Fire Island Sales & Rentals

Loretta Cataldo

2023-05

I have purchased my home through and continue to rent through Fire Island Sales and rentals. They are a terrific team, especially Alyssa. She is responsive, thoughtful, thorough, and simply a pleasure to work with. I trust her advice and it has never let me down. She is willing to lend a helping hand (even if it is not "real estate" related!) I don't know what I would do without her. I highly recommend her and her team, I would give them 10 stars!!

J A

2023-05

Alyssa at Fire Island Sales & RentalsIs the best broker around! Over the years she rented our cottage and then found a family to buy it. In addition to getting the best price, she arranged and managed every detail of the purchase.Alyssa is kind, communicative, and responsible. We highly recommend Fire Island Sales and Rentals and love Alyssa!!

Heather Jupiter

2023-05

We have had the absolute pleasure of working with Alyssa O’Keefe for the past four summers. She initially helped us rent a very special l cottage, which we have been returning to every summer since. Alyssa was especially helpful and supportive during that first summer as we found our bearings on Fire Island. She made sure the house was well-appointed and had plenty of wonderful recommendations for services, restaurants, day trips, and excursions. We enjoyed working with Alyssa so much that we have sent many friends and family her way for help finding excellent summer spots.

Matt Korade

2023-05

Alyssa did a superb job of finding me an amazing house, negotiating with the seller to get me a great deal, and walking me through the process (and thoroughly answering my many, many questions all along the way). Alyssa made sure I understood what was to happen at each step, and her many recommendations on good firms to work with, insights into the market, and helpfulness and responsiveness throughout, from first look to closing, ensured that everything went smoothly and took the stress out of the experience. For anyone who wants a knowledgable real estate agent who will look out for your every need, I highly recommend Alyssa.

Risa Kirsh

2023-05

Great real estate company on Fire Island. Joanie is responsive, honest and reliable, knows the market, and always goes above and beyond whether buying, renting , or selling. We’ve been fortunate to have worked together on our Fire Island transactions and highly recommend.

Jill Aronsky

2023-05

Working with Abi and her staff from Fire Island Sales and Rentals has been nothing but positive. They are very hard working, fair, and professional. They truly listened to our needs and found the perfect home for us! Would HIGHLY recommend.

Jeffrey Aronsky

2023-05

I have been working with Abi of Fire Island Sales & Rentals for more than a decade. Her knowledge of everything relating to Fire Island is incomparable. She is kind, honest and diligent and I would whole heartedly recommend her. She will find you the home of your dreams.

Garry hughes

2023-05

Excellent client/owner responsibility. I have dealt with them over a year now. Dylan, Abby and Joanie have been brilliant.Highly recommended for a stay on Fire Island.

Glenn Chiuchiolo

2023-05

Working with Joanie and team at Fire Island Sales and Rentals is fantastic. They make it easy to do business with and take on any issues that may pop up.... which is rare! Highly recommend.

Terri Maniscalco

2023-05

Joanie always works diligently to rent our house. We trust her to get the best tenants who will take care of our home. She is always responsive and goes out of her way to help!

goose4930

2023-05

Alyssa has always been very accommodating and quick to respond to any questions or concerns I may have. She is pleasure to deal with and her enthusiasm is inspiring.

Tim Flynn

2023-05

I have been dealing with realtors on Fire Island for 50 years. Joanie and her office are not only professional but also amoung the most pleasant I have dealt with.

Cristen Cuomo

2023-05

Alyssa is the best!!! Deal went so smoothly all thanks to her help! And she's still helping me almost a year later ❤️❤️

Steve Trebing

2023-05

It is not easy to sell and buy in a short period of time but Abi made it happen. She was extremely knowledgeable and helpful and guided us every step of the way. I wouldn’t recommend anyone else.

Diane Mandel

2023-05

Dylan is great! Professional and understanding he will find you what you are looking for

Jessica Dzus

2024-05

Rented with Mary Kate and Joanie and it was a great experience!

Chris Lynn

2023-05

The team is great to work with. It’s been great working closely with Dylan and Joanie. If you are looking to buy or do a rental you will be happy with them.

Rich D’Andrea

2023-05

Joanie Woletsky has been extremely professional and accommodating in all of our transactions. Would highly recommend her.

Dan Toomey Jr

2023-05

Very helpful, friendly and knowledgable! Responsive and always there when you have a question or concern. Would definetly recommend Alyssa!!

James Stefanick

2023-05

Joanie is the best!