Best Friends Thrift Shop

4.6 (51)

6616 NY-56, Potsdam, NY 13676
(680) 333-0441
facebook.com

Claimed
Thrift store

From the business

  • Small business

Service options

  • In-store shopping

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

patrick merithew

2024-02

good stuff, good staff, good prices. wish they stayed open a little longer but i adjust. items rotate pretty well

Chicken Little

2023-09

Shopping was very nice but when I donated 2 times now they judge me wrost then my mother in law. At this point I'm no longer going to shop or donated.

Jerry Deon

2022-06

Besides having a lot of neat things to look over and purchase at dirt cheap prices, you are helping to fund the local humane society Donuts a win win. Staff is always friendly and store us very organized. Stop in

Elaine Murray

2022-06

Great store! Friendly staff, good assortment, very fair prices. And my dog is welcome to shop with me. That just puts this shop over the top!

Cole DeSantis

2017-06

Not only are the prices beyond outrageous, the staff has no problems insulting you for no reason. They even insulted my infant daughter because she was interested in the toys. Twice now I've been insulated by staff for pointing out the sales that they made themselves. The prices aren't based off of appraisals, they're based off of what people are trying to sell similar items on ebay (they now put the "ebay price" on the sticker, so I have to imagine many people have said something about the prices) or just a random outrageous number they must have pulled from where the sun doesn't shine. Wouldn't recommend wasting your time here, which makes me sad to say because the animal shelter is a place I hold dear to me, but with the combination of rude staff and horrendous prices for what is mostly junk, I can't in good concince recommend you even step foot into this establishment.

Marcella Laramay

2015-06

This is NOT your average thrift store. You won't find rack after rack of tattered clothing or poorly organized piles of junk collecting dust. This place is expertly organized and boasts some of the highest quality 'treasures' you can find at a store like this. It's like a boutique/consignment shop, but at thrift store prices!! Everything is displayed properly, well-lit and has its own section - electronics, toys and games, books, kitchen appliances, crafts and fabrics, household - you don't have to guess where something might be kept. They seem to have new items out every day - forget that "well, maybe next week" feeling! I visit Best Friends Thrift once a week and I never leave empty-handed. The staff are also an absolute pleasure to interact with!

Thrifty Shopper

2015-06

I used to frequent this thrift shop once or twice a week and loved it. Unfortunately, it would appear that the staff have begun using eBay and the like to price the donated goods, and the prices have become prohibitive (and sometimes downright ridiculous) in the past few months. I used to leave Best Friends with bags and boxes full of great finds. Now I rarely swing in and when I do, I'm almost insulted by the prices. Books marked at 9, 10 and even TWENTY dollars that sell for 4 bucks on Amazon...brand new. Camera lenses for $15 that sell on eBay for...$15. Sewing machines with notes written on them - "$375 - sells for $500!". Maybe, new in the box at a retail store. But this is a thrift store and these items are second hand and have been donated. It almost feels as though my sympathies for the SPCA are being taken advantage of, and I don't like it. Charging the going eBay rate at a thrift store is insulting in and of itself - listing items to sell on eBay is an exhaustive process. You have to research, photograph, and describe every nuance of the item meticulously. You have to monitor the item, answer numerous questions about it, fill in all the product specs and then, when it sells, you have to pack it and bring it to the post office and pay to have it shipped. Then you pay fees to eBay and to Paypal. There is a LOT of work that goes into selling on eBay, and throwing something that was given to you on a shelf and saying "well it goes for 50 bucks on eBay!" is a slap in the face to those of us that spend hours upon hours trying to sell our stuff there. It's a lot of work. If you want eBay prices, sell it on eBay. Otherwise, go back to being a thrift store for a good cause and price your second-hand, donated items accordingly.

alice sokolowski

2019-06

This is one of the best stores we have ever been to. People are friendly, prices are awesome and the return policy ( which I've never had to use ) is really good.

Liz Clarke

2021-06

Something for everyone, lots of different things, great prices saved me lots of money compared to even walmart and the dollar store and support the animal shelter so the money goes to a great cause and buying things used is also great for thr environment

Bonnie Boyd

2018-06

Great values. Super staff. Stuff you can't find in other stores! And it is all for the animals!

Waring Webb

2021-06

Great selection of things. Got a camp chef stove, tools and some cooking utensils for our camper.

Michelle Boots

2021-06

Awesome place to shop. Stop on and browse. You are sure to find something

kathryn smith

2021-06

The BEST place for thirty shopper, added more space more stuff. AWESOME

David Fecketter

2021-06

All proceeds of this shop go to potsdam animal shelter. Please support this great local effort run by volunteers.

Paula Parks

2023-06

Fun and Interestingl Love seeing the DOGS too!

Dar Clough-Engel

2022-06

Well organized thrift shop for a great cause! Also, pets are welcome, which is amazing!

Brendan Bush

2018-06

Always really cool and fun stuff to find here, and the finding is half the fun! Very kind staff.

Tammy Rutley

2021-06

I love this shop . Always find a little something good.

ERIC HUNT

2018-06

This store has a lot of great stuff st reasonable prices

Jackie Herber

2018-06

Such a wonderful place to find little things and it helps the animals out too!!

James Rudd

2021-06

Fun place to look for inexpensive books,games and toys!

Sara Lynch

2018-06

Love the variety available

Matt McLear

2023-06

Great staff great variety of stuff to choose from

Al Bel

2018-06

Nice place with not always reasonable price tag

Gloria Enslow

2021-06

Never disappoints. Always find a little something.

Lisa Amati

2022-06

A great thrift store that benefits homeless animals.

Jennifer Ruggles

2022-06

Fun place to find neat things

Mary Dawley

2019-06

Always find something in this store.

Wholesale Furniture & Mattress

2019-06

What a nice place to have in Potsdam.

Lisa Rathbun

2019-06

TONS of stuff!! It's a must go

Opening Hours

Monday 10 AM-5 PM
Tuesday 10 AM-5 PM
Wednesday 10 AM-5 PM
Thursday 10 AM-5 PM
Friday 10 AM-5 PM
Saturday 10 AM-4 PM
Sunday Closed

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet