New York Pizzeria

David S

2022-05

Excellent local place, you must try! Same owner since 1979 (42yrs), has to be good... many special combos so you can't go wrong here. I had a pepperoni slice- delish and crispy! They even have a Hawaiian style pizza for those of us island travelers.

M

2022-05

These garlic pizza strips are fantastic. Went back a second time today they are so good. Just a few minutes from Herkimer KOA., not locals. We even got the t shirt for the cool logo and to remember this place. The guy started the place in 1979 when he was 19yo.

J “Jay Dee” Dee

2023-05

We ordered from here recently, the sauce on the pizza was very good and had quite a bit of flavor. The wings were doused in an adequate amount of sauce and also tasted really good. The prices are similar to other local pizzerias BUT they also include more wings so look closely at what you’re ordering because I had been trying to decide which place to order from and settled on trying this one out bc I’d get more food for my money. The original pizzeria was very good but did not accept debit/credit cards whereas the new owners do-that’s nice as well bc I never have cash. Overall, quick and friendly service and great food-don’t hesitate to try it.Parking: Parked across street but offers on street parking as well in front of restaurant if available.

Dan Easton (Daneaston)

2023-05

I ordered two pizzas said one hour took almost two hours. I ordered a large garlic and large pepperoni and the pepperoni had five pieces of pepperoni and it was burnt could not eat it, the garlic was under cooked and it was as if they dumped garlic salt on it nasty the customer service was horrible was laughed at and was told we will do better next time there will not be a next time. Wish there wasn’t a first.

Sky Moran

2023-06

This will always be one of my favorites!! As a kid, I remember doing movie night with my parents and little sisters and Pete's was the only one who would deliver to our house in the middle of nowhere 😂 their pizza and wings are seriously so good!! I'm always surprised that the price is actually reasonable. Even if you only want a couple slices, it's delicious and if you only have a couple dollars you can still get at least a slice. They're always nice, I've never had a bad experience there in my whole life! If I could only get pizza from one place for the rest of forever, I'd pick here!

Steve Piseck

2023-05

New owners are carrying on the traditional recipes that made Pete, the previous owner since the '80s, a local favorite! Good pizza and wings amongst other things.

Joshua Flike

2018-05

Pete will always treat you right and I have enjoyed his pizza for 30 years

Loretta Kotary

2021-05

The sub meat isn't of the best quality, the lettuce is in large pieces instead of shredded for subs, and the salads come with canned peppers and mushrooms instead of fresh (when I eat a salad I like it to be all fresh veggies not some canned n some fresh....textures n tastes don't match well). Everything else is really good. Their everything wings r AMAZING!

PHLYFISH _FPV

2023-06

…More

Michael Pinto

2021-05

It's better than gas station pizza but not by much. Ordered for pickup and didn't find out until I walked in that it's cash only. Luckily I had cash but it's strange to me. That they wouldn't say something over the phone before I showed up. Price was average. ~$40 for a large cheese and 30 wings. Honestly I'd rate this place one star but the hot wings were pretty good. Pizza was 1/5 but the wings were 4/5.

Joseph LoRe

2017-05

Beautiful scenic area in the historical village of Newport, NY. Gorgeous olden style architecture that has been well preserved. The WCV river is beautiful. The pizza here is well worth a trip to Newport. Great menu items. Excellent pricing. Friendly service. 5 stars!

Kenny Wayne

2020-05

Phenomenal pizza, cold sodas, and great customer service. I can't wait to try the rest of their menu! I highly recommend!

Robert Zumpano

2020-05

Very good pizza!! Pete and his daughter Danielle do a great job making the best pizza in the North Country!! Wings are to die for!!

A ss

2023-05

Pizza was pretty good but the mild boneless wings just weren't the best

amber vandewalker

2020-05

Ordered pizza, calzone and wings. It's great and the service was prompt. A couple doors down Had a great martini while it was made......ok 2 martinis....ok picked up order and had another.

MBR chowaniec

2023-05

New owners are great had calzone tonite was full of cheese and toppings ..

Daniel Muha

2018-05

ben their a lot years past now being mostly disabeld a at home book keeper . havent seen pete in years always enjoyed going their .always good food and great garlick strips..i hope to visit again soon. hi folks

melissa moran

2021-05

Tonight's pizza and wings were the best I've had from here in years! Keep it coming!

Mark Homer

2019-05

The best pizza and Italian food around.Great service,price and portions...I love the food here👍👍👍👍

Sarah L

2019-05

People are very friendly, food's good, convenient hours. Great for grabbing a quick slice, eat in, and take out.

John Lemche

2020-05

First time we tried food here drove up from little falls pizza and wings were delicious

Matthew Telfer

2019-05

Owner is a great guy and he has been making quality pizza and wings for years.

Glamping Girl

2023-06

…More

Amy Clemons

2023-05

…More

Wendy Wells

2020-05

Great Atmosphere and Old School Style Menu as well as the ingredients and preparation right down to fresh parmesan on the table 💖

Phil Bolton

2020-05

Love the pizza, been going there for 20 something years.

Lorry Kirk

2018-05

Fantastic chicken & wings. All their food is great. Friendly service!

Raymond Rueger

2024-04

…More

Roger Hensley

2022-05

Pizza was good only had 5 min wait.

Tom Fort

2023-05

All was good and delicious. Friendly people to deal with.