Hickory Hill Market

Michael J. Barros

2023-05

Love coming here, they have everything and it's clean and fresh. You have to order a pizza from the deli counter.this is the place to stop for all of your needs in the area. Pizza in 3 minutes.

Luis Diaz

2023-05

Everything you need plus some. Clean store, fresh produce, great food on-the-go plus a gas station. Convenient location on NY-23 in Windham.

Natallia FamKhasik

2024-02

Very nice for a gas station market place.. Some good selection of fresh produce, bread, pizza and sandwich shop.. Not your regular gas station items, more of upscale small store with gas station

Laura Bartner

2020-05

Wood fired oven pizza was great! Pick your own toppings with many choices. Clean, well stocked store, walk in beer cooler, fresh salads, made to order sandwiches, Fresh produce, gourmet cheeses and pepperoni, even seared Ahi tuna strips in the freezer. Hand scooped ice cream as well as gourmet pints in freezer section. This is the new gold standard for “convenience” markets ! The air pump is free, NICE TOUCH!

Will Gray

2020-05

It's hard to imagine a better local convenience market. Fresh produce, snacks, quality sandwiches and wood-fired personal pizzas. We had a mushroom pizza and salami provolone sandwich. Not quite 5 stars but they seem to be working out the links -- there was coffee in the iced tea dispenser, the Danish was ordinary and there was some confusion about where to return trays. I expect 2 out of 3 of these will improve.

Yogendra Bhardwaj

2023-05

Neat and clean store and very good range of items even its small.You can have pizza and eat outside

Sean Arrington

2023-06

Went here during a Bachelor Party in Wyndham and I must say, I was blown away. It's very clean, the staff is very friendly and accommodating, their selection is extensive and their goods are very fresh! And the prices! You can't beat em! If you're in neighborhood, you owe it to yourself to order something from the Deli, you won't be disappointed!

Brien Gorman

2023-07

I ordered a sandwich online, drove 20 minutes and my food still was not ready. While waiting for my food, several customers were able to place an order in store and receive their food before my food was ready. Finally, a lady asked what I was waiting on. I responded that I was waiting on an online order and that I had already spoken to someone. The worker then handed me a bag that had been sitting on the counter for quite sometime. I ordered ahead of time so that I could save time. There should be no reason that customers would be able to order and receive their food while I’m in store waiting

Raghad A

2023-08

Didn’t expect such a selection of things, but we were very impressed. We found everything we needed! And the soft serve ice cream was so delicious, we came back the next day for more. The staff was friendly and the experience was overall enjoyable.

K D

2023-05

Large variety of food/drinks. Both fresh and prepackaged. Staff are very friendly. Store is very clean and well organized and it's always very busy. They even have vegan snacks which you don't normally find in stores like this.Gas prices are high but that's to be expected based on it's location.

T Sar

2023-05

Can't rave enough about this place. Excellent for quick breakfast, lunch to go and get to slopes, even late night snacks. Food is good and fresh and the place is immaculate. Staff is very friendly and give excellent service. It's a little pricey, but you get what you pay for. Bargain hunters go elsewhere.

Peter Russell

2023-05

Stopped here this past week for a late lunch after skiing at Windham Mountain. Quesadilla and Chicken Caesar sandwich were excellent. Staff is friendly and the establishment clean with a "ski vibe" to it. Will stop in again next time we are in the area. Note that the deli counter closes at 3PM.

Jez Gof

2022-05

I have to be honest overall the place is awesome. But they certainly cater to the city folks and non locals. I understand that it where the money is made but most establishments in windham don't do that. It used to be good for locals to get a flavorful hot meal in 10 to 20 minutes. The staff can be rude in rushes but thats just the world now.Amazing coffee. Well rounded deli and kitchen. Pizza is awesome. Bear cave is full of beers. Lots of drinks. Many supplies for home too.In the short the place is very convenient

Spiro Kasimis

2021-05

This place is awesome! The subs and pizza we’re delicious and they had a big selection of beers! I’m from NYC too but I know what a cutworm is (small species of caterpillar) that feed exclusively on basil which is a sign of fresh basil and the excellence this establishment strives for. Oh by the way Andrea you should thank them for the free protein.

Ed Thompson Plumbing

2020-05

Most amazing gas station - country store I've ever been in. Fresh produce. Gluten free options, Excellent breakfast and lunch sandwich. Delicious brick oven pizza. I go there almost every day. The staff is doing great. Keep it up.

Lu Schaeffer

2024-02

Great selection of food and snacks. Great beer cooler

The Law Office of Dr Curtis FJ Doebbler

2023-05

Nice products including some fresh fruits and a good variety of cheeses, but very expensive markups. However, fact that they overcharged half the time (actually charged more than marked price on item and merely say "that is what register says") is off-putting.

Victoria Matos

2022-05

My partner and I went to this place on two separate occasions and I have to say I’m highly disappointed with the service. The staff was extremely rude. One of the cashiers refused to call me up but took the person behind me. It was not fair or right.The place it self was nice to get things but I wouldn’t go back because I didn’t feel safe or welcomed there. My partner went and the cashier spoke to him poorly for a mis understanding that they had. It was disappointing how horrid the people that work there are.

Ula Zbylut

2020-05

I never knew a place like this existed in Windham and I'm so glad that it does. They have almost everything you need here but best of all, they make fresh food and provide seating! My boyfriend and I tried the personal pizza (it's thin crust), sandwich and chicken noodle soup. The pizza and sandwich was made to order and absolutely delicious as was the soup.My go to place from now on whenever I'm up in the mountains.

Numero Uno

2021-05

Love this market ! They carry a great selection of delicious snacks and food items. If you are a beer connoisseur be sure to check out the beer cooler with a lot of international and local brewery favorites! Delicious sandwiches from the back deli as well!

Brian K Hall

2020-05

great place has everything you need. However the hot sandwiches need a little work. Meatball was totally red inside without much taste. Chicken parm was cut in small pieces as opposed to one nice sized cutlet. They are very understaffed at night and wait times can be long

David Larrabee

2022-05

I want to like this store: its convenient, a little high priced, with a good product selection. I've been there frequently since it opened. But today's experience will make them the last choice of local stores.For a number of reasons during COVID I choose to wear a mask. Today I went to the sandwich counter to order. In fareness it was busy. I waited for a quite a few minutes, without any acknowledgement of my presence as others came and went. I went and got the other items I wanted, returned a waited. Still no acknowledgement of my presence. Finally an unmasked man came along, and got IMMEDIATE attendtion with his order taken. First time I have felt I was refused service for wearing a mask... Not planing on returning

Andrea

2021-05

Found a worm in the margarita pizza. Really disgusting and left a horrible impression on us (we were visiting from NYC). Definitely wouldn’t recommend their food, would just go for their snack aisles. This could have been avoided if they washed the basil properly which I’m assuming that’s where the worm came from.

Emily Kenneally

2021-05

I absolutely LOVE this store!!! They have everything you could need in a town with absolutely nothing when you need it..lol...BUT, everytime i order a sandwich it always has turkey instead of ham. They still make the best subs in windham though and i wont complain but the 4 or of 6 times ive ordered honey maple ham they always give me honey maple turkey...otherwise NO complaints but this

Mary Schoepe

2020-05

I love Hickory Hill Market! It's clean, the staff is very friendly and helpful. I go in there on a regular basis to get my morning cup of coffee - which I find very addicting and always piping hot! Now if only they sold the coffee in a box....

steven tailleur

2022-05

Clean, tidy, good variety. Overpriced but hey it's a convenient store. I was craving a certain sandwich. Got to the counter at 3:03..." Sorry sir, the kitchen's closed we're no longer doing lunch". Just another corporate joint.

Laura Jung

2021-05

Interestingly, a quite chic convenient store/gas station located centrally in windham/hunter. Great variety of product selections — high and low, something for everyone!Maybe skip the food area as we got both our orders wrong and the staff didn’t seem to care much.

Paige Kozak

2023-05

Ok tbh best to go market I’ve ever been in. They have everything. It’s like they did an extensive survey of anything you’ve ever wished was in a roadside market and then filled the place with it. Snacks, treats, picnic fixings, bevs, candy, toys, misc practical things, plus they have the lil to go restaurant bar. Love it. 10/10

Johann Stalars

2020-05

Nice place to go shopping.There is a little bit of everything.Great selection of beers.Good fresh pizzas and sandwiches. LEat-in area available.Excellent staff, very friendly.

Laurella Dotan

2021-05

The cutest gas station / market I've ever seen! Has options for everyone, including gluten free!! Food was great, space was super clean and cute. Great music too!