PetSmart

4.5 (743)

535 Montauk Hwy, West Babylon, NY 11704
(631) 422-0213
petsmart.com

Claimed
Pet supply store
Chain featuring a range of pets, supplies & food (most offer grooming, boarding & other services).

Service options

  • Curbside pickup

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Sarah Koepke

2024-04

A kind, young gentleman was so incredibly helpful. Promptly answered all my questions besides one didn’t know an answer to (completely reasonable, because it wasn’t even his department) after I walked away, to exchange a product for the one he suggested instead; He went out of his way to googled the answer to my other question and he found me before heading out to tell me! Now THAT is good service, wish I caught his name so I could give him recognition he deserves!

Lisa Kerr

2024-04

Not only have we shopped here for years, for both our cats and dogs, we recently had beginner dog training with our 2 year old rescue from NYC's ACC. Lucas, the trainer, couldn't have been better! He was patient, considerate & knowledgeable with our new boy, Ozzy. Beyond this experience, Petsmart offers an array of food choices, treats, leashes, training items, toys, etc. I would highly recommend Petsmart to any "petparent" out there.

Chelsea Farco

2023-12

I bought a bag of Purina Pro Plan here on 11/6. When I opened it the next day, the bag was full of webs and maggots all throughout the food. I’ve never seen anything like it.My boyfriend and I returned the bag that evening, and the employee at the register could not have been less phased. She told us that there is an “infestation” in the store. Another employee walked by and pointed at the return at our feet and said, “Is it the worms again?” The cashier processed our refund and sent us on our merry way.I contacted PetSmart corporate that night and I’m absolutely shocked that no one has followed up to share measures that are being taken to mitigate this issue. After doing my own research, it seems that the store is suffering from an infestation of pantry moths, and continues to sell larva infested bags of food to unknowing customers - anything for a buck, huh, PetSmart?I wrote this review the day after we processed the return, but deleted it to give the store the chance to do the right thing and make contact about the issue. Clearly they don’t care enough for their customers in any regard. I will never shop at a PetSmart again and encourage others to do the same.

James Pisano

2023-12

We love this store. The managers and staff are always cordial friendly and professional. It does not have that “ corporate “ feel to it , the employees actually care about their jobs. Manager Mike is always polite and helpful. Erin and Stephanie in grooming always make sure my dog gets in and are always accommodating. You can tell they love the animals and I trust them wholeheartedly with my pet. The store is always clean and well kept. Keep up the good work.

fra (frareviews)

2024-05

This is an absolutely amazing PetSmart. In my opinion it’s the best on Long Island. I got my Syrian hamster named Chester from that store location. If anyone is ever interested in getting a hamster you MUST see someone who works there named Nicholas. He is absolutely amazing at what he does, he is knowledgeable and is always happy to assist anyone. He helped me pick out the hamster that was best suited for me. My hamster and I are inseparable. If you haven’t checked out the West Babylon PetSmart I highly suggest you should!Also Kayla and her mother Stephanie (I think that’s her name) are super sweet and know a lot about small animals as well!!

Dawnmarie Wood

2024-03

Store is always clean organized & friendly safe family atmosphere ❤️! Staff are helpful & always suggesting items or a discount u r entitled to! Just an easy happy experience to shop for pet needs & gift ideas for animal lovers! The Girl Scouts helped drive food & pet needs for less fortunate keep their pets well. 💋💋💞💕💕❤️❤️💜💚💜💙😻😼😼😼😼! Thanks girls!!! what a great way to help less fortunate.

Rob Sep

2023-11

Rescued my dog from the store with Happy Tails pet rescue3+ yrs ago! Awesome team of volunteers @ Happy Tails Rescue. SUPPORT HAPPY TAILS RESCUE @ Pet Smart. RESCUE A PET! DON'T BUY A PET! Donate & Support!

Gianna Pizzo

2024-02

Do not take any advice from manager “Holly!” She has an ego about herself that will not allow her to listen to updated axolotl medical advice. She tried to recommend gravel and driftwood for my tanks. After telling her axolotls can die from ingesting gravel and that driftwood lets off tannins that is toxic to axolotls. She still managed to recommend lizard decor that is not approved for water exposure and would easily breakdown releasing toxins into my tank. She made me buy 3- 10 lb bags of sand that she said would only leave an inch high in the tank. 1 bag fit perfectly and I had to return the other 2. After telling me she would help me out to my car with the 30 gallon tank, she huffed off into the back after our discussion. I managed to let the first time go, but the second time I came back they tried telling me a 30 gallon is too small for an axolotl and I should upgrade. They just want your money, not the well-being of your pet. Please please do your own research and don’t take a pet stores advice to heart. Contact your vet!!!!

Jessica Hardwick

2024-03

Brought 2 out of my 3 dogs here recently, very positive experience. The groomers were prompt, the dogs smelled wonderful after, and left wearing little bandanas. Bringing my 3rd dog tomorrow.

Kristen Mayhew

2024-03

Rude management- ALWAYS running very behind- I’m sure some of the groomers are fine but it like going into a doctors office when the office staff is rude it makes for a none enjoyable experience. Give your money to someone else

George Santiago

2024-05

Great pet store for all your pet’s supplies and training. Store manager Matt is an excellent is great customer service and goes above and beyond to help you!

Donna Barbarino

2024-04

The best pet store around. Always has what your looking for and very helpful staff.

Vincent Manning

2023-05

Got my dog groomed and honestly I think they did horrible. I plucked my dog when I got home and basically pulled a second dog. Then didn't do much at all. They didn't trim his paw hair. Nothing just a waste of money.

Richard A Waskewicz

2024-01

Jen G in the grooming department always does a great job on my mini Aussie. Recommend.

Dennis OCONNOR

2024-04

Great vast selectionGood prices. Nice discounts

Sb sB

2023-05

I dropped my pup off for bath and full haircut & my girl was ready in less than 2 hours. It was our 1st time at this location and it was definitely worth the drive. Antonia did an amazing job. My baby came out happy, beautiful, and smelling amazing. Everyone there is so friendly and all the pups we saw being groomed were so relaxed and handled with care/love.

Laiana Cunningham

2021-05

We had a bad experience with another dog grooming service where they didn't trim my dog's nails or dried him bc he was being " aggressive". At petsmart they didn't have any issues with my dog, and they were super friendly with him. He left there happy instead of stressful like at another place.

Victor Wilson

2024-02

Good prices. All you ever thought your dog might need

Alonzo “Ace” Jackson

2024-01

Great service and they're so nice to the pup❤️

Mr. B. Flood

2023-12

The store is always clean with healthy fish stock, again out of koi due to the season.

jeffrey jimenez

2023-12

Awesome place, awesome people, awesome service what more can you ask for!

Patrice O'Hare

2019-05

Good products and service. I love to visit the animals they have. You can adopt cats there. My children love it. See their pics below.

Gloria Thomsen-Papaleo

2023-05

Jessica A is a caring and thoughtful groomer! We love ove using her services!

Eddie Pipes

2023-05

We adopted our little one from here. Everyone was so nice.

Mabel Kwan

2024-01

Went for Christmas photos. Nice clean and friendly staff

Jim Quent

2023-08

The friendly staff here love animals and are very knowledgeable. I visito to buy food, treats, toys, get grooming and training (all for my pet) and I never go without the pup bc she loves it there.

Kathleen Barrett

2020-05

Great, great store! Depth and breadth of inventory, but what really makes it five stars is the employees. They are incredibly helpful and knowledgable. As a first time puppy adopter, I needed a lot of guidance and the staff was fantastic. Plus a super efficient order online-pick up in store process. Never expected a big box store to be able to offer such client focused, efficient service. So impressed.

Jill Ellwood

2022-05

My boy Oakley goes to Griffin to get groomed and he always comes out looking like a million! Griffin is also so compassionate with him and makes me so comfortable leaving my noy in his hands. Oakley loves him! 🐾💙 The whole staff is always so friendly and helpful with any questions you might have.

Dawn

2020-05

I brought my lab here for the first time to be groomed. He is partially blind. Jennifer the groomer listened to all my concerns and needs for him. She took such great care of him. He looked great. The store and grooming area were both very clean. The staff were very friendly and helpful. I would definitely bring him back again. Thank you Jennifer for doing such an amazing job!

Rich Straus

2024-01

Great staff! Very friendly!

Opening Hours

Monday 9 AM-9 PM
Tuesday 9 AM-9 PM
Wednesday 9 AM-9 PM
Thursday 9 AM-9 PM
Friday 9 AM-9 PM
Saturday 9 AM-9 PM
Sunday 10 AM-7 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet