Gilligan's Island

Josh

2023-08

The Buffalo chicken sub was just chicken tenders, topped with cheese, lettuce, and ranch... disappointed.I asked the girl on the phone if the onion rings were breaded or battered, and she replies " I honestly don't know" and never answers. After seeing them I understand why she may have been confused as they were the most sickening things to look at, and not in a good way. They were dripping oil, soggy and very thick onions, burnt in only a few spots, and the crust oddly just slid right off. Huge disappointment as I absolutely love onion rings.The curly fries are honestly just the same as Arby's.For spending almost 30 dollars on a dinner for my partner and I to spilt it was utterly disgusting. I would have been better off putting my tenders on a hot dog bun....*Update: stopped in for ice cream and ended up throwing it away and getting a refund due to their being hair and other objects in it, pictures posted*

rltbw

2024-03

…More

Savannah Johnson

2024-03

…More

Kelly Tiberio

2024-04

…More

Excelsior Pilgrim

2023-12

Gilligan's, NEEDS to be a HISTORIC LANDMARK!When going to/leaving Binghamton or Pennsylvania, we always make a obsessive stop for Gilligan's. Never have we selected a ice cream, that's out-of-stock. And we order something different each visit. The inside, to most, may seem nothing fancy, and is very typical small-town diners, which can have better food than those over-rated fancy restaurants. Need a meal, they've got an entire menu. Ice Cream, is the most popular, all four seasons. The staff(The Gals), is always busy and very considerate. Public restroom, is kept clean, and the kitchen area, where all the ice cream is, is very sanitary. Three important factors to have returning customers. I find that average & below average Google reviews, are customers whom have poor attitudes and a general "I hate the world," moral. Ya stop-in at Gilligan's, ya just can't give'em a bad review when you taste the ice cream. Outstanding. Tasteful. Prompt. Welcoming. Devoted. Best-of-all: Ya cannot possibly miss the location. It's on Main Street. Just make sure you are attentive and obeying the speed limit. You'll get a ticket for going more than 5 mph over the posted speed limit.

Sarah Bennett

2024-05

The Mr Howell burger is terrific, well done! And the pineapple coconut twist is yum, yum, yummy!Kid-friendliness: Family place, operated and served by decent folks.

Timothy Miller

2024-04

…More

Chandler Mills

2023-11

…More

Tammie Marshall

2024-01

…More

Jay Warner

2023-06

I've been eating their sense I was a kid. It's one of those places you just want to hang out at because a lot of friends work there though high school. The food is always good not to mention the ice cream that everyone loves that brings you back just about every time you bypass it 😋. It's one of those places that you hope we'll always be around for generations to come. To sum it up all the locals just love it. Those who grew up with with this place and moved away when they come home to visit always stop by to visit and eat.

Sean Cone

2024-04

…More

Tina Jacobs

2023-09

…More

LeRoy Burly

2022-05

One of the best places to eat in Sherburne and the surrounding areas. Pictured is the special today, crispy chicken santa fe wrap and it's amazing. They need to add this to the regular menu. As always amazing service, food and atmosphere.

Dorene Gosart

2024-02

…More

James Johnson

2023-08

…More

Jake Morley

2023-10

…More

Ethan Cook

2023-11

…More

Joshua Jeffer

2023-12

…More

Ken Breitenbecker

2019-05

This is Sherburne New York's best kept secret. A Hometown Ice cream shop that has many great flavors of ice cream and great food also. They constantly do fundraiser for there community to give back. Check out the many flavors in photo. In our last trip in March of 2019. We found a reason to go there 5 of the 6 days we were there. Yes it's that darn good.

David Tooley

2023-08

Best burger I have had in a very very long time. This is the last of the classic ice cream joints in the area. All the others in the surrounding countys have gone so downhill (mostly bought by downstate NYC people and driven to cheap ingredients and poor service).What you get here is NOT that. Quality food, great ingredients and great staff. Putting this place as my #1 burger in the tri-county area.

Laurie Smith

2024-04

I would normally give Gilligan's 5 stars, because the food is consistently delicious. They have the best burgers, surpassed only by their amazing ice cream. Workers are exceptionally friendly, takeout is ready quickly, and special requests are accommodated easily. They give back to the community, a definite plus.

Jared Marvin

2023-07

Old school roadside grill and ice cream shop. We only got ice cream but their burgers looked and sounded amazing. Ice cream was unique and homemade. A gem to definitely try if you're staying or passing through.Parking: Plenty of parking. Easy in and out.

Sarah Williams

2023-08

…More

Rich Lomnicki

2023-05

…More

Anthony Cardosa

2021-05

One of the best burgers I've ever had! Very friendly folk. Ice cream was also very very good and the location is comfy.

Szabolcs Beke

2024-01

…More

Matthew Zifchock

2023-05

This little, old-timey spot is a sleeper. The outside is a little nondescript and if you blink you might miss it. If you have the chance, don't pass it up. Along with the vintage hamburger shack offerings there's more variety than one might think. The ice cream is superb and the sundaes come with the old standard nuts and cherry on top, but those are just the start! They serve pints/tubs of ice cream to go. Gilligan's is a place for all seasons with ample seating inside when the temperature dips and a classic drive-in during the warmer months. The timeless and the modern are all here, so there's fare for all diets and styles. Don't pass this place up, you'll be glad you didn't!

Tony Schultheis

2023-05

My wife and I have been going to Gilligan's usually once a weekend for a burger, fries, soda, and ice cream afterwards. We often order one of their liquor flavored cakes for a party. It's a nice treat going there.The caveat is....that when you order a burger you are asked to pull to the parking lot and one of the young girls brings the order to your car. It seemed that over the past several months the food was coming out cold.A couple of weeks ago, my wife and I waited for 40 minutes for our meal. I finally drove over to the window to see where our order was. The young girl asked if I had an order number....they never give an order number or receipt. I told them that if they could not supply the food, that I would want my money back. After all, $27.00 for two burger meals is no bargain.I was told that the girl who took our order went home and did not tell anyone. They asked that I park and they would bring out a new order. They did, in a timely manner, and refunded our money besides.Now, I would of never have brought this up except, yesterday my wife and I went there and ordered our usual. We waited again about 40 minutes. I was just about to go back to the window, when the girl came to my car with our order. She must of drew the short straw to be the one to bring us our meal. She appeared distraught as she handed it over and hesitantly told us that our order was misplaced. So now for $27.00 we had a COLD burger and fries....hardly appetizing on a cool fall afternoon.The owners of Gilligan's are hard workers. I am sure that they would not want their customers treated this way.I implore them to be more aware of their employees actions and hopefully implement a system from preventing this from happening again.If I was to have another incident such as this, I would think my business with Gilligan's would be in jeopardy.

Lance DeForest

2024-04

…More

Holly Williams

2023-07

…More