Pony Island Restaurant

William Stanley

2024-04

…More

Marvin Sullivan

2023-10

…More

Jim Harrell (LarderRoom)

2023-08

LarderRoom...Brunch at the Pony Island Restaurant in Ocracoke, NC wouldn't be complete with a huge slice of Country Ham! The picture does not justice. That is a slab of delicious salty ham. Now bring on the French Toast, Pancakes and that thick Black Coffee! Nothing better than a big southern breakfast before a day in the SUN with the family!Kid-friendliness: What kid wouldn't love Peanut Butter & Jelly French Toast. Right!

Bost R

2024-04

…More

Timbo LeClerc

2022-05

This is the one stop breakfast place. To go to any other place if you could only go to one place would be missing out! WOW! I had the crab omelette and it was perfect and the service was the fastest we have ever been served for breakfast. Make it a point to come here you won’t regret it!

Auguste

2020-05

Wonderful breakfast. The locals and the staff really make this restaurant. Everyone here is so friendly and cheerful. The coffee is excellent and the conversation ideal. You must checkout this local place of heaven.

Edward Taylor

2023-05

Got my first ever Ocracoke breakfast. Somewhat small but very busy restaurant. Food was very good and service was as expected, with such a crowd. Prices in line and place was clean. Banana pancakes because it was a special day.

S Dwyer

2024-05

…More

Chris Mathis

2023-05

When on Ocracoke get out of bed and get to the Pony Island Restaurant. They only serve breakfast but it’s so worth it. The wife got the two eggs with bacon. She loved it. I got the special which was real blueberry pancakes with bacon. The blueberries were plump and juicy, it was so good. Our server took very good care of us. We went back a second time on our stay it was awesome again. This is a must go to place for breakfast.

Lexia Wingler

2022-05

The strawberry pancakes were on special. I am so glad I tried them!! They were some of the best pancakes I’ve had. I also got a side of hash browns, and they were good as well. Definitely would go back.

Frande2nc

2023-11

We were welcomed with coffee almost before our butts hit the chairs. Our server, Daniel, was promptly at our table with a smile to take our order. Tasty omelettes and hash browns arrived in the blink of an eye, and Daniel frequently checked on our meal and topped off our coffee. Delicious food, excellent service, and reasonable prices- positives all the way around!

M.K. Productions

2022-05

Another must eat when staying on the island. Their food is wonderful but the breakfast is a must have. Be sure to get the Pony Potatoes. The salsa is a perfect addition.

Candice Candler

2021-05

Amazing food! The hash browns are the best I've had! Crabmeat and cheese omelet was stuffed with crabmeat! Reasonable prices.

Robin Metcalf

2024-04

…More

Sun Shine

2023-10

…More

Randy Overton

2022-05

Locals enjoy this restaurant. So we tried, had a great breakfast.2nd trip, was here all week. Had breakfast here three times. Great food, and staff.

Julie Hennon

2024-04

…More

Amber Gordon

2023-11

…More

Geraldo pawnkid

2024-04

…More

D M.

2018-05

Our food was simple, but very good. The portions were large, and the prices were very reasonable. The staff was busy, but everyone had a smile on their faces, and overall the place had a homey feel to it.

luke stauffer

2024-04

…More

Debbie Gates (stoopedtollers)

2023-06

Friendly staff… good food… I had the blueberry pancakes this time and they were outstanding. This was my third spring visit to Ocracoke and I’ve eaten at Pony Island at least once each year, and it’s always been good. Go for the breakfast! (I was so busy enjoying the food that I forgot to take pictures…)

A person

2023-10

Where do I begin? It’s SO good! FANTASTIC service! INFINITE STARS! I recommend ALL the food! I will say this: not the best for wheelchair accessibility. They are ok with anybody as long as you pay and are not a Karen.Kid-friendliness: Super kid friendly, as with all places here.

Suzanne Durivage

2023-05

We had an amazing breakfast today at the Pony the food was piping hot, delicious, and the food came so quick. Our waiter was so friendly and accommodating for our party of 6. Erin the owner came by our table to be sure everything was perfect. Get the pony potatoes they are so good! ❤️

Edward Sieferman

2023-07

We begin our annual visit each summer to Ocracoke Island with breakfast at Pony Island Restaurant. Their corned beef hash is AMAZING, and the blueberry pancakes are ENORMOUS. The service is second-to-none.Two minor points of contention, neither of which deter my conferring 5-stars all-around:1. If you have more than four (4) in your party, be prepared to wait a bit longer as they don't have tables available to conform to larger groups.2. They won't poach my eggs to accompany the corned beef hash; however, in all fairness, neither will many other restaurants to which I have been.

J R

2019-05

Not only fast food, but real food. The comfortable atmosphere and friendly staff make you feel like you never left home.

Casey Jennings

2023-05

…More

G Koutnik

2024-04

Nice atmosphere, very kind staff, food was yummy!

Sandy LoPresto

2024-04

…More

Carrie S.

2023-06

…More