Moreno's Pizza

Shawn Collins

2024-04

…More

kristine miranda

2023-09

…More

Erin Kussius

2023-11

…More

Carlos Torres

2022-05

Food came fast so that was great…but the crust was burnt and the pie was overcooked but when it came it was cold? Pizza flavors were there though! The jalapeño poppers not being the greatest we’re also cold.

Sena

2023-06

The Owner is the Nicest guy Ever! Always has a big smile on his face, he's welcoming, friendly & funny! Food is consistently great!! Won't ever go anywhere else! Calzone& garlic knots are Top Notch!!

Emilee Saunders

2024-04

…More

Erin Coleman

2023-05

Stopped in for a quick bite tonight - got a chicken parm sub and an order of mild wings. The sub was great and the wings were delicious (and I'm picky). The service was also great. Will definitely order again!

Spencer Kemp

2023-05

…More

Ken

2023-05

The owner here has to be the hardest working guy in Stillwater. He definitely has the best Pizza. We enjoyed our pies and luckily we had ordered more than we needed so we had plenty of leftovers for lunch the next day. It's even good cold.

Erin

2021-05

I was nervous because we've had a lot of take out fails lately, but this was the best pizza I've had in years! The man who answered was polite and accommodating even though I had a bunch of questions. Delivery was fast and the driver was friendly. Everything was exactly how I ordered it, and again, the pizza was amazing! I think this will be a our go to from now on.

Elizabeth Mendetta

2023-05

Wow ,just returning home from a wedding and was starving. Thought we'd have a pizza to go, not expecting what we received. Top 3. Deep dish with mushrooms and extra cheese holy cow great. Thank you and don't change a thing !

TBONE TOM

2023-05

They have on their menu, a tavern style pizza, which is a very thin crust round pizza! What they will send you a 12 cut square pizza and tell you that is a tavern style pizza. I’ve been all over the country that is not a tavern style pizza a tavern style pizza is a round very thing crust pizza nada Sicilian between 12 cut square pizza.! will never order from them again. Had problems with them and Dom’s pizza in Stillwater… out of the three pizza parlors in Stillwater. The only one is legit is Buccieiro’s in Stillwater.. I never had a problem and pizza has been spectacular and I’m consistent on time. Best pizza in Stillwater New York.!👍🏻

richard “RichS73” shoaff

2023-05

Great pizza! Great atmosphere! great people! My go-to place to feed my kids. They get my order right even after 4-5 drinks. Thanks guys!

Brendan Swider

2017-05

Quick service. Pizza and wings were ready in about 15 minutes. Friendly guys at the counter. Fair pricing. Loved the cheese with just the right amount of grease. However, the crust was not my favorite. It was a little overcooked and a bit chewy.

Joe Rourke

2020-05

Went here on a hunch and was not disappointed! The pizza was perfect in every way. Very generous with the toppings and the wings were the closest thing to perfectly cooked and seasoned anyone could ask for. This just became my go to spot.

Paul Matula

2013-05

I grew up in Stillwater and every since was a little kid Moreno's has remained consistently a solid pizza place. While Dom's and Frankie-o's have had limited runs with different recipes and owners as a better pizza, Moreno's is a time honored place with a constant quality of pizza and service. Very good across the board, however I would recommend only as a delivery or pick up location, not exactly restaurant material.

Tony C.

2013-05

Moreno's is by far the best pizza in Stillwater, NY. I've lived in the area my entire life and while other pizza parlor's have come and gone Moreno's has remained constant and tasty. Skip Dom's and whatever other fly-by-night happens to come to town and just go to Moreno's. Their buffalo chicken pizza rocks!

Tim Moran

2022-05

Not bad at all. Everything came hot and had no problems with my order. Very clean place. I would definitely stop in if you are in the area.

Rick Sherin

2016-05

I have not been there yet, but my bro tells me that Moreno's uses the Valley Falls Inn? crust recipe that I recall from my youth many years ago.If anyone out there can corroborate this, I will jump in my car tomorrow and drive over. And, I live 16 miles east of Rochester, NY!Thanks!!

R W

2022-05

Had a calzone. Served piping hot with pepperoni, mushrooms, and green peppers. I was pleased with the service as well as the food.

timothy abbott

2021-05

Great Philly pizza. Wish they would cut their pies a little better so I don't have to dirty a knife, but it's fine.

Cyndi Van Dewerker

2023-12

…More

Barbara Winslow

2021-05

Food and as staff were great and great prices the best pizza place in the 11 + yrs I have lived in this area

Dillon Costanzo

2021-05

Exquisite dining experience and staff is communicative and appreciative of your sale please stop in this lovely restaurant to grab a slice of one of saratogas finest pizzerias

joe McMillan

2021-05

Pizza is great just be aware they charge a $5 delivery fee that other pizza places in the area do not.

Patrick Barton

2020-05

Tom make the Best deep dish Pizza. And, he is Very Generous with the Toppings.

Bryan Culver

2022-05

Fantastic pizza. Our new favorite spot!

Philip Carpenter

2023-10

…More

Charlene

2021-05

Good pizza, decent menu. Apps are baked not fried.

Paul Daloia

2017-05

Always great pizza and wings, employees are always helpful and happy.