South Dayton Supermarket

Pj Michalak

2024-05

It's an excellent staff wide variety of products and awesome Pizza and subs 😁

LauraLee Ring

2023-07

This store is so adorable. It's out in the middle of the Country.It's very useful for sure.High prices for sure. Extremely respectful, clean a little shy in the Deli. I stud waiting for around 5 minutes, then I had to talk a little loud for anyone to help mean couple times. But then I received help.

Brian Lock

2023-10

Been buying doughnuts here periodically and always been good with decent filling, this last dozen was cut back a good 50percent. Sure wasn't worth $16...

Amanda Kopacz

2024-05

Their Donuts are worth the trip!

Dustin M

2023-09

Nice store but don't bother the lady putting the doughnuts away the day old doughnuts at that, she was very rude and disrespectful , tells us that she has them all put away as we see them on tray's sitting on the counter.. Oh well looked like flies were crawling all over them maybe the b**** did us a favor but I'll be telling everyone that I hear say they are stopping there,not to....

Gary Crispin

2024-02

Large selection of local spices and sauces, along with a variety of unique products.

D M

2023-05

I made my first visit today and from the deli I had made some subs and salads with them being excellent. It's a full service store including fuel, pharmacy, besides a very well stocked grocery store which includes a bakery and mentioned deli. In visits to my cousins I've had their award winning donuts and goodies, needless to say they're excellent. Great job South Dayton Supermarket!!

gene dloniak

2024-04

The best apple fritters ever hands down

Joshua Holdsworth

2023-05

Delicious 🤤 Donuts 💯Wife 🛑 in grabbed a couple dozen 💯 Peanut 🥜 and Bavarian cream 🍩were absolutely amazing! If you don't try this you are definitely missing out in life 😉

Riley Goodwill (Reaper)

2022-05

The super-duper deli has come a long way from where they started and I can see and taste the change. They have such a variety of side orders you can chose from. They are friendly when taking an order, and they have some fast cooks working back their. I can't wait to order again!

Cath Kestler

2021-05

If you love donuts this bakery will blow your mind! You gotta get there early for the best selection. One of my favorites are the peanut sticks, the dough is as airy as a cloud and it melts in your mouth. The jelly donuts are filled to oozing out, the jelly is homemade in store and OMG they weight close to a half a pound each. They stay fresh for a couple of days unlike from other stores or coffee shop chains, which turn hard by the end of the day and is filled with less than a tablespoon of filling.We will drive out of our way to get these, they DEFINITELY are worth the drive. Kudos to the bakery staff ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

knightnrmer

2022-05

I've been coming to this store for over 10 years . Recently they are going through a lot of staff changes but most all are sincere on doing a good job . The deli is very good on fish frys and pizza . Store is always stocked and the checkouts are always fast and friendly . I would give this store a 9 out of 10 stars . Thank you to the owners .

Laura Kennedy

2022-05

Pharmacist is extremely kind and caring. Market carries freshly butchered meats, including delicious, huge, stuffed pork chops. Deli makes great subs. Bakery makes the best donuts but the apple fritter is where it's at! Highly recommended.

Tracy Shelanskey

2023-12

I feel sorry for the people who shop here, small town store with HIGH PRICES!!

Duane Perkins

2018-05

Very clean store with fresh produce, good look in meat and a very good over all selection of items for the space they have available. Western NY's BEST donuts. Award winning!! I confirm this to be the case!! Deli is excellent as well. Excellent run small town store and an assett to its community! Value deals and frequent shopper reward system. Highly recommend!!

Barb Bartlett

2019-05

Hometown owned and operated, small/friendly, clean and they have the best donuts in western NY. I buy all my meats here, because I know the butcher wont put out anything he would serve to his own, the cuts of meat are excellent quality. Try their homemade breakfast sausage and their Homemade Polish and Italian sausages, you won't be sorry!!!

Christina Werner

2019-05

I drive all the way here just for their bakery. The donuts are beyond delicious, best I've ever had. Coming from Buffalo, I would pick these donuts over Paula's or Eileen's bakery any day!

Kathleen Stratton-Yorke

2016-05

Best doughnuts in the world! Soft, yeasty with an abundance of filling. Always fresh. Always... The store itself is very friendly and filled with lots of happy employees which makes for a good if not great shopping experience.

Shawn Phinney

2018-05

Nice supermarket in the country. Good selection. Meat department and the cooking spices are second to none. Pet food selection is a little small. Navigating the store is difficult for first timers.Hey went to this store today. I must withdraw my statement about difficulty navigating this store. Major changes just happened and it's much easier to get around. Especially if your not already familiar with it. Good changes South Dayton Super Duper!

The Mobile Jockey

2023-05

Overall a nice store and nice selection of stuff but there's one person there who's been rude to me everytime I've gone there otherwise I'd give it 5 stars

Elizabeth Contrera

2022-05

Prices are not accurate on personal website and fb as well. I tried to order a pizza special and the price is more than double of what their menu and Facebook says. I asked to honor the special as it is on fb Google and their website and they lady on the phone would not and said it’s not up to her nor her manager to correct prices on their website ect. I’m honestly very disappointed that they couldn’t honor the special I understand prices go up but to more than double them and not update anything is misleading and the lady on the phone also said it confuses a lot of customers….

Brandon Schuster

2012-05

This review is for their doughnuts:They may perhaps be the best ever made! My friend lives nearby and was kind enough to get me some. I do not know what they do different but they are AWESOME! The cream filled doughnuts are much richer than most. You MUST try them.

Luann Schleicher

2022-05

We drove 18 miles to go to the bakery .. we bought two apple fritters and they were very doughy and only half baked.. Usually the bakery has wonderful bake goods.. we normally go there for their sun flower bread which is fantastic.. this was a very rare occasion and don't let this one review stop you from trying their fantastic baked goods .. this bakery puts all bakeries to shame in a 50 mile radius .. Thank you for the selection and flavor of your bake goods..

Lindsay Horning

2018-05

Amazing selection! very traditional experience, like before the super stores when your local shop had everything you need and take pride in their services. Donuts are the best, i drive 20mins one way just for one 😍

Priscilla Lycett

2018-05

Great place to do your shopping and the best hand cut meats and home made donuts. You also can get food made to order from their Delhi. What a lot of good food cooked to go with you. Also have a self service gas station. 😀🤓😎🇺🇸🇺🇸🌞🤗

R L

2020-05

Great selection and variety of items for a small town grocery store. Prices are slightly higher but you’re paying extra for the convenience. Friendly customer service. Just wish they had restrooms that are easily Accessible and not tucked away in some back room. Would come back but with an empty bladder.

Adam Buzzard

2023-05

Great Small Town Grocery Store! Updated and Tidy! They carry delicious hard to find products like Byler's Relish House Pickles, Relishes, Jams, and Jellies!

Jeremy Koszelak

2023-08

Great grocery store and you find items not usually found at the major stores.

Hillarey Schultz

2019-05

The best donuts. 1 of the few that still has a scratch bakery. Awesome sales on meat with loyalty card price busters. Also bring your groceries out and load for you ( without you even asking)😀

Harvey Hostetler

2019-05

Absolutely love this place the staff always greets you with a smile and they always have people there to ring everything up and their donuts are the best donuts I have ever had an I grew up amish just try them