Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street

Dawson Hall

2023-12

This place is great, it was my second time coming here and this time my wife and I came for lunch. They have an all you can eat lunch deal for 14 dollars and it’s totally worth it. The pasta was good but the pizza was great, awesome texture and delicious taste. If I had one complaint it would be that they drizzled one of their pizzas with way too much olive oil and it overpowered the taste and coated my mouth for the rest of the day. Other than that some of the best pizza I have had. Also the customer service was fantastic, right when we walked in were immediately greeted with a smile and amazing service the rest of our meal. Will for sure be coming back.Parking: Parking was awful.

Dayna Guinn

2024-04

Popular pizza place. Bit loud inside. Cool older building, which gives it a historical vibe a bit.The service was good our waiter Michael was helpful and friendly.We tried the Tensbysimmo pizza, loaded with all the meats! I'd say the sausage was not my favorite tasting. Pizza sauce reminded me of a basic sauce nothing too fancy just simple. Needed salt to bring out the flavor more. The crust had a good chew to it. A hefty pizza full of those toppings made me full quickly. The homemade delicious ranch tasted amazing with fresh dill and other ingredients used.Pricing, wow was kinda surprised by the bill when my husband told me. Even with a beer it was like $50 for 2 of us. We tried it. Nonetheless, maybe this place will fit your pizza needs. I think I got my fix.Parking, they have a lot in the back and some along the road. Busy busy area!

Ric Gonzalez

2024-04

Can’t go wrong with just plain ol pepperoni pizza and garlic knots here it’s amazing. The Italian deli is not what you would think but it’s still good. The staff offered to make another menu item and take it off the bill but we refused to let them do that. Always a great experience and a little secret if you have littles they’ll give them a piece of dough to play with while they wait . We will always go back when in Tulsa .

Mubeen Kamani

2024-03

I’m not sure what was happening the day we went, but they were getting everybody’s order wrong. We had told them to make sure there is no meat on the pizza but they served us pizza with chicken on it.We had to wait a little bit more for them to replace and remake the pizza.The waiter highly recommended the garlic knots and said they were heaven on earth. They were good.

Cyn Guzman

2024-03

Hear me out. The location is nice, great customer service with attentive staff. There is patio and indoor dining. Kids friendly. The menu had so many choices great pizza choices awesome combinations and plus also can half and half your pizza. We got the cinco of something pizza it’s in the very last with spicy condiments. I liked and loved the pizza… the reason the sausage was huge I felt like it needed to be thinner it looked more for a pasta which is more reasonable but pizza no. The jalapeños I did and was looking for crisp jalapeños not whole cut and the crust was very bread I literally just ate one slice! I got full which I attempted a second slice but I couldn’t crazy usually a average times is max two. Slices are long slices.The rest was good ,the raviolis we ordered seems like they keep them in the fridge and try to refried them which no doubt but the inside kept very stiff. It was crispy the bomb part but some were delish and tender and the others were stiff and not ready… on the other note try them out

Eliza Vandiver

2024-04

The service was amazing! The appetizer was delicious, as was the pizza! My absolute favourite is the BBQ chicken pizza~ Those onions with the bbq sauce is absolutely divine.Parking: Parking was difficult, since the free parking is shared by three other restaurants. We had to park down the block in front of someone’s residence. It was still kinda close, but awkward to find.

Nam H. Nguyen

2024-02

Sunday, Super Bowl Sunday and Cherry street seem emptied!Andolini is active and busy making pizza for the Super Bowl!Excellent!Will be back for more!garlic knots are just tasty!

Kasey Raia Stout

2023-09

Delicious! This pizza was really good. We were a little disappointed in the garlic knots, as they are fried and served in a puddle of oil, (plus they charge $2 for marinara or ranch to dip, when they already cost $8). Definitely not the best knots. However, the pizza was great. We got a half and half on a 14", but they do up to 20" pizzas. They also have "Roman style" pizzas that are square. They have a nice bar too with some local beers on tap. If you're looking for pizza in Tulsa, this is a great choice. They have multiple locations too.

Scott Mueller

2023-07

If you are traveling through Tulsa Oklahoma I highly recommend a visit to Andolini's Pizzeria. We did the Slice and salad combo. The Italian dressing was the best I've ever had. The mozzarella is fresh house made so the fried mozzarella was excellent. We had one slice of Demarco which is a great slice with great flavor. We tried the slice of the day which was a pickle slice and it was Great. I tried the house made Italian sausage and it was good as well. Nice beer list. I had the Ace Pink Guava which was tasty. We sat on the patio which had a nice breeze and ceiling fans. 92 out today so it was still warm but bearable. All slices had solid undercarriage and great crust flavor. Ton of great sounding pies on the menu.

Nicole Koh

2023-11

…More

Devin Bolton

2024-01

…More

Andrew Fisher

2023-05

I been to this location several times now and keep coming back for the best pizza! They have such a great selection of different pizzas you wont find at a national chain. The ingredients are so fresh and good also. I have more pizzas here than i dare to count and have yet to have a bad one, even the plain cheese pizza is amazing! They also have a great selection of beers on tap, including Marshalls, that go great with pizza. The outdoor patio is also nice on a spring or summer day. The staff and bartenders are all so friendly here. It is true, its hard to find parking being on cherry street, but its worth the trouble for this pizza. Go check them out!

Tom Kuriakose

2024-04

…More

stressed

2024-03

…More

E Z

2024-02

…More

Ethan Azwar

2024-03

…More

Amanda Banks

2023-06

It was a great place to eat with our three year old son, because the place isn't quiet, and they gave him a dough ball to play with. The special pizza (I can't remember the name but it has imported tomatoes and house made cheese and fancy olive oil and fresh basil...) was really good. I didn't realize how much the right tomatoes and a good sauce made a difference on a pizza. Same with the olive oil they add on top.Kid-friendliness: They will give your child a dough ball to play with if you request it, and the atmosphere isn't too quiet.

Bradley Garrett

2024-02

I'd give this place 5/5 stars if the atmosphere was something more than normal/usual/typical. I do enjoy normal restaurants but for a restaurant that got 5/5 stars on everything else, I don't think it's abnormal or wrong to want something more than the usual atmosphere of a normal Italian food restaurant/ pizzeria. This place is still perfect, I just think there's creativity that's not being seen/used in regards to the atmosphere. Again, this place is perfect, even the staff was perfect. Of course, the pizza (and side salad) was on point. This is why I always go to an Andolini's. Is it wrong to want something more from the only restaurants in town that are so high quality that the only thing to talk about in a review is how the atmosphere could have hypothetically been something more? We may never know. But if so, you can always find me at an Andolini's to tell me.Vegetarian options: As a vegetarian (not to be confused with a vegan) 364 days per year, I can say the Caesar salad and pizza slice I received couldn't have been better. I don't think there's a vegetarian section of/on the menu, but one can definitely just order items that don't naturally/usually come with meat on them. Try olives on your slice of pizza; they're delicious. I wish all restaurants functioned like this.Dietary restrictions: This place is very easy going when it comes to ordering. It never hurts to ask about dietary restrictions. Pizzerias often hear and work with dietary restrictions of customers.

Noelle

2023-05

We found this gem 7 years ago while driving from Illinois to Oklahoma City. We never forgot how amazing their pizza was (the one with the drizzled olive oil on it). We finally took another trip back to Oklahoma City so we planned our trip to arrive in Tulsa - just to eat lunch here! It is still AMAZING! We arrived at 11:00am when they opened, were greeted and seated immediately, and had a table near the bar area. We enjoyed mozzarella cheese sticks for an appetizer (delicious) and ordered the pizza (with the olive oil drizzled on top). We had waited so many years - and we were not disappointed! The Demarco Brooklyn Pizza was just as mouth-watering delicious as we remembered! The olive oil is very rich & tasty. You need to try this pizza as soon as possible! The parking lot is located in the back. There is also a covered outdoor patio area that is heated for extra seating during the cold months.Parking: Parking lot is located in the back of the building - see photo.

Brandon Alexander

2024-04

I recently visited Andolini's Pizza in Tulsa and unfortunately, my experience left much to be desired. Upon arrival, the lack of warmth and welcome from the hostesses was disheartening. Despite requesting a table with a bit more privacy, we were seated uncomfortably close to other diners, making for an awkward dining environment.What truly soured our visit was the indifferent attitude displayed by the manager when we attempted to address our concerns. It's disheartening when feedback falls on deaf ears.Despite the tempting aroma of the pizza, the overall lack of hospitality and dismissive attitude from the staff overshadowed any enjoyment.Update: After our disappointing visit to the original Andolini's Pizza location, we decided to give the downtown spot a chance, and it did not disappoint. The contrast in service and hospitality was stark. At the downtown location, we were immediately greeted with smiles and excellent service from the moment we walked in.The manager personally ensured our seating preferences were met, and our server, Jayden, provided attentive and thorough service throughout our meal. The food arrived promptly, hot, and fresh, and we thoroughly enjoyed our selections.It's unfortunate that the experience at the original location fell short, especially when the downtown spot demonstrated such excellence. If the original location had matched the level of service and quality we experienced at the downtown spot, they would have retained our business.

Tena Jones (Explored and Conquered)

2023-05

Our favorite place to eat every time we visit the area! I believe we've almost tried everything on the menu. Our most favorite appetizers to get is the garlic knots and bruschetta. The Stromboli's and Calzone's are already cooked to perfection with lots of goodies inside! We enjoy mixing things up a bit and ordering half/half pizzas. The crust is always amazing and there's always so many toppings on them. The atmosphere is great! I love how the owner, manager, chef or whoever he is will come around and check on all the tables through out the day. The kids love being able to see through the clear glass to watch them prepare all the pizzas. We've been to this location as well as the Tulsa one, and both are just as good! The parking here is hit and miss, we usually have to park a couple blocks down, and walk. At least the area is usually hopping and there's always a lot to do!Parking: There's very few spots in front of this location, you usually have to park a couple of blocks down and be prepared to walkKid-friendliness: They have a huge area where the kids can watch them prepare all the pizzas. They love watching them throw the dough into the air.

lindsey ellis

2024-04

…More

J Golden

2023-05

This was my first time here and I must say, I was THOROUGHLY IMPRESSED. The menu selection was extensive, the atmosphere was nice and the service was great.This isn't your typical Papa John's, Domino's and other little chain type pizza, no. This is the real deal stuff right here. Great flavors, ingredients are fresh and plentiful and even a small pizza is pretty damned big!We had a 14" pizza with (Italian sausage/beef/pepperoni), but before that, as an appetizer, it was Appian Way Meatballs. I highly recommend those if you're not ready to order your pizza yet. Amazing....!I'll be back for more....

Pat Muchmore

2024-01

I almost never write reviews, but I had to for this amazing place. This is one of those cases where five stars doesn’t feel like enough; five stars can just mean a very good place, and this is exceptional. It is some of the best pizza I’ve ever had all over the world, not just in Oklahoma. Very different and interesting toppings, fantastic beer selection, one of us got wine and that was very good too. Super friendly staff and our waiter was friendly and super helpful. If you can, I HIGHLY recommend it. Absolutely phenomenal.Vegetarian options: The Vegetarian pizza was fantastic.

Brittany Cox

2023-05

Yum Yum Yum! This place is delicious and the service is on point.We ordered two large pizzas, a bunch of appetizers, and fettuccine Alfredo to share with a large group. Everything was delicious. I loved their cider on tap as well (I can’t remember the name of it but it’s their best selling cider). I hear the gelato is good too but didn’t have room in my tummy for that :)

skyler thurman

2024-03

We ate here while we were in town on vacation. The food was great and the service was excellent.Dietary restrictions: They have a gluten free menu.

Saul S.

2023-07

…More

Matthew J

2024-02

The De Marco pizza is the best pizza, hands down in tulsa. My wife is from Connecticut, so she loves this style of pizza. On the flip side, I'm not a huge fan of many of the other pizzas. Their Andolini's beer, I can't remember the name, but it's awesome. The salads are great, too. They also sell dough if you are someone who has a pizza oven.

K FLYNN

2024-05

…More

Staci Higgins

2024-04

Pizza is always top notch! One of the best in the Tulsa, if not the best. We like to go on pint slice night. It’s a local beer paired with a big slice, which is often not on the regular menu. The price is right to try new things and you get to keep the glass!Parking: Cherry Street location parking lot can be limited depending on the time of day, but you can usually find spots on the street nearby.Kid-friendliness: Ask for the free dough! It’ll entertain kids until the meal arrives.