Cream of the Crop Ice Cream Shop

Mark Hazelwood

2024-02

…More

Tracie Saunders

2022-05

Absolutely amazing experience. In a time where staffs seem to be short tempered and stressed this was a little slice of heaven. Very clean,we were met with smiles,and the ice cream was made locally. There were flavors here I've never heard of. What a yummy end to our day.

Diana Salsberry

2023-05

Excellent! Love their home made ice cream! I had the Resee's swirl and my husband had the almond joy. Both were delicious 😋!

Sydney Arnold

2023-07

This is a wonderful ice cream shop! I have enjoyed everything I have tried here including the regular food. I highly recommend Cream of the Crop!

Dale Chan

2022-05

The service was very friendly. The ice cream was great, too. The shop is very small and that restriction limits their ability to have a large selection of flavors but we will definitely be back to try more.

USA ALLDAY

2024-02

…More

Matthew Buck

2021-05

I LOVE IT IT'S BEEN MINE AND MY WOMAN'S FIRST TIME SHOPPING 🛍 THERE AND THEY WERE VERY NICE AND FRIENDLY STAFF AND I ENJOY MY EXPERIENCE ORDERING OUR ICE CREAM 🍦 🍨 😋 AND WE LOVE HOW QUICKLY WE GOT SERVED AND WE WILL RECOMMEND YOU TO OUR FRIEND'S AND FAMILY 👪... AND WE WILL CONTINUE TO EAT THERE.... It's YUMMINESS and DELICIOUS and tasty 😋 😍 FOOD From, your SATISFIED CUSTOMER MATTHEW BUCK...

brad h

2024-04

…More

Tony Perez

2022-05

Really good ice cream surprised me.the workers are really nice.

Victor Santana Jr.

2023-08

Cream of the Crop Ice Cream Shop was a great stop for us when we wanted dessert passing thru Wakeman Ohio! We stopped here on a Sunday Evening for some ice cream overall, we both got a Fluster! They are similar to a Blizzard/McFlurry. They were delightful. I got Oreo, Reese Pieces, Brownies, and Cookie Dough in mine. The small was a perfect filling size also! The younger staff members there were super kind and nice! There was one older lady that overall... wasn't the kindest person, but I wont let the ruin the good experiance overall.I would recommend stopping here if you want a great little satisfaction for your sweet tooth!

Serenna Subjects

2023-08

They always have delicious new flavors, Keely, the owner is always there. Hands out coupons to different people in the community all the time. All the other staff are friendly too. Love them all.

Robyn Whalen

2023-10

Great little ice cream shop. Stopped by on our way back home. We both had sundaes and they were delicious!

T Mania

2021-05

This is a very nice quaint little mom & pop ice cream shop. Will be back. Eating place outside too.

Michele Purdy

2023-05

Yummy hands down favorite ice cream 🍦 shop! So many great flavors but I love the cyclones and chocolate covered strawberry 🍓 😋 yummy. Also the ice cream cakes are ridiculously good and is the only place our birthday cakes are coming from.

English By Vazquez

2024-04

…More

Brad Jarrett

2022-05

The chili cheese dog here is worth the stop alone but they also have great ice cream.

living simple

2021-05

This place is fantastic!! I ordered a reese birthday cake yesterday for the hubs and it was hands down the best ice cream cake we've ever ate!! My family was sad we only got the 6inch which was plenty for all 6 of us but next time we'll be getting a bigger size for left overs. If you need an ice cake skip the other places and order from here you will not be disappointed. Happy to have such good ice cream in wakeman.

Abby Castle

2023-07

Very amazing and creamy ice cream and nice workers, would definitely recommend.

Shelly Sterk

2021-05

Excellent ice cream! I had the soft serve chocolate cone, John had the Pretzel Caramel Chip Fluster and both were very good! The staff was very polite and helpful. We highly recommend this place for your ice cream fix!

Christy S

2022-05

This little ice cream parlor is an absolute gem - totally worth the trip even if it's out of your way. It's a very small storefront, but more cozy than anything else, and the counter service was friendly, helpful, and patient even as I needed to ask a million questions (do you have dairy free options, anything sugar free, do you sell pints, etc.).Most importantly, the ice cream is phenomenal - definitely the best hand dipped option around. The shop sells Nuhfer Premium Ice Cream, which is locally made in small batches out of Willard and which really does live up to the name "premium." It's richer and creamier than most other ice creams I've had, and the prices are a very, very good deal.If you are an ice cream fan, this one is definitely a "must visit" the next time you have a craving.

Jeremy H. (Jeremy)

2022-05

Ice cream was very good. Store is extremely small. Went to take My daughter there tonight, but there were a bunch of kids in there just hanging out and didn't want to try to go in because of the lack of space.

tricia hoover

2023-07

Excellent ice cream and the staff is super friendly!

Joann Drost

2023-10

Good ice cream, good price. Fast service. Small place

Sue Proctor

2023-08

Absolutely Awesome. Great tasting, good prices,and great employees. Recommended.

Larry H

2021-05

Heard good things about this place so we had to go check it out. Not only was the customer service great, the ice cream was cheap and super-delicious. It's a good alternative if you're looking for something a little different to some of the other ice cream places nearby in places like Huron or Vermilion, Ohio.

Charlene Brooks

2023-05

Just came from this adorable place! I highly recommend this very quaint and clean , wonderful tasting ice cream as well as the very nice and pleasant staff!

Jennifer Hirtzel

2023-09

Delicious ice cream and friendly staff. Thanks a bunch!!!

Keli Klingshirn

2021-05

The ice cream here is fabulous, the flavors are so rich and creamy. And the customer service is wonderful, everyone is very nice and accommodating. I love this place!

Rochelle Langdon

2023-07

Loved the strawberry cheesecake ice cream. Will be back worth the drive for.

gilbert cammarn

2023-08

Great place. Fresh ice cream great ice cream cakes and pies