Great American Cookies

Ian Rice

2022-05

Our go-to place for every birthday / celebration!!! If you haven’t had Great American Cookie, you are missing out! The cookies are the right amount of sweetness with the right amount of icing. My favorite personally is to have all fudge! I’ve tried other small cookies from here which always hit the spot when I need a pick me up. :) They also sell pretzels and lemonade!!!

Nichole Lindsay

2020-05

I ordered a cookie cake for today for my sons party. I ordered it to have a train and say happy birthday with their names on it. Had my aunt pick it up as i had a lot to do. 1st notice it only says happy birthday and their names. No train as i ordered. 2nd they spelled my son JOSEPHS name wrong. I called and they didnt even seem to care! The lady just seemed like oh well and!

baz0157

2023-09

Ordered for my sons bday. They spelled the name wrong, however fixed it on the fly and it look perfect. Location is in what should be a condemned mall, the floors are rippled and raised in areas. Be careful walking inside.

Jade Freiling

2024-01

…More

Dakotah Moore

2022-05

Always love the taste of the cookies, but I asked to have a pig on the cake and they made it white..... very disappointed hopefully it taste good just wanted simple like a cow or pig on the cake. And when I said something about have you ever saw a white pig when the lady asked if I was happy with it she just looked at me as if they just don’t care.... but they got their money for it so why would they care!

nikki bennett

2021-05

My parents brought up a cookie cake for my sister’s birthday. The cookie was as thin as a cracker, not even exaggerating. It tasted stale because it was so thin. Nothing like previous experiences with this company. I will recommend getting this cookie from the company in Columbus in the future.

Don Weekley

2021-05

I love this place and their cookies. However I ordered a cookie cake at 3:20 pm on Friday July 17 and was told it would be ready by 2:00pm July 18. Arrived there at 2:30pm and they have no cookie cake or even a record of the order. This of course ruined a Birthday Party!!!!

Kristina Stoner

2022-05

Love their cookies!! Been going there forever!! Their sugar cookies are the best!!

Jasmine D.

2021-05

I have been getting cookie cakes from here for years and have never had a bad experience.

Roger Scott

2022-05

Best ever and Cheryl is the best and shows all the girls how to decorate the cookies perfectly

stephanie Walker

2020-05

Terrible! I placed an order over the phone and when I went to pick it up, it was the wrong one. No apology or solution was offered! No way to run a business!

Brandi Hedrick

2021-05

Please update your online hours! Went to pick up my cake said you were open but it was closed!

Alyssa Potock

2020-05

I always order on-line and the selection is awesome! Taste is amazing, never disappoints

Linda/Larry Petrella

2020-05

I get this cookie for my sons birthday almost every yrar..and always for special occasions..my family loves them

SiouxBunnyBoo

2018-05

Clean store, friendly manager, friendly employees, fast, and always has cakes done on time.

Dream Big

2019-05

Great Church 2 reachimg out to the community through music

Justin Shay

2023-05

The best cookie cake around .

Kathy Thomas

2020-05

Yummy! Cookie was actually fresh

Kayla Rowland

2019-05

Very expensive. But good house stuff.

Kenneth Mushrush

2022-05

Great snack, decent price

Melissa Beaver

2020-05

Not bad

Suzanne K

2022-05

Still as good as it always was!!

Shannon Loveless

2019-05

Good food

Del Tha 510

2022-05

The best cookies around

Frank Davidson

2019-05

Great cookies great service

CATHERINE YOUNG

2018-05

Love it

Jennifer Matthews

2020-05

Best cookie cake

Jamal Poole

2019-05

Always good

Phillip Smith

2021-05

Great

Marci Jackson

2019-05

Good cookies