Rustic Cow Ice Cream Co.

Martha Boyd

2022-05

Generous servings of ice cream and toppings. Ice cream is cold and creamy and toppings are rich and satisfying. I had questions and the customer service was very friendly. Will be by again! Tried the peanut butter sundae and Mississippi Mud sundae.

Tim Gallant

2023-08

A local gem! Great ice cream, pizza, and a friendly staff. I love that we can call ahead and order our pizza, and it is ready when we arrive. So convenient and such a fun place to go. The flavor of the week is also something my family anticipates and tries every time.

Anna Deckard

2023-10

Best ice cream around! And the hot foods are super delicious. Always appreciate that we can call ahead and order on our lunch break and they have it ready for us in no time, no matter how many separate orders we have.

Kole Baumgartner

2023-09

Ordered a peach sundae since I get that almost every time I go there, this time I got extra peaches because it just wasn’t enough last time, no problem. I get to the window and receive my sundae and it looks like they didn’t put any extra peaches in it at all, so I asked nicely if they could put a little more in since I paid for extra. She said she put extra in it and that they don’t give out extra for free. Which is completely understandable, but I respectfully said it just doesn’t look like extra and looks the same as what I got last time without even ordering extra. and she proceeds to say “the extra might be under the whip cream” which it was not at all😂 so I ended up just leaving because I didn’t want to make it a big deal. I just expected receiving what I ordered and for better customer service. Super unfortunate since me and my family go here often.. but I don’t think I will me returning after this, I shouldn’t feel disrespected as a customer, especially when I’m being respectful to them.

Madison Shultz

2023-10

The sandwich I had was great, heath cappuccino mixer was good, but my partner and I both agreed we didn't get any coffee taste.

kaylynne koepplinger

2023-05

Their Ice cream is good, but Ive been here a lot of times and half the time my ice cream is never right and neither is our food. Everything usually taste good but its the little things that matter. Got a Rocket and asked for a hot fudge tunnel. Got charged for it but never put it in the ice cream. Ive been charged for countless things I have asked for but never received.

Alisa Herman

2022-05

What an improvement since the last owner! While his staff was always friendly, I felt like Idrew the short straw if I had to order from him. These owners are very friendly. We got a lot of ice cream for a very reasonable price. They also seem to have more options for hot food than the previous owner. Even though the line is very long at times it moves quickly. Staff comes out to take your order when lines get long and that really seems to help. We have now been here several times and our experience has been consistently great. I feel very lucky to have such a nice ice cream spot in our small town.

Elizabeth Kingsley Bedinger

2023-08

Wish they had had the actual blueberries in a rocket. I settled for a sundae but it was blueberry syrup not actual blueberries. I like everything else though and realize the flavors are seasonal.

Adam Seem

2023-05

Took my daughter to have lunch. Well worth the drive from Findlay. The food was great and the strawberry shake was perfect with strawberry chuncks just the way I like it. The staff was very friendly. Will definitely go back

AJ Everything

2023-06

They have the best ice-cream and pizza. Their other food and things and very good but the pizza is the best.

Scott Ballinger

2023-11

The melts here are to die for and if I'm honest all the food is absolutely great!!

Henry Daigle

2023-05

Very nice mom and pop stop for food. We absolutely love the pulled pork and mac n cheese. Definitely need to stop and try.

Connie Hoffer

2022-05

After 3 visits, can confirm now that the service & quality of product has been consistently excellent & it's by far a better value for your dollar than many of the other local small town ice cream shops.

carissa bonham

2022-05

My dogs really enjoy the pup cups that they offer for the furry family members. Its vanilla ice cream and a dog biscuit in a cup. I think my dogs will probably be begging me to come back here.

Elizabeth Kingsley

2022-05

Excellent ice cream and love the new selection now they have new owners. Food and drinks good. Love the pulled pork mac and cheese.

Emma Parkins

2023-05

It has reallly good pizza and bread sticksIt has one of the best vanilla ice cream

K K

2022-05

Amazing place! Local ice-cream and the nicest staff, what more could you want ?

Joe Wardzala

2023-05

Love the ice cream, great service!

Mike Von Stein

2023-11

Nice local place. Favorite of the grandkids.

Matt Maclees

2022-05

Very good ice cream and nice staff peanut butter and oreo shake with extra peanut butter is to die for

Daniel Schulte

2023-09

What a cozy little ice cream eatery. And tasty too.

Brady Blankemeyer

2023-07

Great pizza, great Ice cream and great service

Ray Sparrowe

2022-05

Great place for soft served ice cream and pizza and sandwiches!

Geneva

2022-05

Great friendly fast service prices and ice cream

Big F gangster shit

2022-05

Best ice cream ever hands down my favorite place

brad meyers

2022-05

Food was ok suppose to give us a shake was a malt instead long line to get food

Dean Burkholder

2022-05

Great ice cream and friendly service!

Tonnia Young

2022-05

Great ice cream (real creamy & great flavor)

KC Plumbing and Rooter

2022-05

Good stuff, it's great they have coffee too, delicious

Roy Warnecke

2022-05

Good ice cream and and great service