Bagel Barn

Melody Reed

2023-11

…More

Brian Merzbach

2024-02

…More

mandy l

2023-05

hubby and I had a blueberry bagel, egg bagel. Also had sausage egg and cheese and a bacon egg and cheese. SO DELICIOUS. Egg was cooked perfectly and they give a generous amount of cream cheese. Definitely recommend.

Rick Merchberger Jr

2024-03

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ LOVED IT!!!Finally stopped in to try them out ... can't wait to go back. I highly recommend "The Barn" on an Everything Bagel 😍Was soooo mesmerized by the sandwich when it came out ... I forgot to take pics. 🤣

Audra Muscari

2023-12

…More

AJ C

2024-02

Paid $7 & some change for a Egg & Cheese on a bagel ... When I ordered a Sausage Egg & Cheese on a bagel. Big disappointment when I pick it up before I go to work finally get to work open it and this is what I see.

Ray Storms

2023-06

So I went to The Bagel Barn this morning, at 8am. The place was empty. Was very clean and cozy. Nice menu, the female grill cook Very polite, other staff members very quiet? I Ordered a Sandwich called The Barn, 3 meats 3 eggs 3 cheese, on a Everything Bagel with Jalapeño cream cheese! Came to 10$ and change! Got it home opened it up and just about Cried Tears of Joy!!! With every single bite wanting to do the Happy Dance!!! The Flavor Explosion in my mouth was pure Bliss, the Sandwich was Amazing!!! After finishing it I really wanted to Cry, because I didn’t have Another!!! I would have given 5 Stars had I have felt more Welcomed!!! But I will Return Because The Sandwich was Absolutely Amazing!!! It has restored My Faith in Port Jervis in finding a Great Breakfast Sandwich!!! To anyone else calling themselves a Bagel shop, you need to take Notes from this place!!!!

Shadow

2023-05

Fantastic service and amazing food!Everyone here is very kind and respectful.Prices are very affordable and they have fantastic deals. Highly recommend ordering The Barn, by far the best bang for your buck in the area. Can’t be beat!However, the place isn’t 100% perfect.Seems like the staff struggles a bit to get orders right. This is something that will eventually go away as the staff gets more experienced and used to the operation. Weeks later I’m already seeing the improvement!The girl that runs the cashier is very knowledgeable and helpful.Highly recommend this place for breakfast to anyone within driving distance. If I didn’t live as far as I did, I would be going here every morning for breakfast and even return for lunch!Edit: After several visits, the same issue still persists. Unless you are physically ordering in person where you can see your food being made, you have a high chance of items being left out. Originally I believed this may have been due to new staff getting used to the menu items, however, this seems to be a recurring issue months later. Unfortunately, I can no longer recommend this place due to the constant mistakes with my orders.

evelia rodriguez

2023-05

…More

Tammy Tidd

2024-04

…More

Tyler Hoke

2023-10

The employees are wonderful, they work hard and make great food and thats the only reason I go back. The owner parks his tesla in one of the 4 parking spaces (another is taken up by a picnic table that nobody uses) they have every day he's there, forcing anyone who wants to pay him for food to park down the street. He does no work at all, insted he sits around hanging out with his friends shooting the breeze all morning. The amount of ex employee alone is tell tale of poor management, and the worst part is that it's all very fixable but you can't tell someone how to run their business.

Rose E

2024-01

…More

LovleighTM

2023-05

Better than I expected. I will definitely become a regular. The breakfast sandwiches were amazing. A little more pricey but they don't skimp you like some places I have been to. The service was quick and everyone was nice.

CHRISTOPHER P

2023-05

Improvements needed. Bagels are subpar for NY Metro. Start with a better provider or buy a bagel oven. You're literally 1 hour from Monticello where they invented the bagel go up there... Get some tipsAlso, Eat your product and then ask yourself how to make it better! Ask your customers to come in for a tasting!I see you guys are trying and wish you luck. Try to speed up your operation. Painfully disorganized.

Devyn Michael

2023-05

Incredible, probably the best breakfast sandwich in the area. Owner is amazing and 3 breakfast sandwiches loaded up with 2 bags of chips it was $24… overpriced is crazy to say. Great experience and will most definitely recommend.

Sarah Sutton

2023-05

Being born and raised in New Jersey outside of NYC, and now living in PA, it’s hard to find a good bagel around here. When I saw a new bagel place opening up over the bridge in NY I had high hopes. Unfortunately these people have never made bagels before. They are comparable to Lenders or Thomas that you can buy in the grocery store.

Pamela Brewer

2023-05

…More

Mark Hylas

2023-05

…More

Candace Cole

2023-05

…More

Rodney Torres-Mabe

2023-05

This place rocked. Great service. Great food. Wish we could have stayed for lunch. Those subs sounded amazing.

tokindaddy

2023-07

Ordered one of their breakfast sandwiches. It was one of.the best sandwiches I've ever had. 😋I highly recommend.

Pamela Clackworthy

2023-05

Bagels are a disappointment. Cream cheese toppings are good. Service is fair. Service is slow and inconsistent. If you want something fast, go somewhere else.

Emre

2023-05

Bagels ain't bad just wish they at least had more options for people who don't eat pork, other shops around here at least have turkey bacon or sausage.

KRZJ KRZJ

2023-12

…More

Tom Faggione

2023-05

Super clean, friendly, and inviting.Hot, yummy coffee and a wide selection of breakfast options.Great atmosphere to sip, chat, and enjoy.Clean - Friendly - Yummy

Rick Broas

2023-06

Visited today for the first time. Bagels were great and service was fast! Will be back

christine k

2023-05

I wouldn't go there for bagels but their other breakfasts are good. Staff is friendly... Prices aren't bad

Green Scare

2023-09

I have been eating on and off there since the place open. As of today, this might be my last time eating their. This is why there is no consistency.

Charles Magos

2023-05

…More

Jordan Devita

2023-05

Got an Italian sub from this place & will never go to any other place. 9.50 for a giant size hogie. Didn’t disappoint