good breakfast sandwiches also!

Kristina McNeil

2021-05

I love this place . My husband and I love taking the drive out to visit when we can . The staff here is always so nice and willing to share the story behind their beautiful pieces . We have found so many hidden gems. Even when you have a problem their always there to help even if not their fault and make you feel welcome . We always keep coming back because they value their customers and genuinely care . One vendor ( sorry I can't remember the name ) I went in with my young daughter to buy a gift for my sister and I was so nervous of all the beautiful glass pieces, but the wife made us feel at ease and even joked kids are kids because I told her not to touch a thing lol. I just thought that was sweet to say to stressed out mama ;)I also noticed how they treat their vendors like family and care for them . Above anything I value businesses who care not just about the customers but their vendors/employees too .

Steve Drehobl

2021-05

I truly enjoy this place. I've been there twice. I would love to go back again. After seeing that they do not require masks, however I must respect their freedom by exercising my freedom to keep myself safe. There is no wonderful vinyl record or other cool item that I consider important enough to expose myself to the risk of Covid19. Perhaps many more feel as I do and business might be better with masks.EDIT: if customers are so sick that they can not wear a mask, then they should not be in public places.

mrerecticon01

2021-05

Whether you are looking for Vinyl records, your Halloween decorations, to a surplus of movies and games, this place should have your interest spiked in no time with the vast collection of items available. Got some really cool and awesome stuff while I was here. They do only take cash at this time but they do have ATMs on site. They do like to discount you for the more stuff you do purchase. If I am ever in this area again, my wife and i will definitely be back.

Joscelyn Jhtextiles

2021-05

A fun place full of funky stuff from old tools, pin ball machines, to haunted dolls, books, and vintage vinyl and comics.My only complaint is that a lot of the staff did not wear masks, particularly the cashiers. The customers, for the most part, were masked and kept a comfortable distance. The place is big, so it was easy to socially distance.

Karen Thivierge

2023-05

Love going to Fensty’s!! It’s a given I’m going to find something of value or a treasure that holds a memory every time I go there. You won’t be disappointed just stopping by will find yourself aweing at this and then aweing at that. Many interesting items to take home!! Love Fensty’s!!

Becky Bloomer

2021-05

My Mom, twin sister and I spent the day antiquing and this was our last stop. We had fun at Fensty's. Everyone who we talked to who had a stand or worked there were so nice and friendly. Lots of great deals and wide variety of items. Can't wait to go back!

Donna Elliott

2022-05

Loved this place! HUGE vinyl selection! Loved the guys who run this section! We will definitely be back. Give yourself a lot of time as there is much to see! Everyone is so friendly and helpful!

Christian Jude Grillo

2021-05

Fun place to check out vintage and antique items

Laura Korpics

2023-05

Just went shopping there. Bought all kinds of goodies. I needed golden books for my grand son. I found The Poky Little Puppy. Bought some jewelry, several glass items, beautiful sea shell napkin rings, a wine rack and a Delft pin. All great finds..

Dee Gads

2019-05

Stopped by today after Pied Piper Diner very nice indoor flea market. Friendly and helpful owner welcoming us to the area. Also helped us look for certain items.. Great variety of all items including pinball game machines! A lot of fun...

Gerri B

2018-05

The place looks great. It's come a long way. Scott has done a great job cleaning it up and it's a lot more organized than it has been in the past. There are alot more vendors. It goes far into the back of the building. You are guaranteed to cone out with some treasure. Great place, friendly people.

Virginia Germak

2020-05

The owner stayed open for us even after they were supposed to close. He couldn't have been more nice and shared great stories about his music experiences. I was able to find Tom Petty records that I have been looking for and went home with 2! Will definitely be returning but this time with alot of time to look through the entire store!!

Misanthropic Sapiophile

2018-05

I came here per a recommendation from a friend that frequents this place. I wasn't disappointed! The record shop is nice. Inadvertently, I walked up to a table that had a lot of military memorabilia, and I bought a fee pieces from that lady. Nice, mellow atmosphere.

L Rentschler

2021-05

Lots of old stuff to buy. A little of everything. Loads of 45 and 78 records , cassettes , vcr tapes and dvds. Glassware, tools, collectibles. They have restrooms and food. Burgers and hot dogs, soda. Tables to sit. Very pleasant atmosphere. Takes about 2 hours to see it all. Handicap accessible.

May

2022-05

You can find some random stuff here. As the saying goes, one man's trash is another man's treasure. They have a selection of miscellaneous tools, gadgets, collectibles, shirts etc. In the back, there is also a small food store. They make good cream of broccoli!

Darryl Hetrick

2022-05

Interesting place with some interesting finds. I find it annoying though when places don't take cards, but have an ATM right there so they can make money on you getting your money. Bring cash.