Rinaldo's Pizzeria & Catering

Nossa Terra

2024-03

Rinaldo’s in Elbridge, NY, is more than just a small casual pizzeria; it's a hidden gem offering both fantastic pizza and delicious Italian cuisine at unbeatable prices.During my visit, I indulged in the Upside Pizza lunch special, which included two monster slices and a drink for just $7! The pizza was outstanding, It was an incredible value, and the portions were extremely generous. After enjoying the pizza, we had the pleasure of speaking with the chef, who recommended trying several amazing dishes and I settled on ordering Nonna’s Eggplant and Chicken Parmesan for dinner. The food was so flavorful and plentiful that we couldn't help but rave about it. Rinaldo’s exceeded our expectations, proving to be more than just a pizzeria; it's a fantastic Italian eatery that I highly recommend to anyone looking for great food and amazing value.

Katie Weatherstone

2023-05

We LOVE Rinaldos!!! The in-house smoked, roast beef subs are probably my favorite but I also can’t get enough of the riggies!!!!!! And the wings!!!! Top notch food, huge portions, any of the pastas will be plenty for two!!! And true NY pizza! Where can you go wrong!?!?!!!!!! 5 stars *****

Bobby-Jo Bly-Owens

2023-10

…More

Caleb Kliphon

2023-12

Seen this place for months driving by and finally stopped in. The pizza is amazing nice crust good tasty toppings salad was very fresh good dressing and the French fry’s were to die for lol if I could I would give a better rating but I can definitely say I will be coming back soon.Parking: Parking right in the front allows for easy acessKid-friendliness: As I was eating my food a young couple came in with their child and the owner and employees were very nice and considerate of the young girl

Heather Campbell

2023-09

…More

Eric Spafford

2024-04

…More

Katharine Moore

2023-09

…More

Andy

2023-08

…More

Aj Wilson

2023-05

Love Love Love everything I’ve ordered at Rinaldos! Every time I decided to try something new which is totally not like I’ve been more than satisfied! Just got the Penne Alfredo and added chicken and it’s probably the best Alfredo I have ever tasted! Thank you Rinaldos♥️

Ashley Waelti

2020-05

We love their food! Our choices in Elbridge are limited, but we do have some good eats. This is one of them! Their pizzas are always bomb and the staff is really friendly. Met the owner and he was so personable and kind, asking me about what we ordered from them in the past. He really cares about feedback and making his place great! :) The Shrimp Scampi is also a real treat! Can't wait to try more things on the menu.

John R

2021-05

Really good pizza and medium wings. Would recommend.

Sharon Morsdorf

2021-05

THE Best Pizza and wings around! Thank you for always having fresh homemade sausage, meatballs, sauce and dough. The dinners are EXCELLENT and the box meals are enough to feed the 2 of us for 3 nights. Worth every penny and would never go anywhere else. Too bad there are only 5 stars. And don’t worry some people find fault in everything😀

David Schwarting

2020-05

Great tasting food and good portion, you won't go hungry. I had the Chicken Marsala which was very tender chicken, fresh mushrooms with a great Marsala sauce! I have had many items off the menu and you can tell the flavors are from fresh homemade ingredients, not frozen. Worth the drive, worth the price!

Kimberly J

2021-05

Rinaldo's has quickly become my favorite place. We do a family Friday takeout, everyone has their favorite picks. I love the eggplant parm dinner. Its absolutely delicious but also the portion size is impressive. I get four meals from it so I have tasty food all weekend. The fried mushrooms are a guilty pleasure I'll add in. I've tried too many items to go into detail about each. Never a complaint from the family (and we have a few picky members). It's definitely a 10/10 from myself and I highly recommend them.

Paula Sanz

2023-11

…More

Andrew

2023-11

…More

Deborah Reynolds

2023-06

The only place I get my Pizza from, ordered Chicken Riggies for dinner tonight and they were the best I have ever had, more than enough for one meal also, love Rinaldos

Sesiley

2022-05

Great food and the owners are very nice people. I live walking distance and this is my go to spot. I’m not originally from this area but Rinaldo’s is my favorite pizza around over anywhere in auburn or syracuse ! They put love in their food and genuinely want their customers to be satisfied.

Twitchy Toki

2021-05

I have had a super hard time finding decent calzones and the like around our area. These guys knocked it out of the ball park. We had a supreme calzone and a cheese calzone and both were amazingly cheesy, and stuffed to the brim with toppings. (Most places its mostly air with a few toppings.) We also ordered some wings and even through the sauce you can taste the wings themselves had good flavor.The delivery guy was super friendly too. Thanks guys!

Jeremiah Jaeger

2023-05

Keep it local, keep it small. These guys have great food, great customer service and they are local. Besides great pizza, wings, sandwiches and dinners you have to try their cannoli's! Give them a try, you won't be disappointed.

Denise Ryan

2022-05

Ordered ahead of time for a bday party. Delivery was on spot and the sheet pizza was perfect even the onions and peppers cooked on spot ( not over cooked ) wings were great . Everyone at the party was very happy .

Tifford1 Bell

2022-05

Cook and waitress spent a long time with what appeared to be two liberal customers. The table that I eventually sat down at was dirty and had to be wiped down. Some card board shavings were on the table.I was ready to order but the waitress was locked into a extended conversation with the two liberals.I ordered a calzone. About 30 minutes for it to come out. It looked beautiful on the outside but the meat on the inside was actually cold. I mean refrigerator cold. I asked for ice water and I got a solo cup of warm water.I'm not going to eat the calzone and I will pay for the meal but I will never eat here again. HUGE DISAPPOINTMENT.

Nick Hallinan

2022-05

Amazing food. You can definitely tell most of things you order on the menu is homemade. Best prices and definitely the most QUALITY driven restaurant in the area. Really can’t go wrong with this place. Pizza, pasta dishes, subs, salads, cannolis are all 10/10!

Robert Murphy

2021-05

Never had an issue with Rinaldos, best pizza shop to ever take over the location, smoked BBQ every Wednesday for a very reasonable price! Super kind and caring employees that take pride in their craft. Worth a drive from anywhere in CNY!

R williams

2023-05

Great pizzia ! Very clean . Staff is always nice. Owner really cares about his product. Highly recommend to anyone .

Cassandra Page

2022-05

This place is the best Italian restaurant around. Owners are amazing and really put in so much work to ensure their food is top quality. Their chicken riggies and garlic knots are to die for. Be sure to check this place out if you're in town.

Dennis Pelmear

2022-05

We had Italian sausage subs and cold subs last night. Excellent. Everything was excellent. We've had their pizzas and wings many times. Also very good.

charles coats

2021-05

Outstanding food have never had anything bad from them. Very friendly to the customer and very clean when ever I have picked up food. Delivery is fast and food has never been cold on a delivery. Keep up the great service hope you'll be around for a long time.

Michael Ernest

2020-05

My family has ordered from Rinaldos on several occasions. The staff is always kind and welcoming, the kitchen is always spotless, the food is ALWAYS AMAZING! can't say enough positive about this place.Give it a try!

Tina Dann

2021-05

The food is such awesome. We ordered the chicken Alfredo family special it was just GREAT. I can’t pick a favorite food there because they all are good.. The service is always with a smile.