Pete's Cafe

4.4 (142)

115 W Mansfield St, New Washington, OH 44854
(419) 492-2106

Claim this business

Restaurant
Bar
Cafe

Service options

  • Outdoor seating

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Kevin Fourman

2023-07

We went out for lunch and entered the small town eatery about 1:15pm. While online hours posted are 8am to 10pm, out of towners should be aware that they are closed 2-4pm…so don’t plan on a late lunch. We were greeted with, “…you know we close at 2?” This seat-yourself location had maybe 4-5 other patrons, so we felt comfortable in being able to meet that time line…and the waitress did tell us about their special.This is a locally we’ll know bar/restaurant with sandwiches, subs & pizza at a VERY reasonable price. Food was tasty & served quickly—even with a smile—after our initial abrupt welcome.Food came, we paid, and were walking out the door by 1:51pm. Made it.

Bud Knight

2023-09

…More

Ray Lester

2020-05

Really nice people and excellent food, good place to watch sports, not crowded and relaxing place

Denise Ray

2023-11

Stopped in when passing through. Meat a little scarce on the sub but bread and cheese was delicious. It did what I needed. I’d go back. Affordable and staff very kind

ray weithman

2023-05

My wife and I are always in search of a great pizza. We were in the in the area and had to try a pizza from Pete's Cafe which was highly recommended from some of our friends. The staff were friendly and courteous. The pizza was ready on time. We enjoyed the pie. It is all round a good solid pizza, great sauce. The toppings were not over abundant. I like a thin crust, bit if you like your pizza a little more on the doughy side you will enjoy it.Reasonably priced. Great fun atmosphere. Highly Recommend you try Pete's.

William Lawson

2023-05

Smallest chicken wings i ever seen in my life! im on keto diet so I got normal chicken wings and they were breaded and still smaller than my finger nail.

Michelle Messmer

2021-05

Amazing atmosphere and amazing food. The best pizza dough around. The big Tenderloin is good the fresh cut fries are delicious. The drink are yummy. Waitresses are super nice.

Amy Nedolast

2020-05

Best pizza for miles. If you are from out of town and want to take a country drive, well worth the trip. Towners know how great it is!

Dan Davis

2021-05

Excellent food! Full bar with historic wood working. Updated juke box and a selection of good craft beer as well. Love it!

Kati Kisling

2022-05

They have the BEST pizza!! So good! I love this place, one of my favorites!! :)

Jennette Barcus

2021-05

This is a nice little bar in a small town. The people were all very nice, chill atmosphere, and the bartender was accommodating with our weird drink requests 👍😁🍻

Chris Lee

2020-05

I had the privilege to try one of Pete's Cafe' pizzas last night and i have to say it was one of the best pizzas i have ever eaten. Great job and i am back today for lunchto try a sub lol. .

Viper Driver

2022-05

Drove a fair distance to get here and was not disappointed. Service was great. Supreme pizza was. Outstanding 👍

Joseph Knudsen

2024-05

…More

Robert Schock

2023-05

Love a place where you can come in and sit down for twenty minutes before you ever see a server.

Linda Campbell (Sassy)

2018-05

Its a little family bar good place to bring kids . For a country nite out for big big burger good fris .And love there blt sub tosted.

Jeanne StJohn

2022-05

All 4 of us had a sandwich and fries.Good service, friendly waitress and good food.

Mackenzie Crall

2018-05

Nice atmosphere on weekends, full bar, pool tables. Wish there were more food selections, however they do serve breakfast, lunch and dinner.

Tabitha Price

2022-05

Did not listen to my order at all drove 30 minutes to get there and have to wait for a remake and all I get is "I'm sorry". First time, and last time.

Denise Donnersbach

2023-05

…More

Dani Hawk Acrylic Arts

2023-05

…More

Africo Cherubin

2023-05

Charged me $20 for a small white pizza that looked like breadsticks

Lenny Arnold

2018-05

The food was really good! Great place to play, and see a live band.

Suzi Sumerau

2019-05

This is a bar that sells food that is ok at best. Their business comes from the local party crowd that wants to drink

Jon Appleby

2019-05

Awesome food and service, they got free beer tomorrow

James Candel

2019-05

Great pizza at a good price and the beer is the cold

Michael Obringer

2018-05

Good selection of craft beer. Chicken Chipotle pizza is the best.

Mike A

2020-05

Nice quiet small town bar good selection of domestic and import beers

Reegan Burger

2024-03

…More

Dave Stadler

2018-05

Great pizza! Laid-back local place.

Opening Hours

Monday 8 AM-10 PM
Tuesday 8 AM-10 PM
Wednesday 8 AM-10 PM
Thursday 8 AM-10 PM
Friday 8 AM-10 PM
Saturday 4-10 PM
Sunday Closed

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet