The Bay Street

Denise Smith

2023-09

4 of us visited for the 1st time Friday at 5:30. We had the crab cake appetizers, the full filet, Bay Street Shrimp, stuffed pork chop, and lobster mac and cheese. I would go back for the crab cakes. They were fantastic! The filet was perfect, and the bay street shrimp and pork chop stuffed with mozzarella and basil were very good. I loved the mashed potatoes. The lobster mac and cheese was a disappointment. The noodles were soggy and had a bit too much salt. The restaurant was dated and could use some decor updates, plus it has accessibility issues (for the blind) . Low plants on deck walking to the door, uneven flooring, The wait staff seemed ambivalent to their customers. Prices were very high but the food that was good was very good!

Thomas Kubiak

2023-09

…More

Linda Clark

2023-07

I had a very nice dining experience at The Bay Street! It was a higher end meal but one I felt comfortable eating in jeans. It is best to make a reservation. I was seated in the bar area without one but ordered from the dining room menu. They didn't forget about me though! They were friendly and attentive. I felt comfortable dining alone.No one wore a mask, employees or patrons, so that does not appear to be required for dining here.I ordered a pasta dish, Michael Stewart's Square One Key West, with green, red and yellow peppers, spicy sausage, maybe Andouille, chicken, zucchini, spinach, enormous shrimp and scallops. It came with a side salad and bread. The bar was active and I understand the drinks are great. Of course this recommendation came from the barkeep, so it may be slightly prejudiced.I missed the Naples Grape festival, so I thought I'd better order a grape pie to go! If it is anything like the dinner, I don't think my high expectations will be disappointed!

M R

2023-06

Service was great.Food and experience not as good as in the past. Did they sell the place?I raved to our party about the food and the house made bread that I remembered so fondly, but was seriously disappointed to find store bought Italian. The butter was great though.The potatoes and corn were on the cold side of luke warm and tasted like reheated leftovers, which would explain the temperature, was not the best experience for $80 per entree.The oysters on the half shell were wonderful, but raw oysters kind of make themselves and are hard to mess up.Dinner for three with drinks and shared appetizer $450.Oh, and the bs $15 'maintenace fee' added to our bill means we are never going back.

Jw

2023-05

The absolute most amazing food ever. A small place with top notch service and the most amazing food ever. The Martini size and selection is ridiculous

Lynne Shaffer

2021-05

Stunningly amazing!! Pics or words can NOT describe this place..... Total must see! Amazing views all the way around! Breathtaking! Must see for YOURSELF! Ill post more pics Tmw!

Clivis Multrim

2023-09

Walked in last Saturday. No greeter/seater. Sat at table for over 20 minutes with no service. Went up to ask if dining room was open and was informed dining room was fully booked for the evening and would I like to see a menu. If you aren’t going to serve us why do I need a menu? I have never been treated like this by people, two women, with such eye rolling snooty attitudes. They were downright nasty. Was it my attire(jeans and t-shirt)? The staff definitely need some remedial training in customer service and common courtesy. And I have to question the overall cleanliness.

Anthony Butera

2021-05

This place is always outstanding !! It's my first Summer in Sodus Point and it's hands down the best restaurant in the area.

Helena

2023-05

we miss the old Bay Street. the eclectic decor is the same, the martini book is still there but the atmosphere and the spirit is gone. What a shame. We used to get served fresh, warm homemade bread, and banana bread. The food was real creole, spicy. The fried oysters were to die for. It used to be very special.

Linda Sergeant

2023-05

We love to eat at Bay Street. This restaurant consistently gives a wonderful experience. The food is absolutely excellent and the martini’s are so fun! They have a different menu to choose from and the choices are all delicious. One of my favorites is the Sea Bass and my husband loves the Stuffed pork chop.My adult children from out of state request a dinner at Bay Street every time they come home to visit. It makes a special treat for all!!

Debbie

2023-10

…More

Johnathan Blades

2023-09

…More

Dave “Doodles” Newman

2023-05

Very cool spot. Seems many patrons are regs... (Norm!) old hotel turned into The Bay Street restaurant. We were there for drinks... 73 different types of martinis. I prefer bourbon so I had a Frank the Tank. They offer what I would call dessert drinks... mixed with ice cream, caramel, shaved chocolate...I guess anything you can think of really...

Kelley Petock

2023-05

The drinks are to DIE for. Pages and pages of delicious cocktails on the menu. If it's in season check out the Back Alley Grill sushi food truck while you're there. Life changing sushi. Absolutely order the sushi garbage plate.

Monica Macaluso

2023-05

My husband and I had dinner on 11/10/22. Our server was Julie and she did a good job. My seafood was delicious, but my husband's steak dinner was lukewarm. Unfortunately, the owner was not willing to honor a gift card we had for $100 because she said that it had expired. She did pay for a round of drinks, but I felt that she was quite dismissive about our disappointment. I believe that NYS law does not allow for expired gift certificates, and I will be contacting the owner.

rick r

2023-05

The restaurant is way overpriced for the quality of food and decor. Our server was beyond rude and rolled her eyes at points. We left our vehicle parked In their lot and walked to a nearby bar after dinner which is when their server stated "I hope you enjoyed the free parking." I will never return.

R W

2023-05

Per my sister in law the lobster Mac and cheese is the best she has ever had!! Martinis were good as well! Love the side car for dirty martini which was delicious!!

Scott Schabel

2023-11

Always outstanding. Bay Street is a guaranteed great experience, not just a meal. You start with an extensive offering of martinis and Manhattans complimented by a remarkable wine list. The appetizers and entrées are far from the "bar and grill" offerings available elsewhere in the area. Everything is fresh and prepared to order. Intertwined with the food is truly professional service. Of course such an experience is not cheap, but it is worth every penny, especially when you have something to really celebrate. Make your reservation early so their availability can match your schedule.

Char Passero

2019-05

We were in there earlier today and ordered one of the specialty martinis that included ice cream. We had been there before and drove a half hour to have this particular drink. The young bartender gave us the drink without the ice cream. She mumbled that it would come later. How does one serve a drink with ingredients missing? The bartender was very rude about it. When she got the ice cream about 10 minutes later she then through the little spoon in the drink. I would not go back to this place because of the service. The owner or manager did come by but offered nothing butThat it had been a bad start to the evening. I would have expected a more professional bartender in this type of place.

David Lynch

2020-05

Excellent food and very attentive wait staff. Had a family get together there and enjoyed the entire experience. Martini Bar has some unusual fare and goes well with the relaxed atmosphere and great staff.

Scott Stocking

2022-05

Very disappointing. Heard good things thought would have drinks and dinner. Bartender complained nonstop from the time we walked in and made us feel so unwelcome we left without ordering anything. Maybe she had a bad day, maybe they only like locals, but in either case we won’t be going back

Matt C

2017-05

Great experience. Highly recommend going here for a fine dinner or just drinks. Food and drinks are top notch, service was outstanding. The cleanliness was a shock... I always have to clean my silverware at every place I have ever dined, not here silverware was spotless. I tip my hat to the owners for an excellent experience.

Brooke Ferguson

2020-05

My favorite place to go for dinner and drinks when I am at sodus point. They have a great martini menu and I’ve never had a bad meal there. It is casual dining so the clientele a more mature class of people which makes it an enjoyable atmosphere.

Amanda Morgan

2019-05

We started out by choosing a martini! A little difficult since there are so many to choose from, but I love choices! Also the bartenders are very nice and willing to help you find your right martini match! The martinis are strong and so delicious! Then we were seated for dinner, we started with oysters Tiffany and they were AMAZING! The seasoning on the perfectly fried oysters was a mouthful of ocean heaven and then the mornay sauce on top just put them over the edge! I had the special of Chilean sea bass with a cheese soufflé sauce. The fish was perfectly cooked and huge! Give this place a try! You won’t be disappointed!

Steven Bates

2018-05

The owners and staff are very friendly and the food is great as well as consistent. They have a large selection of Martini's to meet anyone's taste. If you haven't been there it's worth the trip and if you have been there, then you will be back.

Jack Steinkamp

2023-06

Great food and drink. Friendly and knowledgeable staff. A must if you visit Sodus Point. A diamond in the ruff.

Paul Redden

2019-05

Ladies love the Martinis at the Bay Street, they have a menu just for them! ( The chocolate one is a fan favorite). After a day of playing on the water, the Bay Street is one of several off the water/walking distance destinations for food and drinks with friends. You can get a great burger there but their chef's prepare a menu with specialty items that are a cut above the rest. Limited tables so make reservations early.

Garrett Schloss

2021-05

Great food. Amazing drinks. And an amazing staff really make this spot a gem. And the cherry on top, is the absolutely beautiful décor. Absolutely worth a visit during your stay in town.

Richard Norris

2020-05

The bar area was very busy when we arrived with several friends. The 2 bartenders were looking at something in their cell phones for at least 5 minutes, which was frustrating. They apologized after they realized people had been waiting for drinks. After that they were very good. They are known for their Martinis

Bill L.

2018-05

Fine dining with a Key West/ Caribbean flair, paired with the finest cocktails you can imagine, and served up in a warm and welcoming atmosphere by the best chefs, wait staff, and mixologsts you could ask for. One of the happiest places you'll ever visit.