Whit's Frozen Custard

Tiffany Wilson

2023-11

We visited Buckeye Lake while camping at KOA and visited this amazing custard shop we ended up stopping at every day.The custard was so good and they had special flavors of the week!The staff & owners were so friendly and made us and our kids feel welcome.We can’t wait to come visit on our next trip!Sincerely- a customer who is day dreaming of your custard months later! (Yummy)

Caitlin Bowman

2023-05

SO GOOD!! New mural on the wall is perfect! The ice cream never disappoints, the staff was super friendly and helpful. If you are in Buckeye Lake you have many frozen treats options, although it's a little more pricey it has the QUALITY to back it up! Would 10/10 recommend stopping in if you're looking for really creamy custard!

alex43223

2023-09

New owners this year…I must say they are very friendly and welcoming! Whit’s is pretty much the same product location to location, with minor variances, but the service is really what makes the difference…and the new owners and their employees(/family?) are very good at that. Makes me want to patronize their local business all the more. The ice cream is always yummy, too! 😉

KC Wren

2023-10

Just finished a foot long Coney dog and I'm trying to remember if I've ever had a better one....... I don't think I have. High quality dog, the sauce is...... I mean Damn! I'm getting another one tomorrow for sure!

Marilyn

2021-05

Delicious frozen custard, perfect for hot summer days! And the Pup Cup is adorable! 🍖 Only reason for 4 stars is because they don't have fresh fruit for a topping.

Emily Logan

2023-09

Under New Management. Very nice people. I ordered the Carmel apple the strawberry short cake and the buckeye all whitseredAnd they were all great 👍

Russell Mc Farland

2023-10

Awesome frozen custard. I have not tasted or found anything on their menu that i found not eaten twice. Simply awesome desserts❣️

Michelle Goodrich

2023-10

The new owners are really nice. I highly recommend if you are in the Buckeye Lake area stop in and check it out.

Katherine Persang

2022-05

The custard ice cream was amazing. Reminded me of my home town of Aurora.Got the Brownie Blitz for my birthday.Awesome 😊 Thank you for the experienceWill definitely be back this summer

Brandon Francis

2023-05

Amazing ice cream and wonderful employees. The young lady took care if mine and my daughter's order and had a smile on her face the whole time.Great place for ice cream and wonderful service

Sara Leikin

2018-05

Whit's has great soft-serve ice cream. You can build a sundae or an ice cream cone the way you like. The have lots if other snacks and fast food items, too.

Joseph Roberts

2020-05

Last time i got icecream at a competitor but it turned out it wasn't icecream, it was a dirty trick to have playdoh in the shape of icecream. But whit's is amazing and real ice cream!!!

Dave223

2023-05

Had 2 scoops of German Chocolate. Tasted awesome with chocolate and coconut flavors. Would buy this again.

Ron Dittoe

2022-05

Great place to treat yourself and your family. Weekly specials easy to get to. Great service walk in or use the drive-thru.

Jason Farthing

2023-05

Great place to grab some frozen custard clean and employees are friendly 👌

D B

2022-05

Really cute place with fabulous frozen custard. Visiting area and will definitely return when back in area.

Kim Nixon

2021-05

We walked over from the KOA. The lobby was locked and the drive thru was open. They ignored us & refused to serve us. Rude & unnecessary.

greg cook

2021-05

Got my order wrong and made the product correct BUT still charged me for an extra double waffle cone I never got.

Debra Wright

2020-05

The Best!!! Friendly and helpful staff!!!

Kathy. Bukey

2020-05

Great frozen custard! Friendly atmosphere.

Jamie King

2018-05

Best custard I have ever tasted!

Angela Sturgeon

2020-05

Delicious custard, I love their weekly flavors

Jeff Barnard

2023-05

Fantastic... get it while you can!

David Underhill

2021-05

My favorite ice cream in the area by far.

Gizella

2022-05

This frozen custard is out of this world.

Justin Gullett

2020-05

It was good, it was just a little pricey

Barb Holbrook

2023-05

Price is higher than in Sunbury, Ohio??

Carolyn Arnold

2020-05

Custard was good and the service was great.

William Settles

2020-05

Couple of small sundaes hit the spot!

Brenda Henley

2019-05

The chocolate peanut butter Buckeye was awesome