Millerton Agway

4.5 (116)

5980 N Elm Ave, Millerton, NY 12546
(518) 789-4471
agwayny.com

Claimed
Pet supply store
Delivery service
Animal feed store
Lawn equipment rental service
Garden center
Enduring farmer-owned cooperative retailer providing agricultural, garden, home & pet supplies.

Service options

  • Delivery

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Betty Spaulding

2023-05

Help is nice I found honey but no cheap cat fleas collars but they had other flea stuff just not what I needed at that time but over all store is well maintained staff r friendly and helpful will go back for future purchases.

Anne Poveromo

2023-05

Went in for propane. Woman behind counter was super friendly and helpful. Man that filled the tank was working by himself. He filled tank and carried to and put in my car. Great place!

Kira Proper

2022-05

Do not take your lawnmower here for service! They had mine for two months although it was done for over a month before they delivered it back to me. When I called to find out what was taking so long, a week after I paid in full for the service, the guy asked me if I knew it had an oil leak that was dripping on the transmission and causing it to slip. I did not know that and when I asked why they didn't fix it he said they don't do that work there and I'll have to take it somewhere else.So I spent $350 fixing a mower with an engine/transmission problem that no one bothered to explain to me before doing the work. Now I finally have it back and it is all sorts of wrong. It doesn't steer straight and the blades aren't turning properly when I try to mow. I called to complain and was told there is only one person in the whole store I can talk to and he is off. And it's the guy who was zero help in the first place.Now I have a mower I will likely end up selling for parts because it's not worth fixing anymore based on its age. This all could have been avoided if someone has picked up the phone in March. But no, two months of my life spent waiting and now I bought a new mower anyway. Good thing I'm friendly with my neighbor so I can borrow their mower for the third time while I wait for my new one to arrive next week.Seriously, take your mower somewhere else for service and save yourself the headache I went through.

Stephen Stclair

2022-05

Great people. Great selection. I am also a little biased because I worked there in the 90's. Lol. Somehow Paul is still the owner, great first boss and a great guy and Dave, who made the weekends fun way back then. Hahaha.

Angela Platt (George & Angie)

2019-05

Very knowledgeable employees. I wasn't sure what I needed to do my project. But I explained what I was wanting to do to the employee who was assisting me and he understood exactly what I wanted to do. He showed me a few different products gave me some different options we narrowed everything down so I bought only what I needed with very little leftovers. I was very pleased with with my experience at AGWAY. I recommend it to everyone...

ST Santoli

2020-05

Friendly, they know their stuff, and always helpful. Some prices on things a little higher, but not by very much and worth it to shop local. Always grateful for their answers to my questions - from gardening to fencing.

Katja Schultz

2022-05

Always helpful and knowledgeable staff around for support. We had wonderful plants and chicks come from our local Agway. So grateful you are all right next door

Deborah Romano

2023-11

You can count on it for healthy grains dog food and all things cat!

Mahcayla Mcneil

2023-05

I love having Millerton Agway so close to my job at Northeast Ford. The prices at Millerton Agway are awesome my boyfriend always stops in to pick up stuff for our cats .

tnypco

2023-05

My go-to for everything garden and pet food, toys and beds. It’s a bit out of my way, but very well stocked.

Judith Gray-zimbalist

2022-05

Millerton Agway us excellent. Helpful, friendly and stocked with what you need. Kristin, Penny, Mike and the rest of the staff are wonderful.

Ernest Viebrock

2019-05

Went shopping for a shrub and found exactly what I was looking for.They have a nice variety and the prices very reasonable.The staff were very helpful and friendly.would not hesitate to go back.

Rustowner

2018-05

Nice, well stocked Agway store. People are helpful and they have a very diverse selection of items for the home, farm or garden.

Marisa Beligni Simmons

2021-05

I am grateful that this company still allows curbside pick up and they don't make you feel awkward about the request, in fact, they are kind and accommodating.

Joe Sorice

2021-05

They are ok the prices aren't too to bad and they have a lot of stuff in stock

William Kirber

2018-05

Always helpful. I wouldn't take my mower or chainsaw anywhere else for service.

Deborah Jessup

2021-05

Usually has most of the stuff needed to take care of my animals. A bit pricey though.

Bert 1970

2023-05

Good local people who care about their community.

Joanna Bree

2018-05

Great place ! Everyone friendly, knowledgeable & willing to help.One of my favorite stops of the day !!!

Vance Cannon

2019-05

Typical Agway. Except the manager is rude than most. Guy should try being polite. What could it hurt?

Delora Brooks

2020-05

Dave is the best. Those guys are the best and give great customer service. Shop local.

Courtney Lilley

2019-05

Always have what I need, top notch staff and great prices!

James Gondolfi

2020-05

Love Agway. Friendly staff. Hard to get items can be bought here.

Sarah Lalibert

2022-05

Helpful, friendly environment, good stuff for animals(feed and seed)

Brenda Neal

2020-05

There is a rabidly angry and rude woman who works there. You're taking your life in your hands if you patronize them

Paul Abbott

2022-05

Old fashion Hardware and Great Feed supply geared toward farm Ranch and Gardening

Lorie Defiores

2021-05

Safe and clean....great staff...had exactly what I was looking for.

Marilyn Miran

2023-07

Staff was helpful and friendly.

Jennifer Silvernale

2020-05

Very nice people both cashier's were very nice

Miroslav Blumenberg

2020-05

Friendly staffers, helpful. Prices good.

Opening Hours

Monday 8 AM-5 PM
Tuesday 8 AM-5 PM
Wednesday 8 AM-5 PM
Thursday 8 AM-5 PM
Friday 8 AM-5 PM
Saturday 8 AM-4 PM
Sunday 9 AM-3 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet