Stewart's Mayville Hardware

4.7 (58)

53 S Erie St, Mayville, NY 14757
(716) 753-2621
mayvillehardware.com

Claimed
Hardware store
Home improvement store

Service options

  • Curbside pickup

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Ellen Yager

2023-05

This is an amazing hardware store. They have everything you need for any kind of repairs you are doing. The staff is very helpful and they ask if there is anything that you are looking for and can not find. It is like going back in time to a nicer, gentler place, in our now non caring, unfriendly world.

Danny Diven

2023-05

They have everything! Excellent staff in each visit. I basically walk in describe problem or project, they fix with products and advice. Quick and down-to-earth!!

Kathleen Hughes

2022-05

Love this store. From coffee makers and cards to hammers and hack saws Stewart's always has what I need. The staff are friendly and quite helpful. Stop in today and tell them Kat sent ya 😉

Mark Peterson

2022-05

Locally owned and operated small town hardware store. Personal service with a smile. I prefer going here rather than Home Depot. They carry a little bit of everything. Don't see what you need, ask and they will probably find it.

Angel Cobb

2019-05

Steve is awesome he did a great job helping me get what I needed quickly cut some keys for me in and out really appreciate these guys bonus there's a puppy in the store too really friendly

Kevin Jones

2021-05

Always helpful i don't know his name but he's the dude thats ALWAYS there and every single time I go there be it for work..or a personal project he give good suggestions and recommends things that could work.better,like today when I neededa quick fix for my hatchet head..since I havea 2 year old who likes to wreck house! Thamk.you sir!

Tom Przybylak

2023-05

A small local hardware store that somehow has everything you need whenever you need it. The staff is super helpful and the prices are reasonable.

Don Pool

2022-05

Great customer oriented service. Huge selection for a small store. They really have everything.

Dave Kerr

2021-05

Small town helpfulness. More hardware selection than the Big Bland Boxes. Go here first (then you won't need to go anywhere else).

Dana Shelters

2023-05

Good old fashioned hardware where you can find those unique items you can't always find in big box stores

David Abood

2021-05

Always has just what you need at a fair price, and always knowledgeable, friendly and helpful. Well done!

John Luker

2023-10

Friendly helpful staff, convenient location

Daniel Stewart

2022-05

The atmosphere is great , the staff is always helpful & I always find what I need !

Jennif S

2020-05

Excellent small town hardware store. Super friendly people!

Daniel Stewart

2019-05

Mayville Hardware always has whatever it is that you need to get the project done. They are close by, convenient and friendly.

Kevin M Cuddeback

2023-05

For all those little things that go wrong at a Chautauqua summer place, this place has great solutions.

Jeff Schermerhorn

2021-05

helpful staff with fair prices and nice selection

hank grosel

2018-05

Friendly, family owned, will order what you need if the don't have it

Adam Gollwitzer

2018-05

Helpful staff, has everything you would typically be looking for.

Steve Tarbet

2021-05

Well organized, great people and good prices!

Sheryl Neal

2023-05

Love this hardware store!!!

Barry Crandall

2019-05

Great place very friendly and helpful staff

Brady Kleckner

2018-05

A little pricey but nice variety.

Matthew West

2021-05

Great service and fair prices

Barb McDonald

2021-05

Staff went way above and beyond to assist me.

Liz Kolken

2021-05

Lovely small town service

John Lyon

2021-05

Very helpful staff

gene dloniak

2020-05

Great service

Jerry Glaser

2022-05

Always professional

Micheal Kleckner

2019-05

Exspesive for most things

Opening Hours

Monday 8 AM-5 PM
Tuesday 8 AM-6 PM
Wednesday 8 AM-5 PM
Thursday 8 AM-5 PM
Friday 8 AM-6 PM
Saturday 8 AM-5 PM
Sunday 10 AM-2 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet