Partner In Crime Catering

Matt h

2023-09

Were able to squeeze in my cupcake order on short notice. Friendly staff and a very upbeat atmosphere. Lots of customers when I arrived and everyone was very happy. The locals love this place obviously. Cupcakes were delicious, sweet and moist. Chocolate chips were perfect. Crisp yet soft, lots of chocolate chunks. Great for dunking in milk. Never had chocolate sugar cookies before so gave em a try and they are fantastic. Also bought the double stuffed brownies and they are deliciously, absolutely decadent! Loved em! Very happy with the entire experience. Gourmet baked goods is how I would classify them. Well worth a visit!

Jen W

2024-04

…More

Steve Alspaugh

2024-03

…More

Judith Schorling

2024-04

…More

Kelsey Beaverson

2023-08

They did a great job on my daughter’s birthday cake! Went above and beyond when the first sheet cake didn’t rise like they wanted it to and they added a second layer to make it better. Really appreciated the kind gesture! The cake was very delicious

Sierra Goad

2019-05

I have used these ladies multiple times and every experience has been wonderful, from special request birthday cakes to picking up extra goodies they have from orders. All of it is simply amazing my husband loved the pumpkin pie I had them make and my dad said the pecan is like having it made southern style! Quick response time and amazing kindness!!!! 10 out of 10 recommend! If you need any suggestions my favorite so far is the strawberry cupcakes with cheesecake filling!!!!

Kristi Moor

2020-05

I ordered a variety of specialty cupcakes for my sons graduation party. They were all absolutely delicious and packed professionally. Because it was such a busy day they even delivered straight to my home. Great customer service and a great variety of yummy treats! Also the prices cannot be beat!!

Emily Ebaugh

2021-05

Everything I've had is delicious! Soft frosted sugar cookies, buckeye cupcakes, Andes Mint brownies -yum. Their service is awesome and prices are reasonable. If you haven't tried them, you should!

Victoria Schelling

2020-05

My son and I a great time at one of partner in crime catering tasting. Every was good we could not just pick one thing. My son loves their cut sugar cookies. They listen to you and nothing is to far out for them to try. They make you feel family.

MKG MSCAL

2024-04

…More

Ammi Forrester

2020-05

There very easy to work with and do a wonderful job at decorating. We had a double birthday party for both my granddaughters and had two different cakes for each and they went way beyond what I could have imagined. They both lived there cakes and cupcakes. If you want excellent service go with these lady's.

Jeremiah Motter

2020-05

We ordered a birthday a cake for our daughters 15th bday and it was based off a picture that was given to the ladies and they did an amazing job and it tasted delicious. I also have had the opportunity to try their Whoopie Pies (choc cake w/pnut butter filling), it was also delicious. They have great prices also

Wendy Person

2022-05

Ordered sugar cookies and a pan of rice krispy treats when I visited parents last Friday. Everything was so good! The sugar cookies were so soft and delicious! Love this place!

Trina Bobilya

2022-05

April was Great! You have to try the mint double chocolate chip cookies OMG they were Amazing I also handed some out to friends and family they loved them too!!

eric pickering

2020-05

Partners In Crime Bakery are amazing bakers. My work always enjoys when i bring their items in to sell or for taste testings. Hands down i recommend this bakery to anyone looking for fresh baked delicious treats.

TAMARA CHMIELEWSKI

2019-05

We’ve had their cupcakes and they are delicious! The icing is perfect! Just writing this review wants me to order some more! ❤️

Maddie braun

2020-05

The mini cupcakes my parents ordered were unprofessional. One of the workers showed my mom the molds for the fondant, but instead we have gotten sugar paper with designs on it. I am highly dissatisfied with this.

Sister Sisters

2020-05

Awesome gluten free peanut butter & strawberry cupcakes. Tasted great & beautifully done. Would order again and recommend! Great customer service!

Kayce Geren

2021-05

These ladies do absolutely amazing work!! They can do anything you ask or try their best. As long as you give enough notice they will certainly make a item for you!! Definitely choose them over a store!

Tammy Kling

2021-05

Have gotten different baked goods from cookies, pies, lush desserts, fruit pizza cookie all have been delicious. Service is excellent and products are always done on time.

Susie Lozowski

2020-05

The girls knocked it out of the park with the cookies they made for our open house at Endless Creations. Our customers were extremely happy. Will use them for many events to come. Thank you for all the yumminess!

Lindsey Davis

2020-05

Come to them for my.kids birthday cakes and definitely for pies. They are all soooooo amazing. Their strawberry cupcakes my kids absolutely LOVE 😍 ♥️

Brittany Sims

2020-05

Cookies are absolutely delicious & the customer service is second to none! Highly recommend!!! I will be ordering from Partner In Crime for all my future needs!

Ashley Heber

2020-05

The cookies I ordered from Erica and Beth were delicious! They stayed fresh and they were so cute! Highly recommend

jeanette hull

2020-05

Great deals and service! Lots of variety...all delicious...and she delivers on some specials. Gluten free options is a real plus! Very satisfied customer! Higly recommended for all occasions!

Kiley Coffman

2020-05

Everything they have ever made for me has been delicious. Kind girls to work with and they always deliver what they say! I HIGHLY recommend them!

Linda M

2020-05

I have had the opportunity to sample and purchase several of PIC'S awesome treats/pies/deserts. Made with care and love by a couple of great ladies ❤❤❤

Paige Fulton

2023-05

Great cakes and other desserts.. always helpful and great prices would recommend to anyone, cant wait until the store is open!

Mike Levy

2020-05

I got some Keto cinnamon rolls to help with the sweet cravings. OMG, they are amazing! Highly recommend!

Janna Hay

2020-05

Great cakes, cupcakes and out this world peanut butter pie! Always friendly and ready when it is time to pick up!