Pirates Cove Pizza & Subs

Joseph Wheat

2023-11

We used to go to Pirate's Cove quite often. They HAD the best subs in the area and surrounding. We went there tonight and are very disappointed. The subs used to overflow with fillings (especially cheese). It seems now they put half of what they used to on their subs. My daughter got an italian sub and they didn't put salami on it, so she basically got a ham sub. It's just not worth the 30 minute drive any more. And I will no longer be bragging about the subs to anyone I know. Bring back the previous owners!

nathan ebert

2024-04

…More

Adrian Torrey

2023-11

Pleasantly surprised by Pirates Cove Pizza. Had it for the first time tonight and ordered online, super easy process. Customer service was great. Pizza was delicious, left a little to be desired in the crust but overall a great pizza: no holding back on the toppings (great topping choices), sauce and cheese are 10/10, and worth the money. Will be eating here again!

Crystal Weber

2024-01

I ordered a cheese steak sub with no onions and no peppers add mushrooms. I also asked that they wrap it so that when I opened it up the cheese did all stick to the foil. When I got home and opened up my sub the cheese stuck to the foil and it was loaded with onions and peppers. I tried picking them off but they were chopped into small pieces so that didn't work. I was not impressed to say the least.

Mindi Robinson

2024-04

…More

Debra Steen

2023-12

As a first time customer I will not return.The subs I bought was burnt and stuck to the aluminum foil. After I got the sandwich unstuck there was no bun on the bottom, made it impossible to eat without a fork.Not a good experience with this place or their Italian subs.

crystal wallace

2023-05

…More

Nick Woodbury

2023-07

Delicious pizza, and amazing staff! My favorite thing about this place is you can order custom pizzas! (still waiting for them to have the ingredients for my Krusty Krab Pizza), but If they have the ingredients they can make just about anything you can think of. They just started carrying wings which have a good amount of meat on them along with good sauce choices. Keep up the great work!

Cole DesJardins

2023-05

This has been my favorite pizza place by far for many years. Excellent food and always wonderful staff. Pizza is unique and tastes amazing. Can’t go wrong with pirates cove. Flakey crust, thick toppings, great flavor

Susie Bennett

2023-12

…More

Chelsey Garrabrant

2023-12

…More

Bonnie Robinson

2020-05

This was our first time eating there ( we are not from there) everyone was friendly food was great!

John & Rose Powell

2023-05

Hands down the best pizza around. They use fresh product, and you can definitely tell in the taste. If you haven't tried them out, do it. You won't be disappointed!

Buster Clark

2024-03

…More

Big Iron Construction LLC

2023-05

We got pizza and subs here last night food was on time place was clean. Best food we had in a long time . We will be back!!!

Samantha Brooks

2018-05

The pizza dough was so dry, sauce was way too sweet. They cut it too soon to the cheese was everywhere and every time you took a bite it was only sauce. Worst pizza I've ever gotten from here!

Chelsie Squires

2024-03

…More

Andrew Beal

2019-05

Best pizza in cardington! Nice small shop that is next to the public library. They use an old dough machine from the 50s(by the look of it) to show they dont use the frozen dough frisbees most places use today. They offer pepsi products and subs as well, although i only got pizzas this time. Highly recommend if you dont feel like driving all the way to ashley or north of mt. Gilead for same quality pizza

Robert Williamson

2023-05

First time trying, and wasn't disappointed. Food was hot and fresh. Employees were inviting while very busy.

Chloe Norris

2020-05

Every single time we try here and get a sandwich, they get the order wrong. If you're allergic to anything and need to have it taken off, don't bother. They'll screw it up.

Darlene Storer

2018-05

Pizzas and subs aren't really bad....They have a sheet pizzas for your parties or a larger group of people....they also have pretty good lasagna dinner &salads .Very causal layed back shop.

Eric Ellsworth

2024-03

…More

Rachel G

2019-05

Really nice people working there, the owner is real nice too. Delicious food and drinks. They are also super supportive and sweet.

Cuyler Rigney

2023-05

Some of the best tasting pizza dough I've had.

Debbie Shire

2021-05

We have ate there since they opened around 1986 and most of the time our orders are perfect.

Sarah B

2016-05

Did not like one thing. Out of town first time ordering and was treated very rude when I called to place an order, I was not asked what I what I wanted to order I have to ask it was like pulling teeth to get a answer that was not rude ....won't ever order from there agaib

Jaryd Bowman

2017-05

Poor service need better hearing ordered 3 Italian subs and received 3 captain hooks??Then called and they new that they were captain hooks.

Teresa Mann

2018-05

Love the thin crust and toppings. Great service and great prises. People are all nice and intertaining

Jason Wright

2023-05

You will not be disappointed with their subs. Best you are going to find in the area.

R.J. RJG (lovebird)

2019-05

Small town pizza place. Serves subs, salads, pizza, soda. Pizza ready when they tell you it will be. Not a big place, not suitable for large crowd seating.