Red Angel Pizza

Sarah Hummon

2024-01

Delicious pizza, ordered carryout. Tried the thin crust 13" taco pizza and a 16" hand tossed 3 topping ( pepperoni, mushrooms, and bacon). There were plenty of toppings and cheese! A bit pricey, but worth it. Will definitely be going back. They have a large menu of items other than pizza as well.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust available

Ben Brown

2023-11

This is a cool home town pizza shop. I ordered 2 pizzas after hearing a number of people raving about their food. The staff was friendly and the service was good. There were a generous amount of toppings and the cheese was good. I really didn't care for the crust at all. It seemed to have no flavor. My son ate the other pizza and he loved it, said it was very good. I wish I'd have tried his. Something seemed off about mine.

Christy Beitler

2024-01

We came on a Saturday night to dine in and there was only one other family already eating and only one other clean table to pick from to sit down. Only one person answering the phone, helping the carry out orders coming in so we didn't get our order taken for over 20 mins (understandable) but the person should have alternated jobs. The person proceeded to clean all the dirty tables before taking our order. Could have had our food cooking first and then clean the tables. Our appetizer came without the sauce and we couldn't get her attention to get the sauce so we just ate it without it. No refills until we stood in line with the carry out people to ask to them. First time every being there as we were there to see the Christmas Cruise we heard about. Maybe we picked a bad night, not sure. We kindly ate our food, had to wait at the desk again for someone to bring our bill and left a tip and left.

damien smith

2024-04

…More

Jasper Higgins

2024-03

…More

Brett Meyer

2024-04

…More

Amanda DeBaillie

2023-11

…More

Brad

2024-02

…More

Thomas Schilb

2023-05

Grew up on original Red Angel in the 80’s. It was a family tradition on Saturday nights. I’ve tried 3 pizzas from here recently. One was very good. Crust was tender and bubbly, decent quality mozzarella, plenty of toppings. Could’ve used a dash of salt over the cheese. The other two were not the same. Tough crust, undercooked cheese and minimal toppings. I think the recipe is the same but the consistency of the “making” could be much improved. I’ll try again eventually.

Steven Bowers

2024-04

…More

Shirley McKeen

2023-05

My husband and I ate here for the first time today. The pizza was probably the best we have ever had! The service was fast. And the servers were very nice. Checked on us a few times to ask if we needed anything. We will definitely go back !

Mr. Tinkertrain

2022-05

Service is fast and friendly. The pizza is a good pie. The crust is a little too chewy for my liking. Sauce is good and I wish they would add a little more (next time will request extra sauce). Plenty of toppings and I love that it is cut into squares. Price is decent for a small town pizza shop.

Stacy Gilbert

2023-05

Staff very rude. Drove over an hour to try this place but walk in and told over a 45 minute wait and cannot wait there. That it's first come first serve and can't save a tableResponseTelling people to get out you can't wait wow. Also I never swore and you. So thanks for the threat! No worries we would never recommend your restaurant to anyone.

Gerry Davis

2020-05

Great sour dough pizza crust. Nice atmosphere pleasent staff. No free refills:(

stacy roof

2023-08

…More

Logan Hobbs

2023-05

Great pizza! They took on 18 people at once in our group and did well. The pizza tasted great. Well worth the trip!

Danielle strouse

2023-05

…More

Keith Feller

2024-04

…More

Max Begley

2023-06

…More

Linda McMahon

2023-05

Good food. Service is a little off at times when they are busy. Staff not well trained on computer check out

Mike Pennington

2020-05

I grew up as a boy on Red Angel pizza and to me it was the best anywhere. I have enjoyed it for years, but now something isn't the same with their pizza. It's not the same as I remember. The pizza was good but the recipe has changed and it's so heartbreaking. Not the same Red Angel

Jaime Handy

2019-05

The Grinders were Amazing!Tasted just like the Originals that we use to get when we were kids. Cute place and felt at home. Service was great.Eric and I enjoyed ourselves talking abt the Old Red Angel when we were kids. LolThanks Kari. Now I know where to get the best Grinders in town just like they use to be.YUM!😀😘💚💋🍀

Mitch Franklin

2019-05

Thought we would try red angel pizza in Hicksville tonight for the 1st time, knowing we would be just as busy as anyone else ordering pizza for supper the night before a holiday. When I ordered it, I was told there was a 35 minute to wait. I showed at about 30 minutes into that 35 minute, was told they still werent done, at what was then 50 minutes after I ordered and still no pizza chose to leave. Again I know you guys were busy tonight, but an update in that 15 minutes would have been nice. We'll have supper somewhere else tonight.

Trevor Berry

2019-05

Some of the best local pizza I've had. Comprehensive menu with loads of choices. Take out is great but if you find yourself with some time, I recommend eating inside the restaurant. Cozy small town pizza parlor.

Julia Gross

2023-05

Best pizza around. They have gluten free pizza.They also have chicken, fish, sandwiches. Grinders (subs) all kinds of sides, and much much moreParking: Right in front of the store.Free parking in this town.Kid-friendliness: They love kids here.Have a kids menu also.And soft serve ice cream.

Ruthann Warren

2022-05

We ordered a extra large pizza with ground beef and extra cheese and cheese bread. Took so long to get it and it tasted terrible.the crust was hard and the cheese bread didn't taste good either.it was a waste of good money and we are done with this place.

Tannie Loucks (Ree)

2023-05

The last few pizzas we have ordered have had a tough crust (like maybe they have a new person overworking the dough?) and you really have to hunt to find an onion or pepper...

Anita Boone

2021-05

This is hands down the best pizza around! The sauce is delicious and different (in a good way). As long as they're open I'll make the drive from Fort Wayne.

Stephanie Elliott

2019-05

Pizza is always great but so is their other menu items. My family ordered cheeseburger baskets and they got the spot. Good price.

Mark Rodes

2021-05

Even after 20 minutes after baked before we could eat (carry out) the pizza was still very good. Order taker was very helpful.