Covey's Cove

4.7 (237)

5855 E Main St, Olcott, NY 14126
(716) 638-4593
coveyscove.com

Claimed
Bar & grill

Service options

  • Outdoor seating

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

timothy schaffer

2024-05

Our server was amazing. I was told to go here for their wings. So I figured I'd make a trip out of It. The wings were outstanding. Tried my sons chicken tenders, something different about them. Maybe they were beer battered, not sure, but there were very good. All and all I'd love to come back when summers in full swing. Amazing food.Kid-friendliness: Even though it's labeled as a bar and grill. It wasn't overly bar like. If you know, you know. It has a balance, which is nice. Someplace you can go have a drink on your own and relax or take the family for food and enjoy the deck. I'm really happy we tried this place.

Haile Coder

2024-05

My Significant Other and I went here last night for our first date out in a long time after having our son. Saying this place is AMAZING is a heavy understatement the food is absolutely delicious we cleared out plates I only took left overs home to have for lunch the next day BECAUSE it was SO GOOD the owner is wonderful and super personable!!! I would recommend this place to anyone around definitely stop in!

Tim Flanagan

2022-05

This is the perfect little bar to stop at if you want a good lunch or even a good dinner. The drink selections are amazing as well, there are so many great ones to choose from. Also the Owner and bartender were very friendly and helpful. My wife and I travel for work so the owner allowed us to see their room that they Air BnB and it was a great room for an incredible price especially with it being so close to the lake in a popular location. I highly recommend stopping here if you have time to unwind and relax. 😁

Jeff Cummings

2023-05

The food is phenomenal!Everyone can find a favorite on the menu.Mixed drinks and cold beer is refreshing.The owner of this establishment takes pride in his business and is super clean both in the dining room and kitchen.Hope to see you there!Enjoy Life

Shari Allen

2024-04

…More

Brandon Bronson

2024-05

…More

Kathy Lowrey

2023-11

…More

Bonnie Walker

2024-05

…More

Larry Vanstone

2023-06

…More

Mark Dunn

2023-09

A nice bar and grill with a great location near the lake. The staff and owner are awesome. They recommended some nice areas of the park to check out after having some drinks at the bar.Dog friendly, but make sure your dog is able to handle the patio environment.

Krystal Pollworth

2024-04

…More

Mike Beagle

2023-07

…More

Jim sherry

2023-08

This place is a hidden gem. The food is great, atmosphere is awesome and the staff was fantastic. Mike the owner, gave us history of area and tips for our next stop.Please don't miss this place, it would be a loss. Can't wait for next visit.Jim

R. B.

2023-08

This was our 1st time going to Covey 's Cove. My husband, myself and my Sister were camping in town and looking for something different and I read about Covey's story and Love places with unique stories so decided to try it and so happy we did the food was fantastic and so was the service! The hotdog wrapped with bacon was so delicious I can't remember what they call it and so was the giant Pretzel and huge chicken tenders 😋! I really enjoyed my Blue Hawaiian as well and my husband had the drink that looked like Creek water haha and gummy worms ,😂he enjoyed that too. We met the owner who also was a very nice guy and very welcoming! We'd definitely go back to Covey's if we're ever in the area.

Nancy J. Smyth

2020-05

Came here with a friend who was visiting from the Southwest, and she was astonished to find such delicious, authentic Mexican street tacos. The service was great and the whole place was very welcoming.

Janeen TAGG

2023-08

…More

Samantha F

2023-08

…More

Logan Herbert

2023-07

…More

Betina Beiter

2023-07

We went for dinner Saturday night, it was reasonably priced and very tasty.We heard about their bloody mary Sundays morning and had to return because they said they were listed 2nd in WNY.OMG THEY ARE FIRST!!Best I have ever experienced and TOTALLY recommend stopping there, get in line early if you plan on getting one!Owner and staff are extremely friendly.If you pass this one by you will regret it!

Amy Pitts

2021-05

Good food. Excellent drinks. Friendly staff.

Eric Metcalf

2023-06

…More

Chuck T

2023-06

…More

Tiffany Mikits

2021-05

Great service, friendly staff, bloody mary was amazing...definitely recommend!

Chris Lambe

2022-05

Based off of one visit, the food/drink was excellent and so was the service. It wasn't crowded despite it's hole-in-the-wall appearance. The live music was nice, was there on a Sunday afternoon. I can't speak from experience but the Bloody Marys looked legendary. Nice little spot tucked in a nice little Great Lakes coastal town.

Kevin Kapell

2023-10

…More

Charlotte Clause

2023-05

Busy Sunday lunch. Drinks, food and service were good. We went for the bloody Mary's, they were out of the loaded ones by the time we made it there, so probably go earlier in the afternoon if that is what you are after.Update 6/11/2022 - after a bad experience down at Captains Galley, we came down here and even though it sounded like they were getting ready to close down the kitchen they still happily served us dinner. 5 out 5. Great customer service great food, wonderful atmosphere.

Nicholas Davis

2023-05

To the short bald headed man that "served" us. I don't know if you were the owner or only staff but you are defiantly not doing the restaurant any favors with your attitude. Sat us down, waited 15 minutes, took our order, didn't come to us to ask if we wanted more drinks or ask how everything was. Waited another fifteen minutes after eating. Another nice employee came over to ask us how things were and clear our table. Short bald man came back after that was done to give us the bill. Then stood there the WHOLE time until I wrote a tip. I wasn't going to write one on the slip and just give it to the kind employee. But felt pressured by short bald man. Food was trash for the price. Avoid at all costs. Go to the awesome Café right when you turn onto the main drag. Gave 2 stars for kind server.

Anne Marie Holland

2023-11

…More

Jim Yaeger

2023-06

…More

Anthony Re

2023-05

The whistle pigs were delicious! It’s nice to see a restaurant in a small town use fresh ingredients. The jalapeños were flavor packed and not too hot. The perfect topping for a bacon wrapped hotdog. Service was friendly and performed well under pressure (came in with a rowdy group of 12). Will definitely come back!

Opening Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 3-10 PM
Wednesday 3-10 PM
Thursday 3-10 PM
Friday 3-10 PM
Saturday 3-10 PM
Sunday 11 AM-5 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet