Pizza Alley

4.6 (173)

10579 OH-4, Mechanicsburg, OH 43044
(937) 834-2209
pizzaalley.goshenlanes.com

Claimed
Pizza restaurant
Ice cream shop

Service options

  • Outdoor seating

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Jessica McCombs

2024-04

…More

Nick Wisse

2024-02

…More

Ann Weindel

2022-05

So, normally food is good and cooked to order, but today, 20 min after I ordered, I got a call saying they were out of what we wanted. My daughter managed to choose something else, but it wasnt her first choice. I asked for a pepperoni pizza with toppings on top of the cheese, and my daughter got an Italian sub with no tomatoes. My daughter's sub had tomatoes and the pepperonis were under the cheese. I don't think anyone was listening today.

Gia Gill

2022-05

Great place to take my Kiddos to go eat.. just wish it were a little less expensive. With just me the hubby and two little ones it was about 70 to 80.00 spent.. but will be going back cause the kids love the environment and love to sit down and eat there together ❤

Nastassia Cook

2023-05

We booked our son's birthday party with them. They were amazing. We also like their food better than most places in Mechanicsburg.

Steve Anderson

2023-10

…More

Dennis Zimmerman

2024-03

…More

Bruce Howe

2023-05

Always good stuff. Great grill food. Outstanding pizza. Add bowling 🎳 and it's delightfulVegetarian options: SaladKid-friendliness: Game roomBowling

Wendy Cromer

2023-05

Haven't been to the Pizza Alley in years and was in the area and stopped in and was not disappointed! My friends and I had subs and they were awesome!

Lewis Hermann

2023-05

Classic Italian sub was generous, good deal for under $7. Served I've cream also. Choice of inside or outside service. Walk up window.

Angie Frost

2023-05

…More

Jennifer Shafer Widay

2020-05

Great food, reasonably priced and very friendly staff. I like to see teenagers given an opportunity to work and pizza alley does just that. Best milkshakes in town.

Logan Dillon

2022-05

Awesome food great pizza great environment to chill and hang out and have a good time

Joshua Fraley

2020-05

Great owners. Very well maintained small bowling alley. Food is great priced. Only place and Best place in town for ice cream. Awesome Staff

Lavern Zimmerman

2022-05

Food was good and hot when we got it. The wait was a bit more than i expected but is the norm on most restaurants anymore.Would definitly reccomend.

Terry Hartman

2019-05

Best pizza in Champaign county. It's a great place to stop if you travel Route 4. It's way more than a bowling alley. Great service.

Angela Hillyard

2023-05

I absolutely loved this pizza n ice cream was a bonus!!!! Love the staff!!! Worth a drive

Daniel Hays

2021-05

I usually like there pizzas, but not this time it was awful. Hardly any sauce on it.ok I ordered from them again and pizza was awful. It wasn't even done. And they got the order completely wrong!!!!@

Charlie Workman

2018-05

A niceplace for keglers! Bowling leagues are competitive! They also have a very good restaurant, specializing in pizza, subs and other sandwiches, hand dipped ice cream, sundaes and shakes!

Jacob McKee

2023-05

Very nice staff.. good quality pizza.

J Fisher

2022-05

Only had their wings and they were delicious. I've heard their pizza is great.

Brad Carter

2023-05

…More

Darth Sever

2021-05

Always excellent, definitely a must have when you're in Mechanicsburg. Best pizza in town hands down

Erica Herron

2023-05

Always delicious soft-serve and hand-dipped ice cream!

Amanda Herriott

2023-05

…More

Rachell Wild

2017-05

Great food. Great workers. Could be faster on certain days but other than that great place to eat.

stephanie vandyke

2022-05

Great food, and very cheesy pizza

Tom H

2020-05

Awesome food awesome people!! And the family that owns it!! Your not going to find a better one that's for sure!!

Seth

2021-05

Great food and pizza! Even delicious ice cream for dessert

Mark Clay

2022-05

Had pizza, milkshakes, and curly fries all we awesome. Will definitely return

Opening Hours

Monday 10:30 AM-9 PM
Tuesday 10:30 AM-9 PM
Wednesday 10:30 AM-10 PM
Thursday 10:30 AM-10 PM
Friday 10:30 AM-11 PM
Saturday 10:30 AM-11 PM
Sunday 3-9 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet