Red Eye Pie and Frozen Fantasty's

Greg Anthony Bowman

2024-04

This place is amazing. Staff is beyond friendly, and so very helpful. The food is absolutely amazing. We get their pizza at least once a week! We get the ice cream at least three times a week! You'll never regret stopping here whether it's for lunch or quick ice cream snack!Best place to visit when taking a Jeep ride!

Jayme

2024-03

…More

Stephen Shankster

2023-09

Great pizza experience! This is probably one of the better tasting pizzas in the Toledo area. Many eclectic pizza toppings that you don't always find at the chains. The logo and branding are fitting for the fun vibe. And even better, you can top off your pizza night with some quality ice cream all in the same place.

Jason

2023-10

Overall a very good pizza . Sauce walks the right rope between sweet and Italian ans was evenly dispersed . The cheese was plentiful and provided an anchor to the crust so when you take a bite all the cheese and toppings stay put instead of sliding off in one clump . Dough is chewy but not tough . Will be back for sure

James Adlington

2024-04

…More

Mark T

2023-08

Great locally family-owned ice cream/ pizza shop tucked away in a quiet neighborhood. The pizza is handmade and doesn't taste like one of those big franchise pizza shops. Definitely quality in the product. Their ice cream treats are great and my son loves the mud Sunday.

Grant G

2023-07

Great ice cream, great service, excellent ZA 🍕 - glad we got a chance to stop in. Will be by anytime we’re in the area!

Sandra

2023-07

Malts are great. Cones are generously made - got a small and it was huge. Soft serve is Tofts - very creamy - quality product. Friendly staff. Excellent addition to Oregon. Stopped by after reading reviews and also want to support this family after hearing about their tragic loss. Anxious to try the pizza next time. Will definitely be back!!

John Hairabedian

2023-08

Very good pizza and ice cream and great prices

Sean Granger

2023-09

Best Ice-cream and SPECIALTY pizza in Oregon, Ohio!We love our lost brothers and support them even when they are no longer with us physically. RIP Max and Ben, you are missed 🙏❤️

buck7567

2024-03

…More

Jessica Wunderlin

2023-05

The ice cream was delicious and fairly priced, my kids said they give it 2 thumbs up. There were multiple tables to sit down at and enjoy your treats, the area looked clean and taken care of. We'll definitely be back and we will have to try the pizza next.

Rick Bradfield

2023-05

I ordered pizza today and experienced great customer service from the owner and the pizza was incredible! I highly recommend red eye pie and suggest you give them a visit. P. S. The ice cream is great too... Keep up the great work. We are happy to have such a great business in our area!

Laurie Koch

2023-05

It was Fantastic 👏! 😁🍕🍦🍨 The whole family went we all had something different. Everyone loved ❤ what they ordered!We're definitely going back!So much better flavor ice cream 🍦 than the Dairy Depot by 100%! And much better portions and prices!WITHOUT all the waiting!♡: )🍦🍕 💕💕

Big Jon

2023-05

This place rocks! I’ve been eating their pie since the food truck days. The beef pepperoni is awesome, Mya’s Mediterranean is amazing. Always a friendly smile!

Mike Black

2023-06

Unbelievable service. So friendly and fast. Good pizza good ice cream. I really love this place

Vince Spallino

2023-05

Love this place! The pizza is way better than I expected and the ice cream is creative and delicious. Highly recommended!

Lewis Mccrory

2024-04

…More

Kim S

2023-06

Great pizza, great staff. Give this place a try, you will not be disappointed!

Brittany

2023-07

Both the Ice cream and Pizza were delicious!!! Will be back!

Renee Harrington

2023-05

Friendly. Reasonable prices. Only got ice cream this time. Sad that they didn’t have sorbet yet

Denise Ray

2023-07

Average ice cream or ice milk. Not as good as other places. Quick service and convenient

Garrett Mallett

2023-05

Kids absolutely love this place. Can’t beat the pizza, and a swirl with sprinkles is my go to.

Kayle Bollin

2024-03

…More

Joan Martin

2023-08

Excellent service and quality Ice cream.

Don Hooligan

2023-05

We love the cheese pizza slices and the chocolate ice cream.

Sara Treen

2023-08

Good prices and good ice cream choices

oNlyOnenoE

2023-05

Buffalo chicken bacon ranch10 out of 10

John Doe

2023-05

Good food great ice cream great prices vast quantities

Elizabeth Ginnett

2024-01

Only went by it didn't go in