Kaseys Cast-A-Ways Bait and Tackle Shop and fun farm

4.6 (63)

102 Schoolhouse Rd, Port Jervis, NY 12771
(845) 858-2001
kaseyscastaways.com

Claimed
Bait shop

From the business

  • Small business

Service options

  • Curbside pickup

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Harold Downing

2023-07

Went to pick up some fishing gear. the gentleman there was really cool had a good conversation and helped me with new places to check out to fish. After getting lures and live bait I took my son to pet the farm animals and he loved it . Definitely will be returningP.s shoes will get dirty so make sure you wear boots to see the animals

Stefanie C.

2020-05

Awesome place!!! Took my 3yr old and we had lots of fun. You just walk in the gate and you're in with the animals. Bunnies, goats, sheep, ducks and ponies. They all get along and were friendly. Highly recommend this place to all animal lovers and good for kids too. My son loved it!!

Tiffany Megan

2023-05

My boyfriend and I stopped in just to pick up some bait, we ended up spending over an hour there talking to Linda (who is so nice!), petting all the animals and then doing some fishing. We even got to feed the baby lambs! It was a whole experience that we’ll definitely be back to do again!

John Ruiz

2023-05

They have a decent selection of gear. I found the staff to be very rude and not too child friendly. On a better note I've been kicked out of better places than this. 1 recommendation. Widen your lanes! It was way too claustrophobic in there! Good luck and work on those people skills!😃

Tiny Kitchen Treats Team _

2020-05

Probably one of the most unique places around. Linda, the owner, runs her bait shop and tiny farm out of her home. We were immediately greeted by two gentle dogs and family and friends were there hanging out.Most importantly-The animals are gentle (all of the Shetland ponies are therapy horses that visit children’s hospitals and therapy centers) and well cared for. You just open the gate and off you go to play with them. Goats, sheep, bunnies and so many tiny ponies. My daughter had the best time. Especially walking “my friend Tucker” around. There is even a little pond where you can fish. We bought some bait and rented a pole.Really just wonderful experience for a really fair price (adults don’t have to pay and there’s no time limit). We will definitely be back again and again. It feels good to support good people, and fellow girl boss small business owners.

Chris Palmer

2022-05

Off the beaten trail, but has everything you need to make a day of fishing. The mini petting animal farm is a plus as well for the kids and grand kids.( I'm a kid when it comes to that too). There is a fishing pond in back I believe that can be used for a small fee as well. Nice people that own the place which just makes it more of a fun place to go to.

Meagan Centeno

2023-05

Drove 40 minutes to visit. Upon arrival, we were greeted with a plethora of “Trump” regalia. As an inter-racial traveling couple, this was uncomfortable for us. We ultimately decided to leave without interacting with anyone. Word of caution for fellow POC travelers.

Brett Wright

2021-05

You will be quite surprised when you walk in. She has a lot of fishing gear and other sporting goods. The minnows lasted thru fishing trip. Lots of lures and a buy 10doz minnows get doz free. I enjoyed my visit. Check out the animals while there n donate to a good cause

Michael Anton

2019-05

An assortment of live bait including minnows and worms. They have a decent variety of tackle, lures, and rod & reels. They even have fishing licenses. All the basic necessities for a day of fishing. The owners have always been super nice and friendly.

Ryan Feeley

2022-05

Very friendly service and a great selection of fishing supplies. The animals are also very calm and love being brushed. Definitely worth a visit.

Greg Zambrzycki

2016-05

Just what we needed in the area. Service is simply outstanding and the bait shop is always well stocked. Truly a 24 hours operation, not to mention the petting zoo. You guys rock!

STEVEN Hall

2021-05

well stocked with a little bit of everythingThey also issue fishing licenses..went in with my uncle to get his renewed and picked up some fresh bait and a few spinners great service...support your local mon and pop stores whenever possible

Tater Tot

2017-05

Such a unique place, absolutely amazing, if i wake up at 4 to go fishing i can stop buy and grab any lures i lost on my prior trip, selection of lures is decent not bass pro shops but they have what you need and are open 24-7 and are super friendly and helpful.

James Gardner

2021-05

Great local bait and tackle shop! They have a huge selection of everything! The live bait is by far the best around. Stays alive for the entire day. Never disappointed!!! Thanks kaseys!

Michael Iannuzzi

2019-05

Really nice little shop. Had all the necessities you needed for a day on the ice when I went last year, and they came and served us at around 530am! Thanks!

Steve Burke

2018-05

Great little shop, great people running it. AND it's 24 hours! Can't beat it! It is my goto gorgeous bait and tackle.

Green_ Oak_Stables

2019-05

I volunteer there. It's an amazing farm and bait\tackle shop. The owner and animals are very nice. I lover it there!

marie art

2014-05

wow what a place !!!!! these people are always open and friendly even in the weee hours , their bait stays alive longer then anywhere i bought from. ill always go back to kasey's

Basilio Torres

2016-05

Great fishing bait and tackle. Good fishing for the kids. Nice petting zoo also.

Ryan Wright

2018-05

Very nice place and the service was great I plan to shop there for all my fishing needs

Joshua VanStrander

2023-05

Convenient and always has a great selection. Support your local small business

Patrick Minehan

2022-05

Plenty of fishing gear,loaded up on shad darts and flutter spoons,

Becky Sutherland

2022-05

Such a fun and free place to go. God bless them

Kevin Keane

2019-05

Good friendly well stocked bait and tackle shop,

ILL ILL

2017-05

I love this place very very nice people and you can buy everything what you need to buy love love this place😘😘😘👍👍👍😘😘😘

john jack

2018-05

This place is Awesome. They have everything you need and more.

Yadira Caffrey

2020-05

Love this place!! Can't wait to go back.

jorge rivera

2021-05

Excellent service wonderful place for kids too.

James Sexton

2020-05

Very nice place and she is a very pleasant woman

KSD

2019-05

Great selection for a small shop with great people

Opening Hours

Monday 5 AM-8 PM
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday Closed
Thursday 5 AM-8 PM
Friday 5 AM-8 PM
Saturday 5 AM-8 PM
Sunday 5 AM-8 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet