New York Bagel Cafe

Casey Peetz

2024-01

…More

Tonya Jackson

2024-04

…More

Mia Navarro

2024-04

Our 1st time visit and it was a great experience, and my grandkids and daughter had a blast. Everything we tried (lox bagel, pizza bagel, breakfast bagel, cream cheese plai, you pick 2, Mango Mania & Strawberry Banana smoothies and sides) was excellent, great customer service on the counter and table side. We will definitely return and recommend to friends and family.

Parker Owen

2024-05

…More

Scotlin Irene

2024-03

I had called them before I left to see how much a bagel was, because I know how these cafes like to up charge on the cheapest things. I call and the guy tells me “they range from $1.00-$2” basically. I go through the drive through and order JUST 3 Asiago bagels and cream cheese (because who eats a bagel without cream cheese???). Tell me why my order was $16???? Not including the tip???? As soon as I heard the drive through worker say “$16 is your total” I left the drive through line because what do you mean 3 bagels are $16???? I can go to Panera and get 3 bagels WITH cream cheese for $9….Absolutely ridiculous. The fact that the worker didn’t tell me how much the cream cheese was also pissed me off, because why would you not tell me the cream cheese is more expensive than the actual bagel??? And how does that even make sense???? I don’t know all I can say is it felt super scammy of them to not tell me when I called, and I’d rather save my money and go to Panera instead, Sorry not sorry!!!

Samantha

2024-05

bagels are good. Employees don't talk a lot and are rude. I didn't realize when ordering through the drive thru that you have to ask for a bagel toasted instead of them asking you. Lady didn't say anything to me at the window either.

Alexandra O

2021-05

Old School Bagel is THE bagel shop in Tulsa, super good, great options, their smoothies are really good, the bagel sandwiches are great, and it’s a nice place to study (when they aren’t packed). Cool morning date place, and did i mention that their toasted bagel is my fave food in Tulsa?!✨

Alyssa A

2023-08

Fantastic bagel sandwich. I’ve never been to New York but I felt like I was there in this little cafe. Must go back someday!

Jennifer Kisamore

2024-01

My family go here regularly. Everything is tasty! They even give slices of bagels to our dogs when we bring them with us in the drive thru lane. Our dogs now get excited when they hear the word "bagel." Service is friendly but gets backed up on the weekends in the drive thru. I wish they had someone taking orders in the line during peak times like other drive thru places so it was ready when you get to tge window. It would help move things more quickly.

Sarah Dewberry

2022-05

If you want the world's best experience eating a bagel, look no further than OSB! The staff is amazing and the food is delicious! The keto bowl, the healthy start bagel, and veggie sunrise are my three favorite things to grab from here. They are serving up the best bagels and coffee in town!!

Jeremiah Perkins

2019-05

I love begal sandwiches and this place has a large assortment of those! You have an option of begal and then you can put almost anything you want on those. The food there is good, no amazingly great but good. The begals seem almost generic in flavor and almost store bought ( I've only had a few though). I would definitely recommend this place if you're in the area.

Trey Neeley

2020-05

This was my first time actually going inside this restaurant and sitting and eating as I've had the bagels before but have never ordered any of the sandwiches on their menu. The bagels...just...so ridiculously good. Everything bagels are the best and these were perfectly seasoned and the sandwich the bagel was used for was perfect. Definitely going to be stopping by more often now!

Nicole Davis

2022-05

The bagels and cream cheese were great. The turkey and chicken both tasted a little bland and processed (definitely not freshly made) but the sandwich still had good flavor and the bagels were nice and fluffy! Affordable prices and a fast drive thru.Pictured: “Old Smokey” and “Chicken Breast”

Sandy Radford

2023-05

First time to visit. Food and service was great. So many choices and food was ready quickly to our table.

Roberto Corral Vazquez

2024-01

…More

Chuck Leupen

2022-05

The best bagels in Oklahoma are at New York Bagel Cafe. They have friendly, fast service and I’ve never received my order wrong! They are truly the standard for delicious, variety bagels. Perfect for large families who have individuals that are particular!

Jordan Hayes

2024-04

…More

Nicole Sonsini

2022-05

I used to love old school bagel, I couldn’t be more disappointed now. I used to order the Caesar bagel a couple years ago, I had an odd craving for it and it’s not even close to the same. Also it was made terribly. The chicken is like a school chicken patty. I feel like I’m in public school again. I also didn’t hardly get any Caesar, and the little I have tastes watered down. Not only poor ingredients but poor presentation as well.

Walter Lipman

2024-03

I'm a New Yorker, bred, born, raised, and a lifelong resident. When I say that this bagel shop has New York quality bagels, I mean every w word of that.Go, eat, enjoy!Vegetarian options: Scallion cream cheese, on an everything bagel!

Jackie O.

2024-02

…More

Carrie Nelson

2024-03

Worst experience, the food was not good, service terrible and quality of espresso drinks was awful. Do better. We won't be back.

Alexandria

2020-05

This place has delicious bagels and coffee. One of the only places along brookside offering Almond milk to use as creamer. (I'm lactose intolerant).My favorite thing they have is the french toast bagel for a treat on weekdays. I have also been known to drag many a friend and relative in to the shop on the weekend for brunch. They have great prices and quality food. The atmosphere is clean, quiet, and cozy. There is also a nice seating area outside when the weather is nice.Definitely stop in if you haven't!

Paul Iwanaga

2019-05

Love this sandwich shop! Great New York style deli shop atmosphere with very reasonably priced delicious bagel sandwiches under $7.

Keke Zara

2023-06

Excellent experience every time! Love the environment...clean, friendly, spacious dining area with outdoor option...and THE best bagels in Tulsa. Everything is delicious: our favorites are the lobster bisque soup, lox bagel, and the 5th Avenue sandwich. Teas and coffees are great too. If you haven't ever visited, we think it's worth a try! 🙂

Petra Allen

2023-05

This is my favorite bagel store. Everything is good. Fresh bagels. Great variety. One of my favorites is half a sandwich and lobster bisque soup.

Barbara H

2024-03

…More

Matt H

2023-12

…More

Heather R

2024-03

…More

Rayofsmoke

2022-05

Pretty Great bagels but worst coffee I’ve ever had. Who wants a bagel without coffee? I’d visit more often if the coffee wasn’t essentially water. Cmon guys- I’m a New Yorker and this is depressing.

E McS

2023-07

Unfortunately, this place has really gone downhill in the past few years. I've loved them since I moved to Oklahoma back in 2010, but I'm officially done with this chain. Every time I've gone in the past 3 years, my order has been wrong in some major way. If it's not missing an ingredient, it's not prepared as ordered. Example: the past 10 or so bagels that I've ordered toasted have been straight up cold/mushy. I've tried ordering them double toasted, extra toasted, etc... they're never toasted. Another example: today, I ordered a sausage roll warmed up (because every bagel I've had in the past few years has been so disappointing), and it comes out cold. Just a cold hot dog wrapped in cold dough. Not sure why they can't toast or warm anything here, but I'm done giving them a chance.