Butcher Boys of Monticello

Bob Engel

2023-11

So unassuming, true gem hidden on a side street.. the team were very helpfull. Great selection of meat, fresh to made chop meat and sausage. Filled the cooler with "The kings special"

Peter Bogdan

2023-05

I really enjoy going to butcher boys. Its about an hour away so me and my friend carpool and have a good time riding the backroads. The meat really is amazing never got a bad cut and its definitely worth the ride. Get a small freezer put it in the corner of your living room fkll it up save money and eat well.

Roseanne Carlo

2022-05

Great selection of meats, great packages and prices. The extras around, like finishing salts, truffle oils and lots of sauces and seasonings are amazing.Great spot, and the orders are ready quickly. Friendly staff.

Vincent Lee

2023-08

Loved the butcher brother's took great care of us. Meat was of fantastic quality and the price was perfect

Kevin Clark

2024-03

Absolutely fantastic, stuck to my monthly budget for meats and not only did I get an extra week but the quality was outstanding…Never again will I buy meats at the supermarket!

Hoot Williams Jr.

2023-05

A carnivore’s paradise, and jewel in the treasure trove that is the Catskills, Sullivan Co. Open Saturday! 🏡🌈❤️

Ephraim Stern

2024-03

Gone here twice now. Well worth the 30 minute drive. Butcher Boys does not dissapoint.

Paul Blart

2023-05

I have been going here for a few years now. I drive about 40 minutes to get to them. I will say these guys are awesome. They always cut the meat perfectly and package everything nicely. They are friendly and appreciate their customers. In my opinion the best butcher around.

Jessica Dower

2023-09

So grateful to have learned about this hidden gem in Monticello!! I'll never buy meats at a grocery store again, the prices, the cuts, the freshness, the flavor, and most importantly, the customer service is absolutely amazing!! Thank you Butcher Boys for serving the community with smiles and the best product around!!

Shane M. Williams

2024-01

Great cuts at a great price, couldn't recommend more highly.

C W

2023-05

I had found out about Butcher Boys through a friend. This shop is awesome. The staff or brothers couldn’t be any more courteous and professional than they already are. They accommodate and genuinely care about every customer that walks through their door. They go over and above to make sure that everyone is happy. Their meats are quality, the chicken wings are incredible (the best I’ve ever had). Also their steaks and chops are wonderful as well. If you have the opportunity go in and try for yourself, I promise you will not be disappointed. Everything here tastes great.

Ralph Brown

2024-01

Awesome Awesome butcher shop cannot say enough great things about this shop. The staff are so very friendly and helpful. Top quality cuts at affordable prices. Daily specials are fire.

Marc Eric Johnson

2023-05

I needed advice on a birthday present for my best friend (who is a carnivorous meat lover). I personally have no knowledge, being a burger rub guy my whole life. This place is absolutely amazing, beautifully dressed meats row on row, every cut one could imagine! A friendly guy named Jake helped me out, and I got a huge box of treats for my buddy for a very reasonable price. Jake is one of those treasures of the culinary world, giving advice on various cuts, rubs, sauces and spices. A great experience! I will be back every chance I get. Worth driving to!!! So different from shopping at a supermarket! Highly recommended!

Angela C.

2023-06

We bought some ribeye steak and it was amazing. Fresh, flavorful, and was great without any tenderizing. We just threw it on the grill and it came out wonderfully.

Christopher McKay

2022-05

This place is the best to get the freshest meat at the greatest prices. The people were really nice to talk to as well. The meats are so fresh and cleanly trimmed. I was able to get a lot of meat and throw it in the vacuum sealer then right into the freezer for later all without emptying my wallet. Simply great people, great meat, and great prices. I will be coming here for all my holiday dinners and BBQ cookout meats.

Bradley Keith Joffrion

2023-10

I absolutely love this place great quality meats and great customer service, place seems clean and decently priced. ✨✨

Michelle Tabor

2020-05

Waited for about 2 hours due to the current world situation. I'm glad I waited. Nice selection of meats. Display a lot of unusual pasta. I'd prefer more baked goods and breads to be offered. The service is amazing. Kind, informative and calm as the line grows outside it did not seem to overwhelm them. I will definitely make more trips there when things level out. Good job Butcher Boys!

torah2riah

2020-05

Very nice remodeling they have done in this place! They always have great deals and amazing selections on meats. They now have a very awesome gourmet selection for spices, pastas, and condiments. They are also now offering fresh seafood selections! Pleasant staff and service. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!

Siobhan Guerin

2022-05

The meat is high quality and extremely fresh. The people that work there are knowledgeable, friendly and very helpful. The prices are excellent. The store was very clean,as well as the parking lot.I drive an hour to get here,worth the drive.This is the only place I will buy meat now.

Thomas Wise

2021-05

This butcher shop is the definition of a wonderful family business. The staff is friendly and the owners are honest, hard working people. The meats taste prime. They kept Sullivan county's freezers full all through this pandemic and earlier meat shortages. When nationwide wholesales prices dropped after the shortage was over, so did theirs. Honest good people. I have been coming to this shop for over 10 years and watched it thrive because of their customer service and competitive pricing. As the grandson of a butcher...I firmly belive... SUPPORT YOUR LOCAL BUTCHER!

Michael LaRocca

2022-05

Excellent butcher with excellent service. Their steaks are great, and their burger blend is ground fresh and makes for a perfect burger. They also have a full cold cut counter, as well as a good selection of "extras" such as rubs and marinades, olive oil, pasta, bread, and more.

Bree Bottom

2023-05

Very kind , family owned business. Meats are great ! Seafood is fresh ! And prices are reasonable and affordable! I never go to a Walmart or shop rite for my meats anymore!

Debra Kaplan

2021-05

Great quality meat! Very friendly people! My dogs love the bone marrow bones! Thank you! I drove 45 minutes away when someone told me about there place and it was well worth the trip!

Allan Benamer

2023-05

If you need to do a barbecue or cookout, this is the place to start. You can't get aged beef but everything else is possible. Great cuts and service, a real gem.

Lisa Bell

2021-05

We will never again get our meats at the grocery stores! Nick's meats are always so fresh and DELICIOUS! From the Steaks to the Chicken to the ground hamburger everything is TOP OF THE LINE. I have a family of 5 and will be making the trip every month to get all my meats. I highly recommend everyone checking them out!!!

Michael Negron

2021-05

I’m not sure if I’m just excited to have a good butcher near me or it’s that the meat was so fresh and came out cooked so well and was so juicy. I would recommend anyone drive from anywhere to check this place out.They have everything !! With decent packages and awesome prices! bring a cooler if your making a long trip lol no frozen meat here.

hillary weiss

2021-05

Best prices, best meat, great service. This is our families new favorite place for meat! Had an amazing skirt steak, brisket and chicken wings. We bought so much food for such a low price. This is the place to go!

Theresa brown

2023-05

The employees are hardworking and nice. The prices cant be beat. Love being able to buy enough meat for the month.

Ashley Hughes

2019-05

These guys are always on their A game! They absolutely are one of the best places around, and many travel a great distance to get their food! I love that they have many pastas as well, making this a great stop for people of all diets!

Laura Asta

2021-05

Hands down the best family owned business. I started going there in March 2020 & have never bought meat anywhere else since then. They are courteous, patient & support this community.