Sterling's Amish Deli

James F

2023-05

Came here for lunch with a friend, it was a wonderful experience. We were greeted when we came in, our order was probably taken and the food came out rather quickly. Everyone was friendly and the fries are to die for. I would definitely recommend stopping in and grabbing a sandwich and some fries.Parking: There is a public parking area across the street that has 3 hour parking

Ashley Thorn

2024-02

…More

Caitlyn Luckhardt

2024-01

The past two days I've ordered the BLT sandwich. I was not expecting a triple-decker BLT! Absolutely delicious! I ordered online and it was ready within 15 minutes. There is a ton of bacon on this sandwich, too so the price is reasonable!I'm excited to try everything else! Thanks!

Lara Beltz

2022-05

Great fresh food! The salads are huge and the fries are the best I’ve ever had. The kids meal has plenty of food. Great service with great people!

Cheryl Wagoner

2024-03

…More

Lily Kramer

2023-05

when i say this place is doing the LORDS work… the food was everything. the employees were everything. the corn dogs saved my life like actually restarted my heart i can see better and breathe clearer i feel like a new woman

Amber Heller

2023-07

…More

Carol Pfeiffer

2024-05

The footlong sub had LOTS of meat. Warmed up bread bun, yummy.Parking: World biggest wooden horse and buggy on display in the front yard.Kid-friendliness: Nice rock and roll.Wheelchair accessibility: Easy access.

Mattea W

2023-07

…More

Amanda Harrington

2022-05

Will be coming back soon for the blt! They use good bacon and it's huge! It's worth checking out if you need quality deli meats and cheese also. The workers were very kind and attentive also

Casey Cannady

2024-01

…More

Jeff Risser

2023-06

…More

Trev Lee

2023-05

If you're in the Bowling Green area andlove a good sandwich, Sterling's Amish Deliwill knock your socks clean off. My wife swears these are the only sandwiches she could ever eat now!

Emma

2023-06

Wow!! Just had this for the first time and it was phenomenal, perfect temperature and cooked just right on the burger, lots of onion and mushrooms on it. The cheese curds were very good! Keep up the good work.

Mark Stratmann

2023-12

Fantastic food in a fun small shop, chicken and noodles on Wednesday is hard to beat comfort food!

Steven Speck

2024-03

…More

Rachel Siebeneck

2024-01

…More

Mariah Deck

2023-08

…More

Brooke M

2023-05

Food was fine, but nothing to brag about. My Sprite tasted very watered down though. Staff was friendly and service was good. I think using the term “Amish Deli” is a bit disingenuous as it seemed like any other sandwich shop, but with pre made items for sale from Holmes County. The whole place looked like it could use a good cleaning, and we had to keep swatting flies away from us as we ate. Overall, we weren’t displeased, but I wouldn’t return. Not sure why this place was rated so highly.

B K

2022-05

Service and food was great. They don't have a public restroom though. And not being from this direct area and getting ready to drive 30 mins home we had to find a restroom. I had children with me so didn't want to take them into a bar. The gas station looked like it was closed, and thankfully it was not since it was really cold out. Even though the gas station wasn't far it just really sucked looking for the bathroom in the cold.

Jenessa Headings

2021-05

The Atlanta Dog with coleslaw, chips, and potato salad is delectable!! 😋

Scott Wilson

2021-05

The Chicago dogs are amazing and the fries are something you have to experience. I personally think they are the best fries I've eaten anywhere. Also tried the chicken tenders and they don't disappoint at all. Definitely going back to try the Ruben.

Austin Herrig (Black Swamp Customs)

2023-12

…More

Austin Clise

2023-08

…More

Jacqueline Durst

2022-05

We hit Sterlings with a 30 person delivery order, on a Saturday night, during a busy weekend & they still knocked it out of the park. Communication from the owner was on point. I highly recommend ordering the Reuben & the cheese curds!

Michele Stricklen

2020-05

Delicious! Used to love the old amish deli. The reuben and club were just as good as we remembered. Cheese curds also recommended 🤤. Fresh cut fries! The inside remodel looks great. Staff was very nice. Would recommend ordering ahead if you're in a rush as everything is made to order and it seems they get busy but it's worth it.

Brianna Lowe

2023-05

Love this place, so happy they’re open after repair!! Amazing food and really kind owners. They deserve all the business!

Ken Materni

2023-12

…More

Karissa K

2020-05

Absolutely wonderful food paired with a welcoming environment! The sandwiches are delicious and very reasonably priced. Also make sure to grab a slice of elderberry pie- you won't be disappointed!

Jacob Egan

2021-05

Ordered the Notorious BLT, Jarlsberger, fried cheese curds, and fried Oreos.Everything was prepared fresh and the food and service were fantastic.Come and support a local and family owned business serving a wide variety of great food!