Positively Pets

4.8 (103)

152 Windsor Hwy, New Windsor, NY 12553
(845) 565-0722
positivelypetsny.com

Claim this business

Pet supply store

Service options

  • In-store shopping

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Michelle Wharton

2024-04

Has several very good brands for dogs with digestive issues,that places like pet smart n petco don't carry,me personally I like to support small business owned companies not corporations.

D Fitz

2023-11

I love this pet supply store! I get personalized and knowledgeable advice on food for my dog. It’s nice to always have a kind and friendly person to help me with all my pups needs. Plus the food is a good quality that I trust for my four legged best friend !

Sophia Rodriguez

2023-09

FIRST VISIT BUT NOT THE LAST: I moved here a few years ago from NJ, and when I used to have a dog finding stores such as this, it was easy. I moved up here and recently got a new puppy. I'm pro raw diet, but I'm anti corporate stores like PetSmart/Petco. I really feel that A) their prices are ridiculous, and B) no one knows anything. I saw this store in passing one day, looked them up online the next, and thats when I saw the types of items offered. I told my husband that we needed to go and check it out. It's a privately owned small business, which I love. We looked around at all the dog options that he had (Acana, Orijen, Stella, Primal, freeze-dried raw, frozen raw, and more). I didn't catch his name, but based on other reviews, the owner is Eric, and he was super helpful and knowledgeable. I want what's best for my puppy, and he helped me find a way to do that. His prices are reasonable. He's friendly and helpful. Carries the brands I already use. Accepts cards and cash. I highly recommend taking a trip and supporting his business. And if you ever thought about trying raw but had questions, go talk to Eric so you can learn more.

Melanie Ratterree

2023-08

I’ve been going to Positively Pets for over 10 yrs. We are fortunate to have a local small business option. Eric is friendly, open to listen to specific pet food concerns, helpful and knowledgeable. There is a very good selection of high nutritional value food. His shop is a rare find these days.

N G

2023-10

We’ve been coming here for years for our pet food. The owner is amazingly helpful, considering we are usually buying ~150lbs of dog food at a time, and literally helps put it all in the car

Rebecca G

2023-05

The owner is extremely knowledgeable and friendly plus he offers a fantastic selection of pet products. Best of all, this is a local business that I’m happy to support.

Markus Hartel

2019-05

Mable loves it when I bring back Dave's grain free food. Great local pet store with a good selection and friendly service.

Rebecca Aviles

2018-05

I love this place! I was in a bind after Chewy stopped selling Fromm and this was the only place open on a Sunday that had it. What luck though! I can bring my puppies with me, and everyone who works here is kind and helpful. They treat my dogs wonderful and even help load my car. Not to mention they also sell the larger bags of Fromm catfood too!

kam

2019-05

Positively Pets is small business with a huge appetite to help pet owners with pet nutrition and pet health needs. Uniquely knowledgable about the industry and helpful to advise with all stages of your pet's life. Everything you would expect from a small business from its expertise to their friendly service ~ what box and chain stores can't duplicate. Love this store.

SuperBp1977

2018-05

We shop here all the time. They know what they talking about. My wife and I came in there with a few questions regarding best food for our boys (dogs), cause our boys hated the other food an one had a allergic (we didn't know that) we tried the food an treats they recommended, now our boys are happy. Thank u guys. You'll always have our business.

EHS

2018-05

Excellent pet food store! All the best, top quality brands, huge selection. My mom's been shopping here for years and I'm happy, healthy and spoiled because of it. Great knowledgeable and friendly service.

Christina Bierling

2019-05

Great pet food store. I called looking for a very particular brand of raw cat food and they ordered it right away and said they will keep it in stock for me. They have a wide selection of high quality cat and dog food and the service is excellent. They also seem very knowledgeable about their products.

Mel Gavin

2022-05

Eric is very helpful and can order most any cat or dog item for you, if he doesn't already have it in stock. Support locally owned small business.

BryanB Bender

2020-05

Best place for pet supplies ! It's nice to be able to shop without worry as each and every product on the shelves has been carefully selected! No frills, no gimmicks ECT only the best available at the same price as online ..... Why not support local?!

Helen Levin

2019-05

Sold me expired taste of the wild cat food from 7 months ago . Told me it was discounted because it got ripped when opening box. . He then said he grabbed the wrong one in the back. Why was it there for 7 months? They care alot about selling USA products but don't care if expired . He knew very well. The place is not the same .

lucrecia rich

2022-05

Pleasant ...Customer service is outstanding.Positively pets have a few options to choose from and good products for your pet.

J Papa

2018-05

They Are VERY knowledgeable on their products. I went in with my diabetic and the help me pick out things that were healthy for him. I will return as soon as I am able.

Dillon Batista

2022-05

Mom and Pop store. Good selection and prices. Nice place to do business with. Nice to know you are supporting your local business.

Michael Menzie

2019-05

Very friendly and polite staff. Lots of great products for both cats and dogs. High quality foods

Timothy Fishman

2022-05

My "go to" spot for dog food and treats. Friendly and knowledgeable staff. Support local small businesses and shop here instead of online pet stores!

Carly Rivas

2013-05

The staff is all amazing. Judy the owner is a wonderful women and takes the time to find the right products for your pets. I am so thankful for her and this store.

jkz33 ume

2022-05

Great mom and pop shop. Owners know your name, what you frequently buy, extremely helpful. Very knowledgeable.

Marc Swift

2019-05

Great place to shop for your pets. Huge selection of dog and cat food. Great selection of natural foods and a wonderful staff of knowledgeable people.

Debra Stiglianese

2023-05

Eric the owner is very helpful and friendly he even helped carry out the cat's food to my car

Ruth Rodgers

2021-05

Love supporting the local, lovely, and genuine folks here. Hope anyone within reasonable distance goes out of their way to spend their money here. The BEST!

Sharon Moyer

2019-05

Great selection of high quality pet food. Friendly, personal service and great prices

Jessica Walker

2019-05

We love this place! They always have a wide variety of healthy dog treats and food at great prices

raffaele catania

2022-05

Great customer service and a selection of essential needs for my pets.

Ward Wood

2023-05

Better quality food for your pets. Better than any grocery stores.

Sal Schisano

2021-05

Holistic pet foot store with highly knowledgeable owner. Will give his honest recommendation on all things pets

Opening Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 10 AM-6 PM
Wednesday 10 AM-6 PM
Thursday 10 AM-6 PM
Friday 10 AM-6 PM
Saturday 9:30 AM-5 PM
Sunday 11 AM-3 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet