Casey's

Greg Coleman

2024-02

…More

Anonymous 1

2023-09

Caseys holds 150. When you get gas there. That's ridiculous. First and last time I ever get gas here!!!!!!Donuts looked better than they tasted. I'm not sure if they even make them here or if another company brings them.One cashier with a line of people at 6 am. All heading to work, waiting forever to simply check out.Sorry Casey's but I will not be coming back for anything.

Noah Vander Galien

2024-04

friendly staff and decent selection in the store but the windshield washing bays were empty by the pumps and the bathroom was yucky

Brad Richard

2024-02

…More

Matthew Bosh

2024-01

1/9/23 - Broken Pumps and diesel won’t pump, go figure right. It should be noted I stop here 2-3x a month, not daily and this is crazy every time i stop they don’t work.Update 9/1/2023Once again pumps are broke and no signage, cannot pump diesel will not let me select it as choice, light just blinks and tells me to make selection. So let’s look to the pros of this station - better than shell across the street, decent hot food options when they are available, clean bathrooms.Cons - I’d avoid the donut case I’ve seen lots of flys in that case, customer service is so/so I would guess minimum wage so minimum customer service. Lots of potential for Casey’s but poor management in the Carey Area.Review 2/10/22 (update) still two-three star rating they have been a lot better employee wise and good food options. But again tonight no fuel available, no diesel no sign stating it. There is a sign that says no plus or premium available however. I mean you are a gas station for crying out loud.

Ivan Boyko

2021-05

new gas station, well-groomed area, clean toilets, friendly and welcoming employees, and besides this, the lowest prices for DIESEL and DEF ⛽️😎🤑 all those who want to save on diesel engines come at the moment only 2 filling places, but everything is new and working ;)

kelly roberts

2023-05

When I go to this gas station it seems that about every 5th time I stop the card reader isn’t working. No one ever tells you unless you go inside. Why is it so hard to put a sign on the pump to tell you about it? The card reader is supposed to be there for convenience. I’m just so done with this place. That was my last stop there. I will just go across the street from now on.

Igor says

2023-05

Took an hour detour to fill up with diesel because of the lowest price through rts app. Even called the store and asked if their diesel island was functional, they had fuel and fleet card machine was working. All good. Hours said they open till 12am. I pull up here at 10pm and it's all closed and pumps are offline. Well that's great.

Travis Duncan

2023-05

I stopped in to the Carey, OH Casey's tonight to get fuel and a cash advance. They noticed that they were short on cash in the register after my card had already been charged but we got it figured out. The manager, who had to work early in the morning, even drove in to make sure everything was taking care of. Great service!!

roy laughery

2023-06

…More

Katrina Taylor

2022-05

Clean facility, friendly staff. This is a one stop place GREAT food and drinks a wide variety to choose from. My favorite snack is puppy chow.The gas pumps are a little slow but i think an overall a nice place to get some goodies along with the necessities.

Catherine Donovan

2022-05

I ordered a sausage pizza and a 10 piece boneless chicken wings that my husband and I planned to pick up on our way to a meeting tonight, and I paid on line. When we got to the store, we were told that they had no boneless wings, but the pizza was ready, and we could get a refund at the register for the wings. The register person said she could not give us a refund, but would call the manager to find out what to do. When she got off the call, she said that there was no way to provide a refund to us even though we did not get food that we paid for. How can that be the final answer on this? Why was our online order accepted in the first place if this store did not have this menu item? We expect a more reasonable resolution on this given that you took money for food that was not delivered. Hoping to hear from someone in charge...Catherine D. Order ID# M037470923-047518137Order time: 09/23 05:25 PM

Anjali Soni

2024-04

…More

Millennial Trucker

2023-05

Truck parking is my main reason for coming here consistently. Pizza is great, coffee fresh. Lowest diesel prices in area when used with RTS app.Parking: Parking for about 4-5 trucks

Kevin Kerstetter

2024-01

Currently no diesel would of been nice to know

Victoria Blackwell

2021-05

The store itself is fine, your standard convenience store. But the food was a little off putting. I wouldn't recommend buying the premade wraps... the tortilla became very gummy from sitting. The burger wasn't that great either. But I did like the potato cheese bites.

Jeremiah L

2023-11

Only 2 diesel pumps, one not working the and the working one is missing a nozzle

Allen Creech

2023-05

Would be a 5 star review. But for the last couple of weeks they haven't been opened at 4 a.m. theres sometimes a car sitting in the parking lot. But doors are locked.

Sophia Reese

2022-05

Bait and switch gas prices the big sign says $3.65 when you get to the pump you find out thats for 88 octane fuel and you cant even buy it the only choice was 89 octane fo $3.84

Tami W

2022-05

Don't bother and keep on driving! Their pumps are extremely beyond slow! My husband went in and mentioned something about it and they said oh yeah we know they're slow. I guess they don't care if they lose customers!

Alex

2022-05

Awesome truck stop. Clean, friendly and lots of food options. Diesel is 40 cents cheaper and cigarettes are a couple bucks cheaper.

Tim

2021-05

Just got a second sub this week. Turkey Club, packed with meat and vegetables. Fast service, friendly staff. They are putting out more food on shelves. Definitely a winner for Carey, Ohio.

Matt McCreery

2022-05

Guy behind the counter got off his phone and ran to the door to lock it right in mine and my wife's face 5 minutes before they closed. This isn't a restaurant, she needed to use the restroom and get some caffeine. If you needed to close early do it before a lady is about to open the door. So rude!

bryan treft

2022-05

It would be nice if someone was in charge of filling the receipt paper at the pumps. Literally out every time I go there. At least once a month you could check them....

Holden Barnhart

2023-05

Closed at 0800 in the morning. No place to eat around this area in the morning. McDonalds across the street is closed in the lobby.

Bryanna Bucy

2022-05

Didn't realize how much candy, beef jerky and other items that they made! Don't have these in Columbus but I liked it.

B. Bechstein

2023-05

…More

Casey Allison

2022-05

Stopped by this location very clean an well stocked employees are very friendly . Love caseys its still nice that cridersville was the very first one in ohio

Eric Ferguson

2023-05

Stop to gas and wasn’t told the gas pumps were acting up and was informed after paying

Larry W

2021-05

It was nice, the store was clean and the rest rooms were clean. They have good food to grab on the go