The Olney Place

Kapil Bhanot

2022-05

Great grocery, deli, and taphouse. In the back there is a bar area with a great selection of beers, with beautiful views of Keuka lake and Tvs to watch the games. Up front is a deli with made to order sandwiches and a grocery store with a great selection of beers. Great place to visit to mix it up from all the wineries on the lake.

Roadblock Thompson

2022-05

Great spot. Whole crew stopped by to grab some sandos. Heard from another guy this was the happening spot. Well, I got the Mustang and I'm here to tell ya, it did not dissapoint! Picked up a nice tin of fancy pear candies for the missus. Great little roadside spot, absolutely must stop by and check it out!

Tia Bliss

2023-08

Great food and a little bit of everything . Staff is delightful . Easy in and out for boat fuel .

Kevin Markman

2023-05

Great spot to stop along Keuka Lake for a snack, a souvenir, a game of cornhole, a smile, or a souvenir tshirt. Nice vibe along the peaceful lake.

Tyler Lund

2018-05

I'm not sure how to categorize the Olney spot. Is it a convenience store with a bar? A general store? A deli with beer? It's hard to say. Thanks to a dispute with the town, the bar isn't open, but you can buy and enjoy a beer from the fridges at the tables inside. The selection is incredible with a huge selection of craft beers from all around to suite any taste. Grab a can and enjoy the scenery.

Jacob Snavely

2023-07

We docked and got gas, then food at the Olney Place and we were delighted with both. The interior is very nice, with a good beer selection and a nice taproom in the back for a prolonged stay. We stopped for gas and sandwiches, came away very pleased.

Jeffery Scott

2023-11

Good place to eat. Expensive and hours are not consistent. Always closed the past several times stopped to try to grab lunch when working in the area. Keep loosing business. 👎

B.D P

2022-05

Our go to place on the lake for breakfast. The sticky buns and breakfast sandwiches are a staple and a must have. Very friendly and nice staff. Some beautiful indoor ones and outdoor seating to view the lake while having your sandwiches and coffee. Nice selection of local beer, wine, and products. Just simply one of you favorite stops ok the lake.

Robert Faith

2023-05

Lovely view of Keuka Lake! This store had the best potato salad EVER which was being handmade by the owner Seth when we walked in. Friendly staff, great merch, and the Mustang sandwich was AMAZING. Definitely worth checking out if you're in the FLX.

Aji Maimaiti

2021-05

This place is awesome beyond description.The food selections are good and healthy. The staffs are very welcoming and friendly towards the guests. I am amazed by the hospitality of this place and the location is very convenient for Keuka Lake site seeing, parking and out-door dinning, so if you are around definitely check it out, stop by and I highly recommend this restaurant and their Eye Opener sandwich! It is truly an EYE OPENER, so fresh and so good!I will for sure go back and visit often.

Chris P

2023-09

Sandwiches were absolutely delicious and exceeded expectations. Shop was quaint and service excellent with indoor and outdoor seating.

Zach Corum

2022-05

The first thing we do when we get to the lake is stop at the Olney place for sandwiches. We always get the Rachel aka the Turkey Reuben. Seth is awesome along with the rest of the crew. Definitely stop by if your in the area. They have a bar featuring local beers and they also offer dock side service and gas if you travel by boat.

Richard Yhip

2018-05

Easy to spot from the road but if you're going the speed limit you'll drive right buy it. This is my go-to place to get the best sandwiches on Keuka Lake. In addition there's an amazing patio in the back of the store with a great view of the lake where they serve beer and you can dine. They don't have the cheapest groceries but do have high quality snacks and sundries. Highly recommend this store.

Matt Wilkins

2021-05

Always our favorite spot to visit every year. Consistently great food and amazing service. The owner Seth Olney knows what seems like everyone who walks in the door. His staff is always so friendly and happy to help. My wife is gluten free and she has no worries eating here. Get the Zach Deputy and grab a beer....you won’t regret stopping!

Karen Lee Marzak

2023-05

Came to Keuka for my birthday, as always. Decided to stop in (first time ever) for some coffee. They made me a homemade breakfast sandwich on Gluten Free bread. I was SO happy!!

Andrew Little

2017-05

Craft beer, general store, great sandwiches and wraps and more. I ordered the Rachel sandwich and it was the best sandwich I've ever had, washed down with superb craft beer. Made a few more visits here during my stay in the area for more food and beer and was always great. Friendly workers and owner also.

EJ Plimley

2023-05

It’s the Olney place you need to go! It advertises as a grocery store but it’s oh so much more! The beer tap room in the back, best egg sandwiches, and great people. Just go:) and a gas dock and tie up!

Brian Young

2021-05

Best customer service on the lake! My family had to throw together an impromptu party and I reached out to Olney Place for some help. They put together 16 hot sandwiches, all of which came off the grill within 5 minutes of each other. The sandwiches are packed with flavor and were the hit of the party. Thanks for all the help!!

Chuck Pugliese

2018-05

I support this place to the end...I visit the area all seasons, my parents settled down on Keuka Lake & we love this store for groceries , sandwiches & I think the best craft beer selection around. It's sad that some bitter neighbors are trying to slow progress, lets hope they see the light. Keep up the good work...see you again soon. Chuck. (Visited by Boat with my friend & daughters week before labor day)

Kyle Marshall

2022-05

We rode our boat to the Olney Place and used their dock. It was a short walk up the hill to grab a great sandwich. We are outside and enjoyed the great views of the lake.

Heather Anderson

2021-05

Everyone was so amazing and friendly. The food was great and the taproom overlooking the water was beautiful. Very inviting place to visit. We will definitely come back. I love the seating outside at the picnic tables. Thank you all for your hospitality.

William Lagasse

2020-05

Exceptional service, beer selection and great sandwiches, quick and inexpensive. A great view over looking Keuka Lake on their deck. Perfect stop by boat to gas up and grab lunch. Truly the only place to go.

David Sherburne

2018-05

Had a Cuban and a Rachel sandwich! Good sandwiches and a nice owner! Town has been messing with him so he couldn't serve draft beers but we had some good bottled beers! Show em support and stop in. Tell him Dave sent ya!

Leo Lesh

2021-05

This place is inviting! The staff is professional and very attentive - the gas dock attendant was great - always something special going on - every night it seems like a different theme! You can tell the owner really wants guests to have a great experience- couldn’t recommend it more! Definitely worth the stop!!

Carl Templer

2018-05

I grew up on Keuka Lake. Family had a cottage there since the mid-1930s. Through the years, under various names and management, this was the place to go for convenience, the basic necessities.Now it has changed. Yes, convenience. But community. Support. A welcoming place. Good fresh food, fine experiences or interactions. The owner remembers your name -- and those of thousands of others -- plus where you live and other small details floated in light banter every day. And he does it year after year.Professionally, I have managed downtowns/central business districts for a score of years. The Olney Place and its owner, Seth, is above the platnium standard for service, desire to improve and provide experiences and be engaged in the area, community and is fully genuine. Only good intent. Professionally, I would want every merchant, retailer, business, restaurant owner to strive to anticipate, provide and replicate the experience(s) that Seth and the diamond-stellar staff provide in every downtown that I have ever managed or been engaged with. The Onley Place is not that good, it is simply and remarkably better than the best at what it does. It is The Only Place. Remarkably unique, the Olney Place.

Leslie Lesh

2021-05

Super friendly, the crew works so hard to make sure everyone is takin care of! Appreciate how much they cater to the needs of the lakers. Above and beyond. (Plus the breakfast sandwich’s are amazing... ) Thanks Seth for providing a great experience to so many!

Edward Kent

2018-05

Excellent Cuban sandwich, great view of the lake too.

Nick Paladino

2023-08

Great spot for sandwiches, souvenirs, groceries, and more.

Benjamin “SK8BBC” Noyes

2021-05

Great people, very hospitable. Love the sandwiches and the ice cold beer on tap. Looking forward to this coming summer, so I can visit again.

Shawn Daley

2021-05

The lifeline of Keuka East. Why drive to town when you can bike (or scooter) to Olney's