Coney Island Diner

T J- Mann

2024-04

Ordered pick-up before opening time. Unfortunately the homemade cornbeef hash definitely set in a fridge uncovered ( tasted sour) over medium eggs were over done. While the price when ordering through clover is much cheaper then ordering pickup through DD. If You are an early eater this is not the place. Homefries lacked seasoning more of a simple boil potato 🥔.

Marco in New York

2023-06

Had a good meal here!We got an omelette that was fluffy and flavorful; and a steak, good amount of food compared to the price.They refill your coffee which is appreciated.Place was clean and it seems well organized, it’s clear people working there do care to do a good job.Will be back!

guymard

2024-03

…More

Marilyn

2024-02

Couldn't even put not one star. I ordered breakfast. It was eggs and pancakes the eggs. I said over medium they came overheard. Look like egg salad. The pancakes were ice cold the next day I order soup. They give me 9 salts, not even a pepper. I go over there. The boss is refusing to do anything about it. Tell me all I'm gonna watch the cameras and see how many salt and pepper they gave you. And then he never came out the back. Never gave me my money back. This place has gone downhill. We need a new restaurant in Middletown downtown. Beware of the new owners rude beware food disgusting. Beware, they don't know how to cook.

Jessica “Peche” Peche

2023-05

It’s in a great location especially by the bus and all the barbershops around. Easy parking and close to everything. They are fast in there but the price on these sandwiches are ridiculous. I got 2 BLTs one with fries the other with chips no drink and it was $18. I wouldn’t have complained about the price but when I took a bite out of it and only tasted bread and lettuce I was upset. Of course I open up the sandwich to only see 2 slices of bacon on white bread smh I was extremely upset because I was hungry. The chips came with the sandwich where burnt and had no flavor. I wouldn’t recommend you getting a BLT from here.

Richard McMickle

2024-04

1st time going there and it will be my last. Food was edible, but nothing I would go out of my way for. Fries were very bland. Customer service was not very good either. Funny thing is they have coke signs on the wall but they serve Pepsi. Overall an experience I would not do again.

kenny D

2023-05

…More

Anna Xu

2022-05

Recommended by a friend who has been living in Middletown for over 40 years, so we tried their loaded hotdogs. It was good, and I liked the fries too. Very good prices too. Would like to try their breakfast sometime.

CHRISSY BROWN

2024-01

…More

Amanda Rodriguez

2023-10

My first time going to Coney Island after hearing it had new owners and it’ll be my last time. While I was underwhelmed by my food being bland it was their customer service that is losing my business. I first hand witnessed the woman behind the counter be racist towards another customer. The woman came in and upon listening to her try to order a coffee I could tell she was not English speaking. She asked for a medium to which she was told they no longer did that size. The lady clearly did not understand and to which the the woman behind the counter became ruder in saying “we don’t do medium, do you understand?” Then proceeded to get a Spanish speaking employee from the kitchen and told him to talk to “Mexican lady” She got her coffee then went to sit and wanted to order food, again with the same woman from behind the counter. Most likely unable to read English the customer pointed to a picture of food and said “like this” to which the woman said “What you just want the steak? I don’t understand” then walked off and got the Spanish speaking employee again and said to him “go get order from Mexican lady” I had never seen such terrible and racist customer service come from Coney which I’ve been frequenting for 15+ years throughout all their ownerships. It is rude to assume what someone is and terrible to treat them as less due to lack of communication. The area is highly diverse and highly trafficked due to the location and bus station, if you do not have the patience for the constant diverse language of clientele then don’t serve.

Jayden Rheel

2024-01

Undercooked eggs and soggy toast, the food wasn't cooked properly and tastes off. They're not that hard to cook correctly so I don't understand what the issue is.

Reggie Miller

2023-11

…More

David Lust

2023-05

I just visited Coney Island about 10 days ago, and just have to say, the dogs now taste just like they did 60 years ago when I first ate there. I was really surprised by the turn around that has transpired there. they’ve got it right now!

Joshua Sanchez

2024-04

…More

Mr Lugo

2023-08

So this time I went in for brunch I had French toast with strawberry compo and they are homemade corn beef hash which is absolutely a must. My wife had The fried chicken BLT and then you can't go wrong with fresh fried chicken. Also trying out their very delicious Mexican hot dog jalapenos bacon cheese mustard delicious sauce it's so good next time I'm getting at least 2 to 4 of those.

Alberta Hardison

2022-05

Food was good and fresh. I did uber eats and they didn't make my order until I got there

Gayla Henry

2023-08

…More

Charisha Jamison

2022-05

Recently started job in area and was looking for a good breakfast sandwich. The sandwich was decent but I also ordered chicken soup and a salad for lunch. Lunch, no so good. Soup tasted like dirty water with an abundance of noodles. No chicken or veggies at all. They made the salad with big hunks of iceberg lettuce (which I hate) and there’s literally no seasoning on the chicken. Will go back if I had to for breakfast but that’s about it. The people were nice so that’s a plus.

Janine Blough

2022-05

Dining in the food was fabulous. Grub hub delivery the food wasn't as good. The aujus was a thick dark sweet strong liquid. Horrible tasting and the sweet potato fries were soggy rubbery not delicious and crispy when we dined in

Goddess Frigga

2022-05

As good as I remember. Coney dogs are one of those nostalgic things I have to have whenever I visit the area. Great service. Staff was friendly and accomodating. Prices are still very reasonable. Highly recommend!

Debra Hay

2023-05

…More

Deboara Terwilliger

2019-05

It's great food. Coffee though is grainy. A lot of grounds at the bottom of the cup. Never brought it back to them to complain about that because I got to get somewhere else in town by a certain time and then the bus leaves shortly after I get back to the terminal. The food is a little expensive for the amount of food given, but prepared well and tastes great so in some ways it is worth the money.

Brittany LaChausse

2014-05

Everything here was delicious. I was impressed by the homemade mozzarella sticks, homemade potato chips and beautiful cheesecake desserts. My only complaint is that they have mac n cheese on the menu but its not available on sundays. Will definitely come here again!

Norman Wohlmuth

2023-09

They just recently had a price change. Their online menu does Not reflect it.Also a coffee is NOT included during the breakfast hours.

Nick Mc

2020-05

My first and only time here was yesterday 7/23/19. I will not be going back. Had some eggs with an English muffin. A few hours after eating and leaving, i began feeling nauseous, weak and disoriented... I came down with food poisoning. I'm sure you'll ask "how do you know it was this food?" And your answer is... It's the only thing i ate yesterday. I couldn't eat anything else due to- vomiting, diarrhea.I will never be coming here again.

Cheyanne Carmen

2023-05

Fantastic customer service and fantastic food. Will definitely eat here again!

Diana Anderson

2020-05

YAY for coney dogs! I've been ordering them for years- and now I add sweet potato fries. Big menu, although I haven't tried most of it- they are right next to the bus station and get lots of to go traffic. When you sit to have a meal the service is always good.

Vanessa Ramos

2023-06

…More

David Young

2023-05

It is impossible for 2 coney dogs and 2 lg fries come to 19.02. I guess since last time I was here this place really changed and time to find a new hot dog place it's a shame they were so good

Vickianne Snyder Clark

2020-05

Taste of home. This location does not have the ambiance of the original and it may seem a little shady, but the Coney Island hotdog has not changed and is my benchmark for any chili dog. Missing the rice pudding.