Prattsville Diner

stepha2591

2023-10

…More

Bill Allegretti

2023-10

We stopped here on our way back from Cooperstown; good food, (one of the few places where the coleslaw is actually enjoyable!) generous portions, and wonderful atmosphere. The server was very pleasant. Diner was clean considering we arrived an hour before closing. I was impressed that even though closing time is 2pm none of the staff complained when diners came in 15 minutes prior. As an added plus there was plenty of room in the back lot to park our camper rig, and there's actually YooHoo in the cooler!

Bradlay Pryde

2023-05

We stopped by here after a hike and swimming in the Schohaire Creek. We were hungry and this place absolutely hit the spot. They served us tons of food, were super friendly, and kept it coming with the bottomless iced teas. Total classic American dinner. Would stop by to refuel if you are in the area. Great value! 😁

Wendi Paster

2024-05

…More

James Pipitone

2024-01

It was January of 2018… four friends showed up to what is still considered the greatest diner we have ever been to. Nothing will ever top the authentic delicious breakfast we were served. We talk about this place as though it’s Bethlehem and we are the disciples following the stars to Jesus’s births- it’s that good. God speed and Godbless this place

Eric

2023-05

Sorry.. in hindsight I’ve change this review at the end.. it just didn’t feel right. Prattsville diner seems to have changed hands since the last time I was there. It is still a fine restaurant.. in fact it is better managed. My only complaint would be the pricing is very high for the quality/quantity of food. Serving me a garbage breakfast bowl in a soup cup and slapping a piece of processed cheese on it for 13.99 will have me stopping at other area places. I would like to add i moved to the south were garbage plates are common in mom and pop diners. Lots of peppers, onions, potatoes, meats on a plate. eggs are an unneeded extra if you want. The prices run around $7-8 and its all you can do to finish it. This meal was.. somebody scoop their regular breakfast in a bowl and called it something different🤷‍♂️

Vinny

2023-12

…More

Nancy Wong

2023-06

…More

Allen Wong

2023-06

…More

Paul P

2023-05

Been here a few years ago, Sunday afternoon, it was packed with people, I remember we enjoyed the place. This Sunday it was a different experience, the cheeseburger with fries was absolutely horrible. It's there on the menu: french fries. not the overfried potato chips that I got! "under new management" banner probably explains that... and prices... manhattan prices away from manhattan!

Mary E Proal

2023-07

Decided to stop here while traveling because parking lot was full, always a good sigh of good food, and because we were hungry. Crowded so we sat at the counter, ordered Rubens and a drink from friendly waitress. Within a few minutes she came and got our drinks and moved them and us to a table behind us that had just been emptied and cleaned. Nice move, bigger tip, lol.If I lived close by I'm sure I would be there frequently as we were made to feel welcome and right at home. Did I say the Rubens and coleslaw and Mac salad were delicious? Yes they were and for $40. Including a very nice tip.

Carrie-Jean Cusson

2023-08

…More

James Kolenda

2023-09

…More

Deli Lama

2024-02

…More

Athanacios Lionas

2023-05

Great service. Got a bacon cheeseburger deluxe with disco fries and let me tell you it hit the spot. New management is on point. Servers are great and have great feel for their customers. I’ve been coming here for 30 years and what a difference from last owner. These people care for their customers and deserve repeat business. Looking forward to many more meals to come.

Kim Kravitz

2023-05

Super cute little diner! Food was great and the staff was friendly!

Marla T

2023-10

Best biscuits and gravy!!! The mushroom swiss burger is on point!! The food was amazing and inexpensive. Service was a delight, staff was seen cleaning and being very friendly with guests. I can't wait to come back and have their sausage gravy on pancakes. Apparently, it's a patron fav!Kid-friendliness: Lots of kid breakfast and lunch options.

Ricky Cunha

2023-05

…More

Derek French

2023-09

…More

doreen bacotti

2023-05

…More

Allison McDonough

2023-05

Delicious, friendly, and the most beautiful view!

Nelson Martineau

2021-05

Very good food, very welcoming and kind. Would def recommend to anyone visiting the area

Joanie Axelbaum

2019-05

Great country diner. Had a grilled chicken sandwich that was actually beyond expectations. Really loved the country feel of this place.

James Lawrence

2022-05

Good, great service. We enjoyed our visit.

Debra Wood

2023-05

It was clean, wait staff was nice. Food was horrid. They definitely need a new cook. Ordered two eggs over easy and they were so well done you couldn't eat them. Fries tasted like the oil hasn't been changed in 6 months or more. Will I go back? No.

Nick Guttormson

2024-03

…More

Nikko Bacci

2023-09

Stopped in traveling through NY and had some of the best breakfast around bacon, eggs, hash brows very fresh and the staff is awesome definitely recommend trying this place out!!

Jessica Brown

2023-09

…More

Anna Hernandez

2023-09

…More

Sold By Syl

2023-09

…More