Wow! That's Unusual!

Jay S

2023-11

Steve has an amazing collection of vintage gear and collectibles. Loved the Harlwy shirt Hamburgler story and 70's doll we purchased.

Mal

2023-05

Pretty awesome place. Lots of cool stuff everywhere, and reasonable prices. It’s chock full of stuff and pretty messy but you can find cool treasures!

Bella

2024-04

They have a very interesting and expansive collection of vintage pieces. The owners are husband and wife duo, and you can tell they really love old things.

Mommabethy

2024-03

I have shopped here numerous times and love the vast array of products. The owners are very friendly and welcoming.Definitely recommend.

Jessica De La Rosa

2023-09

I purchased a Barbie airplane for a great price, my daughter was ecstatic with the find. The gentleman behind the counter was polite and had a pleasant disposition. We hope to return in the near future, it certainly is a place for nostalgic treasures.

Mia Villella

2022-05

I love this store so much! There's always something new and interesting. Owner is extremely friendly, nice, personable, and a great person to have a conversation with! Even if you're not looking for anything in particular, you're sure to find something that catches your eye! I make sure to go at least once a week because there's always something new that the owner finds and goes "wow, that's usual! I need that in my store!" Prices are extremely fair, I found some 45s vinyls and he sold them to me for 50¢ each! Some other things I found were fun earrings, and random patches and accessories. Really cool vintage clothing finds as well. The basement is always a fun time because you never know what you'll find down there. I definitely recommend going here often because there's always new things. The owner is super nice and I always have a great conversation with him! Steve's the man 😎

Alex R. Castro

2023-05

I was a foreign tourist passing by, when I was taken to this shop by a nephew. I was floored by the range and diversity of the collectibles---what an incredible mess (which is what I wanted!), Of course, I scrounged for an hour and came away with some fun, pop culture items! On my last day in Suffern, I paid another rush visit (1st customer of the day!) and got a few more postcards, vintage coloring books and paper dolls. So much amazing stuff, so little time! Thank you Mr. Steve, for your wonderful welcome, and I promise to come back next year, for I never get tired of being...WOWed!

Ileana Rivera

2022-05

The store was a lot of fun to look though. It was a little messy but that didn’t bother me at all. I’d expect a thrift shop to be a little messy with all the random items they carry. They did have a great selection of things. A lot of it was vintage which was amazing and the staff was extremely polite. Will be back soon. I also asked if they took donations. And they do, so that’s also awesome if that was something you’d want to do with stuff that’s laying around.

Ripley Butterfield

2021-05

I loved this place! I was looking for interesting spots to visit during a day trip away from nyc, and I am so happy I went here. There's a huge variety of music on CD, a room full of vinyl records, and plenty of stuff like action figures, old magazines, books, and furniture. The guy working there was incredibly kind and sweet. He took the time to show me some really cool Paul McCartney memorabilia he had in stock after he saw me holding a McCartney vinyl + vhs tape. In fact, after my mom accidentally left the vhs behind while checking out, he ran after us to make sure we got it! I certainly plan to return :o)

Joyce Lee

2021-05

So cool!!! I walked out with some vintage cast iron cookware and records (incl some promotional/ not for sale copies).It’s a digging kind of place so come with ample time. I was very tempted by some complete vintage China sets... but exercised restraint.Super helpful owner. Highly, highly recommend

Gianni Molluso

2023-05

My Name is John Intonato, This was my first time at this store. There is definitely something for everyone here. So many items to look at. I recommend this place to everyone.

Cerberus Muzak

2022-05

Steve is the best! He’s sold me everything from rare cassettes, books, posters, figurines, collectibles, record players and even cassette tape decks! Always love coming by the shop! Best shop in Suffern!! Also check out his shop on eBay @ oddballdad-Andre

A Rose

2021-05

My husband and I spent an hour in this shop combing through the PACKED aisles and shelves. It is very Overcrowded and almost a safety hazard. My husband picked out a vinyl record he was really happy to have found. When we went to check out, the owner rudely took the record from him and said that it just sold on eBay. The fact that he didn’t apologize or say a simple “sorry”, made this interaction even more appalling. You’d think he’d be courteous and sell the record to the customer who has walked around the store with it in his hands for an hour and cancel the ebay sale. We will NOT be returning to shop here.

Danny Rowland

2019-05

This place has everything you could hope to find in an antique store. There are corners of the store that are well organized and neat and others that require some digging to find your buried treasure. There is a basement and it is full to the brim with even more stiff like furniture, records, paintings, and tools. The entrance to the store tells you pretty much everything you need to know about it with all of the random things on display. The prices are fair and the owner is nice. I would highly recomend going in to shop for the next birthday party you go to because you will certainly find a present that is unique and amazing. Even if you don't plan to buy anything you feel like you are peering through a window at American history by walking around the place.

Jennifer Steeber

2021-05

The proprietor is polite and helpful, and there's tons of stuff; it's just hard to find anything. There's no rhyme or reason to item placement, so if you're looking for something specific, ask. It's also crowded; browsing's a bit challenging. But if you love the thrill of hunting for a particular collectible or bargain, this is a fun spot to visit.

Jeff Sherer

2016-05

I collect mickey mouse snow globes. Yes. In stock. The pricing is always negotiable. Steve knows every item. The inventory is extraordinary. The staff always makes you feel like family. The experience of walking thru this very crowded shop is worth the trip into Suffern,, EASY parking.Go for it! You will find something that you will want to take home. And you will. five stars compared to all the Nyack and Cold Spring shops.

Jessica Jones

2019-05

So happy I found this place. Went in one night, amazed by the selection and friendly, welcoming customer service (Steve is the best!) went back in the following day with family, lost my necklace and Steve got down on his hands and knees to try and help us find it. Cant find that anywhere else. If your in the area, and even if your not find the time to stop by here. You never know what you might find!!!

Insite Auto

2018-05

Very nice place. You will all sorts of odd and quirky items there. There is something there for everyone. The prices are also very reasonable. There is usually a different person everyday but whoever it is, they are very friendly and willing to help.

Briana Kaufman

2018-05

Family run store, decently priced and everyone is so friendly. I'm the oldest daughter and the store manager. Been there on & off for 7 years, wouldn't keep going back if I didn't love the atmosphere

Irene Voce

2018-05

Fun place to shop or browse for nostalgia. Wide selection of music CDs and even vinyl records. You are bound to find something fun to buy. FYI physical space is tight.

marsha lewis

2023-11

As the name says, lots of unusual items to choose from

sussie herzl

2022-05

Owners are so kind. Patient. And they have beautiful unusual finds. Excellent things

Auti 140

2021-05

Can easily lose track of time being in this store ! Good way to spend your day . Never know what you might be inspired by ! 😊

Isaiah Mccall

2019-05

I'm a thrift store junkie and this is one of my favorites. It's not the most organized, but if you enjoy digging for gold you'll love this place.

Frank Buch

2019-05

Lots of different, interesting and collectible items.

Michael Mihok

2017-05

Very unique items for sale. Owners are fantastic and extremely welcoming and nice people.

Jannice Quevedo

2020-05

I love the owner, he's real fun and the store has real cool stuff

MoneyGetterDavid Cash

2018-05

Great store has very cool stuff and the owner is very nice and helpful I highly recommend going there.

Jon Marten

2019-05

Great place, has many hidden treasures and owner is very respectful.

Maynard James Keller

2017-05

Quirky miscellany of old and new fun stuff (and some useful) stuff. Personable owner.