Betty Kaye Bakery

ReAnn ReAnn

2024-04

We bought a cherry pie last week. Delicious! My daughter is in love with the brownies. It just so happened that we were coming through Carrollton county again.... So a stop at this yummy bakery was a must. My daughter loved the cupcake, today. I highly recommend and we will definitely be back! 🙂

Vanetta Schrader

2023-09

OMG! Stopping here is a MUST!!! The Blondie Brownie was to die for. I definitely recommend the Blondie, the peanut butter, and the turtle brownies! And the cream horns...oh my! This little bakery was phenomenal!

Moonhunt Media, LLC

2023-11

I ordered a cake a couple of weeks ago, and picked it up today: a cherry chocolate birthday cake with lilac coloured buttercream, lavender sugar sprinkles, white roses and a “happy birthday” monogram, with a dozen cupcakes to match. The lady who took my order said that she didn’t know if the baker would be willing to do all of this, and I had no idea what to expect. We had our party this afternoon. The cake(s) was delicious, delicate, beautifully elegant and just what I had imagined in my cracked noggin. The birthday girl (a middle aged woman who claims to be five) was delighted to tears; she said that she’s never received such a wonderful cake.Almost as impressive as the cake itself, was that it was $15 less than what I had budgeted.This is the third time I’ve ordered a birthday cake from Betty Kaye’s, and they never disappoint. So lovely. Thank you!

James Swaim

2023-11

My work crew and I were working in the alley behind the shop, and the owners were nice enough to invite us in and get some sweets before the store even opened. Everyone was super nice and polite. Very welcoming and long-lasting business.

Michael Scott

2023-10

The cutouts were amazing but then we got to the brownies and they were so dry i had to chug a water after eating half. I understand that you may not be able to sell all the brownies you make in one day but make a smaller batch. The brownie i was given today is shocking due to its state of being hard along with the icing and dry. These used to be the best brownies ever and i dont know whats going on. Its been like this the past couple of times i've went but i continued to come back in hopes they would be soft and like they used to be but today was ridiculous. The worker is super friendly and very helpful only bad thing is the brownies. I come to bakeries to get baked goods to have for a day or two so i want them fresh, why would i want 3 day old brownies when i bought them a couple hours prior?

Caleb Devitt

2023-12

…More

Melissa Sheldon

2024-04

…More

Wilbert Werling

2024-01

…More

J.R. Bockoven

2023-05

The brownies at the wedding reception were phenomenal!Many guests complemented us on your brownies. Thank you for everything and keep up the great work!

Frances Gundrum

2022-05

The best home town bakery for miles and miles. The most awesome brownies anywhere! They ship and you won't be disappointed. The best of cakes banana flips cream horns and nut horns you ever had, ever!!!

Rusty Funkhouser

2023-05

Good stuff but they have banker’s hours. 9-5. Whoever heard of a bakery opening at 9 AM. They definitely don’t want you to get bake goods on the way to work.

annette thegreat

2018-05

The "cut out" cookies at the Betty Kaye Bakery are a soft but firm sugar cookie with a thin layer of colorful decorator frosting. If I lived in the area, I would bring several dozen to every family and community gathering! I was delighted with the hint of lemon and the wonderful crumbly texture as I chewed. They do not form a "pasty" feel or texture in your mouth. I also tried & highly recommend the pecan tarts, tea cookies and mint frosted brownies. Everything seemed to be priced appropriately for the quality. $0.60 per cookie in March 2018. Discounts are given when you buy or more.

Chelsea Berardinelli

2016-05

They did our wedding cupcakes. I never got to try one but they looked amazing. Prices aren't bad. Only negative thing was we paid and ordered our flavors early and I ordered banana specifically for my son and daughter. They called the day before we picked them up and said the ingredients had gone bad. It was a little frustrating that it hadn't been thought of before. Overall, we were happy.

Jennie Pegram

2019-05

If you are driving through town you MUST STOP! These are the most delicious brownies you will find anywhere. My favorites are the chocolate, PB and blondies! I always make a special trip into town just to stock up on my sweets!

Christy Winter

2020-05

I had a cappuccino chocolate chip muffin and it was outstanding! If I lived nearby I’d stop by Betty Kaye’s and try more of the pastries! The coffee was good too!

Ris Salazar

2019-05

We came in and got the apricot & cheese kolochis as well an an apple turnover like thing. They were not great. They kolochis had little flavor and the turnover thing was average.

Rob Shelley

2021-05

Pumpkin spice...chocolate ....creme sticks... donuts...breads....what CAN'T Betty Kaye do fabulous??? The answer..NOTHING...they make the best baked goods and once again I'll say it..NO ONE does it better than Betty Kaye..NO ONE...😎☝#1

Taralynn Rouse

2020-05

AMAZING!! They are super easy to work with and knew exactly what I wanted for my wedding day! The detail was amazing and cake and cupcakes were DELICIOUS!

Susan Williams

2018-05

I've been going there for years, I love that bakery!! The staff is AWESOME and. Jamie Burkhart waited on me today and was her usual great self!!

Barb Devitt

2023-05

Great baked goods. Best brownies anywhere

Emily Dever

2017-05

Well, I called and asked if they have nutella donuts and the answer is no. But everything they make there is awesome, I just really like nutella and nutella donuts would make it five stars.

Barb Newbold

2022-05

What a wonderful selection of delicious, freshly made treats! I am there at least twice a week!

Marcus Drysdale

2020-05

Friendly staff and very good pastry. Little hint... peanut butter iced brownies are a must!

Connie Mackie

2022-05

Got the grandbabies some cookies cuz he was sick just to cheer him up and sticky bun yummy

Sandra Collins-Talbot

2019-05

Love the Whoopi’s pies but they call them something else. Stop and get goodies and you won’t be disappointed.

Mark Shotwell

2022-05

Friendly people, amazing service, phenomenal selection, brownies worth going to jail for.

Kelli Rush

2018-05

Best bakery there ever was!! I haven't had anything better.

Tracy Johnson

2018-05

Very friendly workers, great service and amazing delicious bread, desserts

Maranda Rorrer

2019-05

Cup cakes were dry but the brownies were excellent

Victoria Francois

2014-05

Great bakery+ and the owner is a very nice person.