Old School Bagel Cafe

Whitney Schnook III (Madre de Bea)

2024-04

…More

Grant Wissler

2023-09

Great place for a delicious, inexpensive breakfast. We love coming for the bagel sandwiches! They’re always so good!

Idk_ PAPAS

2023-12

Went here for the first time, got two strawberry cream cheese bagels. The cream cheese was nasty, it did not taste like strawberry at all and looked like it was flavored with food coloring. The bagel was good, it was soft and crunchy which I really liked. However the cream cheese was gross and there was so much of it I had to wipe it off. Atmosphere was cute, and the customer service was okay. I can't say it was very special unfortunately, but the cream cheese really ruined the bagel for me. I don't know if that's a common occurrence but I wouldn't order it again. I'd recommend just getting a plain bagel with butter, the bagel was good!

Leann Farha

2022-05

Referring to location at 10946 N May: I've always loved Bagel Cafe. It's long been a favorite of my family and friends. However, my experience today was beyond disappointing. Not only was my entire order incorrect (ordered 5 bagels), but my food was inedible because the bagels were burned so bad. I didn't even want my bagel toasted to begin with! See attached pictures. The staff at the time were incredibly young and incompetent. I could barely understand the boy who answered the phone. I would not recommend this restaurant to anyone with the current staff. When I went to pick up my order, there was a customer yelling at one of employees for messing up his order. Another lady complained that she had been waiting on a bagel for 1 for over 30 minutes. I hope the Bagel Cafe I love takes the time to evaluate their employees and do better.

Mark Hiersche

2024-01

…More

Elaina Moore

2023-12

We had high hopes trying this place. But the bagels were very rubbery and hard to even chew. Very minimal meat. My bagel had one sliver of ham. Pricy for seeming to be microwaved ingredients. And I hate when cold coffee isn’t made with cold brew resulting in the coffee tasting burnt. Just not a place for us! The girl helping us was very friendly though.

Alli DelaRosa

2023-05

This is the best lox bagel I have ever had! it was amazing with sprouts. also the service was amazing, Michael was super friendly and checked in on us to make sure we enjoyed all of our food.

Katy Hawkins

2024-01

I love yalls bagels but whoever is in charge for the am crew is dragging yalls business down. I've tried to come atleast 3 times. I'm there when doors are supposed to be unlocked at 6am. Yall are never on time and never prepared for the morning rush. Like this morning was there at 6am doors still locked and only a basket of bagels were prepped and out . Guess I'll find other bagels or another business. Thanks for wasting people's time.

Jody

2021-05

Bagels are always good. I always get the plain ones sliced.Service needs works. I understand a Saturday mornings would be busy. The line would move more efficiently if the employees put a little effort in to the service. Of course all the employees )that I saw anyway) are younger. A few of them gave me the impression that they were just there to get a paycheck. Just to get the job done. No, “hi”, no smiles, no effort in making me feel like a valued customer. Apparently they don’t get the Connection that they have no paycheck without customers.Our bagels were cut way uneven- 3/4 on one side and 1/4 on the other. I mean I understand that they won’t be perfectly even but, really? All of them cut like this??I felt like going back there and cutting and bagging my bagels myself.The only reason I left 2 stars is because the bagels are good.

Dig B

2023-12

…More

She Does Taxes

2023-06

The food was great! Husband loves bagels but I love croissants. Found out you can easily replace the bagel with a croissant! #score

Keira

2024-04

…More

Larry W. Cornelison

2024-01

…More

Jordan Hoven

2023-07

Great as always! I was a kid in the 90s and absolutely loved new York bagel shop. I'm so glad they've been back after the hiatus when Manhattan bagel took over... Dark times those were. You cannot beat these bagels they're the absolute best! And I know the classics are great (cream cheese, pizza bagel) but seriously try one of the bagel sandwiches! You'll never go back to a regular sandwich once you do.

Jordin Kolman

2023-11

The bagels are delicious, but the service at this location is rough. I constantly have situations where I’ll order online, show up after 15-20 minutes and my order hasn’t even been printed out to start making yet (sometimes it’s before the quoted time, but the restaurant won’t be busy at all and they haven’t even started yet) and half the time when my order is ready somebody will just set it on the counter with the other orders that are waiting to be picked up even though I already told them I was there and I won’t even know my orders ready for another 5 to 10 minutes

Kristen

2021-05

I love love love this find! Since discovering it, I visit at least 2-3x a month out of being conservative. I wish I could go daily!My first visit, I had the Sooner Club- turkey, ham, Swiss, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes and onion. It was a great first start!Now- its Always the El Fuego- Chipotle seasoned pulled pork, jalapeños, onions, Jack cheese and spicy mayo ❤The restaurant itself is very clean and well maintained. The staff has always been friendly, even when they are busy..Also- just to note: Prices seemed a bit high at first but the quality is undeniable and hands down worth it!!

sharon copeland

2024-02

…More

Nick Scurra

2020-05

I've purchased many many times from day 1 at this location. The Bagels are outstanding, my sandwiches were terrible per my comparison. Wet soggy broken up pieces of turkey, terrible tomatoes and a piece of romaine lettuce that looked like it was cut to size. Like most now noy a one napkin in the bag.Very nice young man help me dur to being Handicapped, he was kind enough to bring out my order. I am grateful for this and showed my gratitude respectfully.

Vanessa Nguyen

2024-01

I am not sure why there are so many bad reviews. OSB is my favorite breakfast spot and I have been going for years. The bagels are yummy and the workers are kind. The owner is a really nice guy!what happened to the BLT?

Philena Livlanich

2023-10

The gf bagels was hard and drying. Couldn’t even eat it had to throw it away. You know it was bad when the worker said he ran it thru the toaster twice and it did t even toast. I want my money back.

Chelsea D

2023-06

The bacon egg and cheese bagel is great. I wish there was an option for uncured turkey bacon. I always add onions and mayo and have the bagel toasted with warm meat and melted cheese. The only caveat is the price. I will only order when they have a buy on get one free on Uber eats. Otherwise $16 for one bagel sandwich is pretty steep.

L. Leigh

2023-10

Late morning visit on a Saturday. I appreciated the seating beside the "fireplace." My bagel was fresh, and so was my coffee.

Jeffrey Langum

2023-08

Constantly out of menu items. The past three times I’ve tried to eat here they didn’t have multiple bagels, meats or ingredients shown on their menu. Feels like a run down, dying restaurant. Used to be good, but won’t be back again as it’s just a waste of time.

Keith Lashley

2023-05

I expected better.Myself I had the cuban. Unfortunately it was dripping in the mustard and it was too much. I like mustard but not dripping down my hand. Even removing some it was the overwhelming flavor.My lunch partner had a salad and he enjoyed it.This was my first visit for lunch.Maybe I should just get a bagle next time

Valentino Renou

2023-05

Incapable of getting even the most basic order right. Every time the office makes the unfortunate choice to eat here it's a gamble what we'll receive.The bagels also taste identical to the Braums breakfast bagels so I imagine they come from the same frozen foods company

Alex Wisdom

2023-05

Great breakfast/lunch spot. Good bagels with lots of tasty, fresh toppings to make sandwiches or flavored cream cheeses. They also have really good coffee.It's a local chain, and all the locations I've been too have similar quality.

MaryAnn C

2023-05

Expanded and now pretty huge and less intimate. Does have a couple of couches seated next to a faux fire place which was nice. A bit shocked at the prices. Two bagels and two coffes was close to $30. Still like it but not as much as I did a few years ago when it was smaller and cozier.

Nick Scurra

2023-05

Here we are again, what was for a fair amount of years exceptional now is nothing but simply below average. This Bagel easily challenged the New York Bagel, NOT ANY LONGER. OVER PRICED RUN BY PENNY PINCHES. The Mix is even different. I'm done.

Dawson Evans

2023-05

I never leave reviews on anything but felt like I needed to share. I have been coming to Old School Bagel for 5 years. I had the pleasure of meeting Michael on my most recent visit. He may possibly be one of the most upbeat and professional individuals I have ever met. His positive energy changed my mindset for the rest of the day. It is so rare to find people like these these days so I thought I would share.

Mandy G

2023-05

With the cost of prices going up, I about had a heart attack for how much it costs for a bagel with cream cheese. But....the employees were the nicest and genuine people, and for that, I would go back. Employees like that deserves our business. It's truly hard to find now days.