Jim's Bait Shop

4.9 (148)

118 Second Ave Ext, Mayfield, NY 12117
(518) 661-5724
jimsbaitshop2023.com

Claimed
Bait shop

From the business

  • Small business

Service options

  • In-store shopping

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Tiffany Snyder

2024-04

Super awesome owner who has helped me in a pinch! Always the freshest and fatest worms. I need them for my axolotls, not even for bait, and I know I can trust them to be safe!

Tyler Queen

2023-07

Jim was fantastic! He was friendly and knowledgeable and set me up with a new baitcaster to try out on Lake Sacandaga. His advice scored me some killer fish!

Eduardo Herrmann

2024-04

Great bait shop, the owner gets really involved in questions about fishing and local sites to fish.

A Jones

2023-06

Love this place, Jim has everything you will need for a fishing trip priced extremely reasonably. The live baits are always lively and healthy. Jim keeps his shop very well stocked and rarely sells out of products unlike many of the big box stores nearby. If you aren’t sure of exactly what you need Jim is extremely knowledgeable of fishing the area, and will set you up with exactly what you need to catch fish.

Mark Willert

2023-08

Can't say enough positive about our stop in. New to the area and saw reviews so made him our first stop for info and supplies. He was quick to share information, what to use, time of day and technique. 10 minutes super well spent. Jim is the real deal. Just look at the reviews and his response to the negative ones. As real as you get. Thanks Jim!

Mario Quintana

2023-06

Jim's bait shop has been around since I was a child. If you love fishing this is the shop to check out for when you enter the Adirondacks. Not only do they have a wide variety of bait and tackle options to choose from, but they also had expert advice on what to use for specific types of fish and water conditions. Their prices were competitive and the quality of the products was top-notch. This is my local bait and tackle shop and highly recommend it to anyone looking for quality fishing gear and expert advice. If you're a serious angler or just looking to get started, this shop has everything you need to make your next fishing trip a success. 5 stars!"

ELK2u

2023-05

Jim's shop is the kind of place that you just feel good when you walk inside. He has everything that you need for every fishing need. I always get my minnows and spikes here. Jim is authentic, sincere and down to earth....and he's a excellent fisherman also. He is a true expert at his craft.

Damion Tucker

2023-07

Thanks Jim ‼️ Jim even took the time out to help me rig up my fishing rod. I'm now catching fish‼️

Brandon Levesque

2023-05

Jim was on vacation when I stopped by, but Joe was there to help us find all of our bait needs. Not only was the store filled with such an immaculate supply of bait and tackle to rival a bass pro shop but Joe was very knowledgeable in both the supplies we needed aswell as sending us to a great fishing spot

Jacqueline Smith

2023-05

My husband and I are here ice fishing because there's no ice in Connecticut! Jim is great, fair prices, welcoming and helping us so much with his knowledge of the area and fishing here! Thank you, Jim, for making our stay in NY even more enjoyable. We appreciate you!

TheLastBoyScout1976

2023-05

I paid for bait while waiting for the person in front of me to receive his. Jim’s son proceeded to get my bait and I exited the store. He ran out behind me and yelled “Hey! Are you gonna pay for that?” Across the parking lot. I was highly irate at the accusation. I told him maybe he should check with his his cashier (young girl) before calling me a thief. He never even apologized he just turned around and went back inside. I will never patronize their store again. Jim is a nice guy but his son has some obvious character flaws and his manners and common sense are nowhere to be found. Buyer beware

brodie mosconi

2023-12

best place ive ever gone too. He doesnt get enough appriciation

Heather Holcomb

2023-05

The BEST tackle store I have EVER been to!! Its one of those of rare finds that you really don't want to tell your buddies about so they don't buy everything up on you lol. If you need it or even want it, you'll find it at Jim's!!! I just found my new favorite fishing store!!! Awesome staff, awesome prices, awesome inventory!

Kaytie Compani

2021-05

Jim is the best. Always has everything we need to go fishing 🎣!! Only place we go for bait and new poles.

Jerrod Vila

2020-05

Been going here for years and years. 5+ rating no doubt. Jim is a genuine and humble guy that has everything and more anyone could ever want in regards to a bait shop. Opens super early and honestly would open for you no matter what time as long as you called him prior. Whether you need bait or just to shoot the breeze Jim's is great.

Amanda Snay

2023-10

Love the variety merchandise easy to locate helpful local information for target fishing and decent prices

Bert Perez ayala

2019-05

When I was a kid just starting fishing coming here was like a rare gift. I never wanted to leave, on one occasion I was watching the British and looking at soft plastics I didn't realize that my dad had left and I was pretty small at the time he got back and picked me up. I didn't even know he was gone and I was genuinely happy I had more time in the store. Wonderful place some of the best lures I have ever seen and the nicest people I have ever met. I highly suggest this place if you're just starting or if you've been fishing you're entire life.

April Perez

2022-05

We moved up state 17 years ago and my son Freddie always says Jim's Bate shop is a part of his childhood a favorite part ...he grew up with Jim and what an incredible kind and all around good guy he is...we went today again and talked about special funny moments we've had through the years and I always leave feeling like I visited a family member...♥️ I feel like Jim's is a right of passage for every young fisherman or fisher woman... like if you're really from here then you know Jim and all his awesomeness ! Looking so forward to the fishing contest Saturday June 19 and wish everyone the best !

James Pate

2023-09

Great service and selection. Jim was very helpful on walleye fishing.

Adam Hallenbeck (rapatator)

2020-05

Jim & company rule. The dog Steve is the coolest dog ever and will just come up and want to be pet. These guys will go out of their way to make sure you are satisfied. All fair prices and best bait around.

free bandz

2023-07

Love Jim's some of the best selection of baits and lures around .a real fisherman's paradise.

Aaron Hammock

2022-05

Awesome Guy. Has everything you need..Thanks for the advice on the Bass..

Keith Wheeler (Psike)

2019-05

Good selection. Jim was very friendly and knowledgeable. Pricing was actually competitive versus internet and big box pricing on several items I needed, which surprised me. Definitely going to make this a regular stop when I'm heading to Sacandaga and need something.

Edwin Marcais

2018-05

It's a great bait shop. Service is better than good and Jim is very knowledgeable in all aspects of fishing. They have anything and everything you would need and can order special items if necessary 5 stars.

Jeff Smith

2021-05

Pure fishing shop. Not an “outdoor sports” where you find racks of rifles, and a small corner with some bobbers and a couple of hooks. Jim sent this out-of-towner to good publicly accessible local spots. Always welcoming, willing to talk. Can’t wait to head back.

Matt S.

2020-05

Best bait store period... I'll I'll add more to my review. The selection of lures and bait and alll kinds of tackle is truly amazing..we got their 5 am rang the bell and he was out side in 2 mins. There's isn't many stores like this anymore. So take advantage of it. SHOP LOCAL!

Silas Amlaw

2023-05

Jim is a great guy with lots of info and a great shop! Often spend 15 minutes talking fishing and life !

justin rhodes

2016-05

Great guy! Always smiling always open always helpful. Never leave there disappointed. Jim makes you feel like family. I love that shop. And the prices are good too.

adam houle

2019-05

All way has any type of bait your looking for and great knowledge

David Alexander

2023-10

Always like to pick up what I need at Jims before a fishing trip

Opening Hours

Monday 5 AM-6 PM
Tuesday 5 AM-6 PM
Wednesday 5 AM-6 PM
Thursday 5 AM-6 PM
Friday 5 AM-7 PM
Saturday 5 AM-7 PM
Sunday 5 AM-3 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet