Yummies Ice Cream

Mary P

2024-04

Went here with some friends to get ice cream!! I got the chocolate + strawberry ice cream. You get your own ice cream (you can choose multiple!), with whatever toppings you'd like, and pay by the weight! There are many options of ice creams and toppings for anyone to enjoy :) Mine was about 7 dollars and it filled me up.Dietary restrictions: There are gluten free and lactose free options!Parking: There are some cute shops around!! Easy parking to walk where you'd like to go

David Nagel-Nunez

2023-08

Very good ice cream shop!! We stopped by here for the first time and glad we did. There are a lot of unique ice cream options, and they are delicious. My husband got a mango smoothie, and it was very rich and good. Great shop, and very visible from the road. Definitely recommend it.

Sarah Beana

2023-10

Their icecream is fantastic and if you have any sort of food allergies THIS is the place for you! Allergens are clearly noted, no need to ask, and their accommodations are phenomenal (ask for a GLUTEN FREE waffle cone!)! Portions are LARGE to say the least, so be prepared. Cute and friendly outdoor space to enjoy your treat, and they also have a drive-thru.

SY L

2022-05

One of my favorite ice cream places in the east coat! I didn't expect to find such an amazing ice cream place in the middle of my way driving from Philly to Buffalo! The ice cream tastes creamy and flavorful. I drove an extra 30 minutes to have the ice cream again on the second day when I left Buffalo!I highly recommend their “apple pie” flavor! I ordered the apple pie and muddy frog the first time I came here. The muddy frog is tasty but you can imagine how a mint ice cream tastes like.I ordered the apple pie, butter pecan, and black PB attack on the second day. There are so many pecans in the ice cream that makes me feel satisfied when I had the butter pecan flavor! The PB one is also good. If you like PB, you will really love this flavor.The medium size is $4, in which you can choose up to 3 flavors. The price is super fair! The portion is EXTREMELY HUGEEEE!!I highly recommend you visit this place if you visit or drive by Warsaw!!!!

Crystal Knowles

2023-09

First time visiting this icecream shop. The icecream is pretty amazing. We got the PB signature Sundae and the PB Sundae both where amazing. Best vanilla icecream I have had yet. Definitely a must try!

Nathan Krouse

2024-05

…More

Rich Pembrock

2023-10

Made it just before the end of season..great flavors nice vibes good service

Scott Bowman

2024-05

…More

Stephan Penke

2023-09

Maybe the best ice cream I had on all of my worldwide travels..a must go and worth driving a long way

Miles Away Everyday

2019-05

The absolute best! Ice cream is supposed to be delicious and fun, and Yummies is rare in the sense that they do both very well.The ice cream is to die for. The serving sizes are HAYUUUGE. And the atmosphere is what you hope for - vibrant, fun, and satisfying.The owner, Valerie, has improved the place every year and frequently adds new flavors to the arsenal. There is truly something for everyone and I look forward to many more visits to Yummies in the future.

Cindy Madar

2022-05

Yummiest in Warsaw NY is the place to go for ice cream. Offering 75 flavors from which to choose and serving soft ice cream hot fudge Sundays and other great treats. Make sure to check out the menu on fb and also the website. Drive through is congested its much faster to order through the window. Plenty of seating under the spacious patio and benches and tables have their own green space. A creek runs in the back and is lovely to sit at on a nice day enjoying your ice cream. Love yummies and I have a feeling you will too.

GingerandHerb Conly

2023-05

What a rare find. Wonderful homemade ice cream. 28 flavors to choose from at one time out of 100 flavors. We WILL be back. Too many flavors to go just once.

ASHLIN BPG Marketing Inc.

2020-05

Fabulous selection of ice cream. They even have a sugar-free options. Great place for break while travelling through this picturesque town.

Lydia B

2023-05

This place is tasty, and I would call myself an ice cream connesouer. The cream doesn't get icy or anything, and their flavors are original. The baby cone/scoop is actually baby size and a fair price.

Alex Ingles

2023-06

Yummies Ice Cream is Warsaw's only ice cream location (sorry McDonalds). The selection here is immense and often overwhelming at first. This only gets worse coupled with the fact that there are often new flavors throughout the season added or changed out. This is hardly a negative though as you simply cannot have enough ice cream to choose from. From a variety of styles, sizes, flavors and types, as well as different drinks, there's a little bit of everything. Take your time when deciding and try new things, you're bound to find something you'll enjoy here, and their staff is more than happy to give you some suggestions as to what they like should you not be able to decide.However, not all is positive. Due to it being the only ice cream location, if you are expecting to get ice cream on a weekend or a hot day, you had best be expecting a long wait time. Drive through is a hopeless adventure during peak hours as the traffic will often stretch down the street and block the road, you're better off parking in the next-door Wyoming office parking lot and walking. Ice cream is a bit on the expensive side, with cheaper and larger serving sizes being offered outside of town and taste can sometimes be inconsistent, especially soft serve. I do not recommend sitting outside as the noise pollution from being on a major throughfare coupled with other patrons makes for a very loud ice cream session of having to shout to be heard by the person next to you.All in all, a great family experience and a good place to cool down with a sweet treat. I cannot begin to tell you how many times I've made late night ice cream runs to satisfy my sweet tooth.

Ady82

2024-05

…More

Takumi Otsuka

2023-09

Tl;dr - Good ice cream, bad experienceGirlfriend and I stopped through on a drive, got a waffle bowl w/ Max Black PB Attack and a waffle cone w/ Cherry. Ice cream was delicious, portion sizes generous, staff friendly.Unfortunately, the bottom of the waffle bowl was accompanied by a very strong and bitter chemical taste, which was hard to wash out and ruined the experience. A follow-up call w/ Yummies points to residual dish soap on the tool used to press the waffle bowls as the likely culprit.We are not local, but we pass through the area annually, and while this was an unfortunate first experience with Yummies, I would still consider stopping by again (the ice cream really is very good). Might skip the waffle bowl next year though...

Sierra Gaglione

2023-05

This is such a cute and great place! The ice cream is yummy and the people are very nice. 10/10 would come again 😊

Ian Laird

2021-05

Fantastic ice cream selection with delightful homemade flavors and waffle cones, complemented by a timeless awning seating area and friendly service. Yummies is a new favorite!

wilson chong

2023-09

Im 47 years old and this is the best Ice Cream I've ever had, anywhere, in my life. Stopped here coming home from Niagara. If I ever go back to Niagara I'm stopping here for more hand dipped ice cream. Incredible.

Jainil Kapasi

2023-05

I think this a hidden gem in Warsaw, passed by it a couple of times over the year and when I stopped by it didn't disappoint.The waffle cone smell is amazing and the choices you have are endless. If you have a sweet tooth stop by and enjoy some ice cream by the water

Benjamin Monessa

2023-05

Travelled through on the way to Canada from NYC. Had the Coconut flavor. Absolutely, without a doubt the BEST ice cream I've ever had in my entire life. I was very upset that we didn't get a chance to stop by again on the way back down. I still think about that ice-cream days later and I only had a medium size. Such rich flavor with a consistency I have never had before. I've had many ice-creams but this one is not your average ice-cream. If you're travelling upstate and making a stop, you need Yummies. Staff is very friendly as well. 10/10 coconut flavor. I wish I can write more to express how much I love this ice-cream but I'm starting to sound crazy.

Linda Duman

2018-05

Nice seating area.Friendly staff.Drive thru. Most of all like the name says "YUMMY" homemade rich creamy icecream Even have take home pints pies etc.

Jeff Gumm

2023-05

Impressively great ice cream and such cool flavors! I forget what my flavors were called but one was deep dark chocolate with peppermint swirls, and the other raspberry with chocolate chips. So good!

Michael Ackley

2023-05

Art ved an hour before close, three cars ahead of us in drive through. Rainy cold night so no one at the window. Took 30 minutes for us to get served. Only one little girl actually taking and filling orders. Little worker she was, the others could take note! The other 5 kids I saw in the shop, were either just chatting it up, or looking to attempt to clean coolers or mop. There was one male young kid that was not doing anything. Peoples time is valuable, we love Yummies ice cream and understand it's tough to find good help especially with these punk lazy kids...but this was not a good start to ice cream season.

Albert Chang

2022-05

The ice cream cones / cups sizes are quiet big and the ice creams are sweet, flavorful and tasty.

Cheryl Buechi

2023-07

Great selection of ice cream flavors and generous servings. Attractive outdoor seating. Very good service for our group.

What Ever

2024-04

…More

Tom Eichler

2023-06

Great stop on the drive down south or the way back. Tons of different flavours for soft and hard ice cream as well as milkshakes. Highly recommended!

John E Becker

2020-05

Wonderful homemade ice cream selections. Outside seating. Comfortable. Courteous service staff.