Frosty's Ice Cream

Barbara Wengler

2023-09

Love coming here whenever in town. The prices are great, people are friendly, and even a baby cone is good size! They put my cone in a cup, so I was able to take it across town and deliver it for a friend. Awesome !!

Victoria Sterling

2023-09

Fun throw back in time. Excellent soft serve ice cream.

Dennis Smith

2024-05

…More

Jose Hamtig JR

2023-07

Very tasty ice cream! I picked the banana split "boat" version and that was amazing!! I ate it all lol I might have been really hungry for anything but I finished it all! My family ordered ice cream as well and they all finished their ice creams also. I would love to go back again!

Clarivell Reyes

2023-06

Not alot of icecream flavor options but it is super affordable perfect for a quick stop. My husband and I got 2 medium vanilla cones and they filled the icecream all the way to the top only for 7 bucks all together. Will definitely come again. Has parking as well as benches. Just be wary there's a cemetery like right in front so it's not really a scenic area but who cares yay icecream

Trent Lytle

2023-05

Nice place to get ice cream with reasonable prices. The girls that work there are always friendly, fast and efficient. If you feel up to it, leave them a tip. I always look forward to them opening up for the season so I can get my ice cream fix. Highly recommend.

Michael Handley

2023-10

Ordered 2 cones and a flurry for myself, the portion sizes are great and priced very reasonably. Will definitely be back for another visit!

FireShepherd 115

2023-09

Better prices and portion compared to Cowlick and Blizzard barn. Their soft serve is super fluffy and flavorful and workers always been kind :)

Riley Ramsey

2023-05

Personally, Jodi's Dairy Bar in Dexter is our favorite but since this is so close to home, it's quite good and has very reasonable prices for the sizes, the only real "issue" is they don't have authentic vanilla flavor 😅😅 I get MallowDramatic or Panda Paws. Can't go wrong.

Lynda Morgia

2023-10

Frosty's is always a great treat for the family. Took my granddaughter for some ice cream , she was so excited.

Jon Lavelle

2023-10

Delicious ice cream and fast, friendly service. Looking forward to next summer!

Jessica Beasley

2022-05

Ice cream is great but hours of operation are not consistent! For instance, we arrive at 8:15 pm and the 3 girls turned us away at the window and people were still pulling up!

Michael Devito

2023-09

Great ice cream stand in Watertown NY. Also great owners past and present.. High quality products.

Lawrence Millen

2022-05

Soft and Hard ice cream, slushies, splits and more! Wonderful!

Joseph Mann

2021-05

Friendly staff and good sizes. Prices aren't too bad either. Not too difficult to get to. About a mile off the highway. Our friend was able to get in and out with her pop-up camper without difficulty.

Will Beecher

2022-05

Visit at least once a week with my children. This is very clean and well maintained establishment with very friendly employees everytime! These girls spend there days and evenings putting smiles on people's faces and work very hard for a busy place so please tip as many of these girls are working while attending school.

Brian Cowan

2021-05

Great service and friendly ladies that worked there during the summer of 2020 with all that was happening. Always left the ladies a tip that I thought they could use, I know being an essential worker your taking a risk with all the virus that was happening and I feel that these wonderful ladies worked as hard as I did they sure deserved what I always left them. Thank you for your wonderful service. Stay safe and will see you again next summer in ther year of 2021.

Derek Crowe

2023-05

Said they was open til 9pm, closed at 8pm. Now after our texas roadhouse bread challenge we have nothing to wash down these 9300 calories with. Hope they fix their hours, headed to dairy queen

Michelle De Leon

2019-05

I ran into this quaint little ice cream place by accident and later on discovered what a gem it is. They have so many ice cream options all so good. You’re not feeling like ice cream? Have some of the cookie dough or snowcones or icicles or some of their other snacks and treats. They even have great tasting low fat sugar free ice cream! Oh and if none of this sounds like enough they even sell dog sundaes. Yes your pup can have a treat too! Only con to me is that it is cash only and no restrooms but a good place to go chill for a bit with your kiddos or friends.

kevin keller

2023-07

One of the best ice cream shops around. not much for dairy free though

Adrianne Lewis

2019-05

This was a nice treat on a hot afternoon. I got crazy vanilla with Reeces pieces I asked for the cup because it was bigger than I expected and very reasonably priced! They have Any kind of ice cream you can think of.. And they have other stuff besides ice cream.. Come check this place out!

Tee Marie

2018-05

This place has great ice cream and friendly service. Outdoor seating in sun and shade! Prices are very reasonable!New menu items including smores sundeas and salted caramel milkshakes!

Stephen Raab

2019-05

Great Ice cream, decent prices.... what more could you ask for. Took the kids there today and got them Magical Unicorn flavor, let's just say I have a new absolute favorite!

John Maxon

2021-05

Hands down the best ice cream in the area. They are cash only. Frosty's uses only high quality ice cream, even their sprinkles taste better than other places.

Rachel Nickoley

2021-05

The ice cream was very good, they did get a bit busy and forgot part of the order but as soon as it was brought up the happily fixed the error. Simple error with a quick fix made it so it was still a good experience.

Saskia

2023-05

They have non dairy ice cream!!

Robert Potesta II (Bobby)

2018-05

If you're looking for a quality ice cream shop, then look no further than Frostys. It's cheap but doesn't taste like it. In my several visits to Frostys, I have never had to wait more than a few minutes to order unlike Sonic where the wait is 15+ minutes regardless of how many people are ahead of you. Frostys is the perfect little mom-and-pop shop. I like how quiet the surrounding area is. You can enjoy your sweet treat without being bombarded by the hustle and bustle of the inner part of the city of Watertown.

Hoang Nguyen

2023-05

Ice cream is great, reasonable prices, friendly staff, and they even gave us free sprinkles!

Danice Cashin

2019-05

Great staff. I love the soft ice cream served in a cup. I know when it is summer, and when it's over when they open andclose for the season.

Brenda Barajas

2021-05

Best ice cream in town.. I love Hershey ice cream.. please don't ever stop having Hershey ice cream.. they put all the good stuff toppings on there..