Jerlando's Ristorante & Pizza Co.

Glenn Leong

2023-12

Amazing fresh-baked pizzas plus garlic knots swimming in garlic butter! My group of six out-of-town visitors arrived on a busy Saturday night. Without a reservation, the wait would've been an hour. So we decided to come back 3 days later - Glad we did! Service was courteous & attentive. And we loved their amazing garlic knots so much, we ordered a 2nd serving. Besides the Supreme Pizza and a veggie pizza, we thoroughly enjoyed the fresh side salad and the fried calamari rings. Five stars!

Sarah Medina

2024-03

…More

Will Johnson

2024-03

…More

Princess K

2024-03

…More

Staci Miller

2024-04

Friends & I always look forward to eating here when we do our wine trips. This time, we found the food to have been very poor in taste. Chicken was barely warm. Marinara sauce wasn't much better than a low-quality jar sauce. We missed the homemade sauce we remembered. Taste was definitely not as good as we recall. Baked potato wasn't cooked all the way and wasn't hot enough to melt the butter. Server seemed rushed and didn't even suggest/offer dessert. We had to flag him down twice to refill our drinks. Looks like we'll be finding a new favorite restaurant.

Amanda & Nathaniel Farr

2023-11

…More

randall h

2023-09

We had dinner here, unplanned. Arrived to a 45 minute wait. Fortunately, two seats opened up at the bar and we waited no more than 15 minutes! The bartenders were very efficient in light of how busy they were.My wife and I started with a Caprese Salad. This was presented nicely and super fresh.For entrees, my wife had a gluten-free pizza with pepperoni and spinach. She has had a fair number of GF pizzas and said that hands down, this was the best crust she's ever had.I went in, planning on ordering my normal chicken parmesan. It was suggested I ordered the Grilled Chicken Cantonese. It clearly says on the menu that it's a favorite and the bartender says he gets a grilled chicken Cantonese topping on his pizza. Why not? But this was better than I had thought it would be.Next time we are at Watkins Glen, this will definitely be one of our places to dine.Dietary restrictions: GF pizza crust and pasta

Jeanette Durkin

2024-03

…More

Ny Barber

2023-05

Great Italian food for a small town and wine country.The restaurant was definitely decorated to portray Italy. Small, quaint, and nice atmosphere.We arrived around lunch and we’re seated right away.Staff was super nice. He was definitely in top of providing great service.My husband ordered the personal pizza and I had the French dip. The food was so delicious!Menu had a lot of delicious options for all types of pallets.Prices for the food was appropriate for my taste.Service was quick.Cleanliness was great.Overall we enjoyed it and will definitely be back when we’re in town.

Sherri Simpson

2023-11

We were visiting Watkins Glen Gorge from out of state and decided to have pizza. So happy we chose this restaurant!!! The meat lovers pizza was excellent and the service was outstanding. Our waiter was a young guy named Sean -top notch!Highly recommend. They have a large menu of items and are evidently known for their garlic rolls.

james wolfe

2024-04

We have been going to Jerlando's since they were pizza place in Montour Falls. So for many years. Unfortunately the last few times we've been it has been disappointing, so we quit going. Our daughter was on leave from the military and wanted to go, so off we went. The garlic knots as always were excellent, but that's where it ended. The eggplant parmesan was incredibly tough and flavorless. The supreme pizza was the most disappointing, it was the worst pizza we've ever had hands down. A cheap wet knock off from papa johns. terrible. The waitstaff are very good ,so no fault from them. Jerlando's was a top notch restaurant, but this is no longer the case. I would avoid this restaurant now, there are many new and better places in Watkins Glen to enjoy a much better meal.

Laura Domic

2023-05

Excellent food! The service great once they agree to serve you at the bar. The 4 star review is because of that. The hostess told us that we can wait for the table at the bar or get the full service there if we want. We let the bartender know that we would like to order food there but they served us drinks and ignored our request for a while. After us asking what's going on, the bartender told us that we have to walk back to the hostess and let her know first. I have never heard such a thing before and even if that's their practice why couldn't they let us know about it when we first asked to be served at the bar?!At least the food was very tasty and we were able to leave happy!Hope this review will change things in their system.

Patrick Orwig

2023-07

…More

Bill Dixon

2024-02

…More

Theresa Block

2023-08

Idk why but the atmosphere felt super fancy compared to how I think it should have. Our server Allyson was amazing! Little did she know we also had an Allyson at the table.I ordered ravioli's and meatballs, it was really good. We also ordered some soft drinks which she kept full. She didn't dip into the kitchen and avoid eye contact like some servers do and I really appreciated that. I'd suggest this to anyone looking for pasta dishes as thats all we ended up ordering.

Helene Dembroski

2023-07

Great service, our waiter was fantastic. Food came out quickly for Saturday night. Ribeye was seasoned perfectly. Fettuccine Alfredo was divine. Calamari was fresh. Sauce was so good I could have drank it. Would definitely recommend. Restaurant was clean looks recently remodeled. A must try if visiting Watkins Glen. Prices were very affordable and food was so worth it.Didn't get to try famous garlic knots. Next time.Parking: Need to get there early as later in night spots are limited on weekends. Lots of pizza pickup orders

Mike Reid

2023-11

…More

Jen D

2024-03

…More

Paula Mangiardi

2023-07

…More

Benjamin Schwantes

2024-04

…More

David von Doehren

2023-11

Good pizza. We ordered small pie, they brought a large one but only charged the small price. Nice, friendly service.Dietary restrictions: They had available gluten free if you need that.

Vanessa Bouton

2023-07

…More

Helen Shu

2024-04

Delicious super flavorful food and super friendly service. We got the classic trio which came with a piece of lasagna chicken parmigiana and fettuccine Alfredo along with cheesy garlic bread and a side garden salad. This combo was enough for two to split for $26 absolutely phenomenal deal. The tomato sauce is exceptional and alfredo was the best I've ever had 10/10 recommend. The place is busy for a reason even when they were packed we only waited 30 mins and enjoyed a beer at the bar the time flew by.

Aaron Boyle

2023-05

Up front, the service was very good, the atmosphere wasn't bad either, and food was middling. If you love American Italian food and looking for an obvious step up from Olive Garden, this is for you. If you're looking for genuine Italian (with Influences from all over the country), you may be disappointed.Food: Tomato sauces tasted sugar sweetened and I felt my dish, the stuffed peppers were smothered in cheese. Great for some, but not what I was looking for unfortunately. We had to try the garlic knots based on other reviews - they tasted under done (still doughy) and were only a conveyance for butter, garlic, and marinara sauce.Service: Nothing but praise, our waiter was attentive without being obtrusive. Friendly. Thanks!Atmosphere: Semi-open seating with attractive murals and decorations. This place appears relatively recently refurbished.

IT Guy

2023-07

…More

Woojoo Na

2023-05

…More

James Parris

2023-09

…More

Steve Demuth

2023-07

…More

Wendy Smigielski

2023-05

We had a wonderful dinner here. Wait time was 10mins, food came out quickly even though they were busy. Our waiter Ryan was attentive and friendly. Good food! Definitely will come back when visiting the area.

Mike Mastracco

2024-04

Just a great italian restaurant........ A wide variety of Italian and American foods they are all very very good......Parking: Free on street parking there is also parking in the backside of the building in a public parking lot.....