Bottle Values

4.6 (334)

734 Old Bethpage Rd, Old Bethpage, NY 11804
(516) 420-1000
bottlevalues.com

Claimed
Wine store
Beverage distributor
Liquor store
Lottery retailer

From the business

  • Small business

Service options

  • Curbside pickup

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

lisa carver

2024-04

Great place to pick new wines at better prices. Matt is very approachable and gives great advice on wine picks. Roy is holding small group wine tasting classes once a week. Roy showed how to sample and appreciate the subtle aroma and flavor and how to hold the wine glass. Very enjoyable way to learn.

Frank G

2024-04

A nice store with fair pricing and good variety. I would also like to comment about one of the managers, Matt Scordato. He does various wine presentations throughout the year and I finally went to his Wine 101 class. He did a tremendous presentation that was very interesting and informative. He has a tremendous amount of knowledge to give and does so in a very fun, easy to understand and in a relaxed manner. All accompanied with a nice selection of wines to taste, along with some snacks. It was so worth the money and I would highly recommend signing up for one of his presentations, all done at the store.

D Chen

2024-05

Nice store, good selection even some allocated bottles. Prices are a little higher than SRP

Barbara Gilman

2024-02

I needed vermouth for cooking, and they checked that the one that I had bought the last time they no longer carried. They were kind enough to take me to the aisle and get me one that would be just as good for cooking.

Kundan Sen

2023-05

Plainview’s favorite liquor store. Great selections - on both wines and single malt. Good prices. Clean store, efficient cashiers, knowledgeable staff, free wine tastings.

Ben P.

2023-07

Bottle Values is like what Home Depot, Costco & Amazon did for consumers. Though you want to support your local liquor store you're drawn back here because the pricing is phenomenal and the selection is amazing. Go to 3 liquor stores in your neighborhood, price out your favorite liquor then come here and you'll be shocked how much cheaper Bottle Values is. It makes you second guess your local liquor stores pricing!!!

Thanos Zarkadas

2023-08

You would not believe the difference in price between bottle values and other liquor stores. I'm not even talking about $1 or $2. I'm talking about $10 per bottle. you will save quite a bit if you go here. Not to mention how great the customer services Is. There are always employees walking around the aisle Willing to help you with whatever you need.

kieran1313

2024-02

Prices are not bad, and they always have what I'm looking for .

Kenny Simon

2023-08

So I ordered some items from Uber eats usually the driver has your phone number but he said he knocked on the door and I didn’t answer so we brought it back to the store… Thankfully bottle value employees dropped it off at my house .. that’s great service This place is definitely the best around for prices and selection great store great Staff, A must go if you’re in the area- 5 stars ⭐️

Shirley Tao

2023-12

My dad and I went to get a bottle of wine just before they closed. Staff was welcoming and friendly.

Jennifer B

2023-07

This is my all time favorite place to shop for all of my booze. I love the fact that they sell some flavors of BeatBox too! Just wish they’d stock up on the new BeatBox Hard Tea flavor so I can try it already!!

Michael Feinstein

2023-05

Came here because their website said they had a particular wine in stock (Terra di Seta Chianti Classico). Very friendly associates helped me find this wine. Purchased a case and was on my way. Joined their club and got a discount. Looks like they have a big selection. Clean and modern store with a warehouse format. I'll be back.

Victoria Duran

2023-05

It’s a great store for a bunch of wines, they are organized by where they are from as opposed to the kinds of wine. The liquor is mostly giant bottles so if you are looking for regular or smaller bottles then this might not be your place to go but if you want to stock up for a party it’s a good option for decent prices.

Domenica Tantillo

2023-05

The wagons are inside the entrance, so you never have to get wet. Everyone's always helpful there, and the store is clean, and the aisles are wide enough to walk through they have a good variety of liquor and wine.

Marla Sferra

2023-05

Bottle Values has a large selection of wines and liquors. Their knowledgeable staff are always willing to help and make suggestions. Their rewards program also discounts the costs too!

PJ

2021-05

This is not your dads old dark liquor store. This place is big and bright. A fantastic selection of wine/liquor. They even have taste testing days. The staff is very efficient with usually more than 2 people checking customers out. You can pre order and pick up in store.

Chris lewis

2023-05

Usually love this place but have to say the man with the long white beard and bald head was wildly disrespectful today. Telling me I am not the one in my license picture and asking me unrelated questions about my identification like how long ago my picture was taken. My ID scanned, I have other proof of ID which I would’ve been happy to give instead of being questioned about the timeline of my picture. Also, I have a rewards account there, so once my ID scanned my rewards account showed up, and he still questioned my picture. I’d gladly bring this guy a photo book of me if that’s what he pleases. If my picture isn’t me and you have to question me about and even state, “this picture isn’t you”, then why still sell alcohol to me? If you were so concerned about me using a fake identification follow the proper procedure. In that case I’d be happy to bring you my passport.

Mark Minsky

2022-05

This shop is clean, white and bright. A pleasure to shop in. Knowledgeable staff (except those below legal drinking age, lol). Much more pleasant shopping experience than a Total Wine. Great prices. Will match with published ad too.

Steven (Steven)

2020-05

Pretty big selection with wine tasting classes too. It's always stocked and the cashiers and employees are always helpful.I'm always in this store so its always a pleasure seeing the same faces. They were just as friendly the first time as well as being a returning customer.The only downfall is that they can't order specifics. I like my Yukon Jack but they won't order it due to the supply cost ratio.

Prophetgu3

2023-05

Very helpful and attentive staff. Clean and spacious it looks small from the outside but it's huge inside. You can even do taste test before you buy some products wide variety of vodkas, wines, scotch, rum and other alcohol. #1 alcohol store for me

Julien Matthew

2023-05

Daniel is a Super Star! Help me find every Red bottle on my list. RESPECT!

Kirk Larsen

2023-10

They had what I needed at a great price. Shopping was easy staff was friendly

Denise Thompson

2023-05

Wonderful customer service

Lori Hofmann

2020-05

I love Bottle Values! They have a fantastic selection of quality 90 point wines at great prices and the team is always knowledgable, friendly and fun every time I'm there. They do tastings quite often in the back and I've made some really good finds of both wine and liquor as a result. Keep it up Bottle Values, highly recommend!

M. A.

2019-05

Really great prices but their wine selection is a little odd. Despite many choices, you'd be hardpressed to find nicer selections that you'll get in the smaller wine/liquor stores. For what it is, it's a convenient spot to grab something. They also have regular tastings at the back of the store.

Daljit Chandi

2016-05

Great liquor and wine selection. They have free wine tastings they they change up monthly. That's pretty great for someone like me who knows nothing about wine, but needs to buy some as gifts on occasion. They have a limited cider selection as well. I'd love to see them expand that and add some beers as well, but this is still a top flight liquor store with very reasonable prices.

Linda L.

2023-05

Amazing store.So many selections.Place it huge and cleanStaff are wonderful too

Joshua Koppeis

2019-05

Good store with great service. Make sure you ask to taste up to 12 wines in the tasting room. Various sponsored events including bottle signing, bottle engraving, celebrities, and unique single cask tastings. Some purchases earn “bottle bucks” which can be redeemed as cash for future purchases !

Catherine Allen

2018-05

Huge selection and friendly employees that help out a lot. They often have quite a few wines and a special offer liquor in the tasting room. More of a big chain looking store but the customer service makes it feel like a mom and pop place. This was our go to liquor store when we lived in Plainview.

Belvin Christopher

2020-05

I was actually excited that there is a wine shop that rewards you 🙂. They have a descent collection of Bourbons, Single Malts, Wines, Brandy (limited), Whiskey and other international liquor. Not very crowded. Good place to shop around for some delicious hangover!

Opening Hours

Monday 10 AM-8 PM
Tuesday 10 AM-8 PM
Wednesday 10 AM-8 PM
Thursday 10 AM-8 PM
Friday 10 AM-8 PM
Saturday 10 AM-8 PM
Sunday 12-5 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet