Spanky's Pizza

4.3 (167)

128 E Findlay St, Carey, OH 43316
(419) 396-3569
spankys.pizza

Claimed
Pizza restaurant
Delivery Restaurant

Service options

  • No-contact delivery

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Miranda Aldrich

2023-09

…More

Floyd Barnard

2023-06

The pizza was good but had way to much sauce on it. The crust was not crispy and the cheese could have been cooked a little longer to brown the cheese a little. Plenty of toppings on this pizza though. Not very impressed.

Austin Carroll Ritter

2023-11

…More

Tessa Keefe

2023-08

…More

Dustin Brooks

2024-05

…More

d mcdannnell

2023-11

…More

Tyler Kinney

2020-06

Been there 4 times and now feel like I have a good vibe on the place. Food is okay, nothing special, I wouldn't go out of my way to eat it and there's nothing that excites me. The issue I have with the place that is two things. The two ladies who usually work the front bar for the most lethargic and uninviting human beings I've ever met. Clearly seem to hate their jobs and don't like interacting with other people. They won't acknowledge Your Existence unless they have to. The bigger issue I have was I was sitting at the end of the bar where I could see into the kitchen and watched the fry cook drop a wing on the floor and then continue to serve it

Fred “Freddy” Freeman

2020-06

Before you read further know that I don't have an issue with their food at all, my issue is with their customer service. I've been ordering pizza and burgers from them once a week for about 4 months now and every single time the person on the other end of the phone is super short with me, rude, and they have absolutely zero personality and give off a general vibe of don't care what you have to say. It feels like they hate their jobs. IMHO

LifeBeginswithAseed

2020-06

Food is good that's why we order from them instead of Angelo's. Called to order dinner. Had 2 questions and the dude on the other end that answered the phone responded with,"Jesus Christ, man!" All I asked him was," How much is a large with 3 toppings?" Really?! Couldn't believe the amount of disrespect for such a simple question. Mind you we've ordered from them at least 10xs over the years. This is recent, but you can't give people your business that treat u like that. I'll take my money elsewhere.

Jason Smith

2020-06

Food is awesome! The 2 ladies that work the bar and wait tables not sure if there mother daughter made the experience bad the dry no personal interaction along with the silent stares made the 4 of us uncomfortable that's why 1 star

Cheryl Webb

2022-06

My husband ordered whiskey on the rocks and a side 7up, he got both together. We ordered a taco pizza with sour cream o. The side and it came with sour cream on it. Wasn't bad just not as we requested

Thomas Czarnecki

2020-06

Ordered four large Pizzas for delivery, and they were large, from the ingredients to the crust it was very good, and the cheese was really good, I ordered yesterday, and had some today cold, and I am not disappointed, great hot or cold, I know it was a little bit of a ride to get to the shop, but it was good and hot when it showed up.

Robby Wells

2023-06

Service was fast, and the staff was very friendly. I ordered a ham fold over and a BLT fold over both were amazing .

Lois Lowe

2022-06

…More

Holly C Johnson

2024-03

…More

Brad Depinet

2018-06

They got great food but don't order for lunch at work cause no matter if u repeat the time to bring it they bring it late twice brought my food with less than five mins left of my 30 min break and the final straw is when I called 20 mins into my break and my food still wasn't here and they said didnt think it was coming till 8 and I said that's why I had u repeat the time back to me.. Not gonna lie sucks cause I like their food alot but I refuse to order from here again..

Taylor Blum

2018-06

Pizza was pretty mediocre, but my drink was good and the staff was very friendly. The place has a nice, small-town atmosphere, and overall I quite enjoyed my visit.

LaDonna Stables

2023-08

…More

Melissa Willis

2022-06

The atmosphere was welcoming. The food was hot and delicious. The portions were very large and worth the money.

Barb

2021-06

They have fully loaded Subs, and awesome customer service. Best place to get Subs; taste fresh, good quality food, fast delivery, and fantastic customer service.

Fortune Bormuth

2023-10

…More

Maureen Adolf

2023-06

This meatball sub was excellent, the best I've had in a long time. The server was pleasant and attentive.

Lorrie Kauffman

2019-06

Great place for great subs and really good pizza. Wash it down with a cold drink. Philly sub, veal parm sub hamburger sub and meatball pizza are yummy!

Jim Pahl

2019-06

I've been going to this place with all my siblings on wing night once a month. They are very very good service and good food

Brian Corfman

2018-06

First time trying spanky's. Went all out for the double down. Toppings were great but crust was burnt black which makes it just a burnt pizza. Very disappointed!!

Thomas Lutz

2021-06

Very good food and prices but keno numbers need to hit more😜😜😅😅😜

peggy Collier

2023-06

…More

Criswell Farms

2020-06

Super cute small town sports bar. Food was good. Fun atmosphere.

Tracy Spallinger

2019-06

Pizza was Delicious by the time I got home it was cold Not Their Fault But the Pizza was cold & Still Great

Andy Clouse

2021-06

Whole family was happy. Everything was spot on delicious. Highly recommend it!

Opening Hours

Monday 4-10 PM
Tuesday 4-10 PM
Wednesday 4-10 PM
Thursday 4-11 PM
Friday 4 PM-12 AM
Saturday 4 PM-12 AM
Sunday 4-10 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet