Spanky Oliver's

4.6 (171)

4 NY-31, Lyons, NY 14489

Claim this business

Ice cream shop

Service options

  • Takeout

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

Jazmin Hupp

2024-04

…More

Sharalee Warner (Shari)

2022-05

Perry's ice cream, along with several flavors of soft ice cream and sherbert, Flavor Burts. Pleasant service, clean outdoor tables. No inside service. Cash only.

Cary Johnston

2023-10

The ice cream menu is huge and a little overwhelming. The staff was great! My boyfriend had a banana split that weighed about 5 lbs, and he loved it. They have soft serve and regular ice cream.

Amanda Baumgart

2023-07

Tough to beat the friendly staff and prices at Spanky Oliver's! A little bummed that the flavor Bursts only come with vanilla soft serve and not chocolate, but I definitely understand that having that option as well could be more costly and time consuming. (Chocolate soft serve with Butterscotch flavor Burst sounded really good while I was in line this evening!) A Chocolate and Banana shake hit the spot tonight, for sure 🤤

Delores Martin

2024-02

…More

STACIE BRIGGS

2023-08

Love their variety of sundaes. My favorite is Peace Out with apple pie. Big portions and great service.

Jessica Claeys

2023-05

I have been going here since before I was able to go by myself... Still 30yrs later... Great ice cream, Great prices, and PHENOMENAL staff!! The one worker there Haylee connected with my nonverbal autistic 6yr old son whom I couldn't figure out what he wanted... She went so far above an beyond got him an ice cream with sprinkles and he had the BIGGEST SMILE EVER!!! Afterwards she came to my truck and invited him to come back the next time she worked and then gave him $5 for his upcoming visit!! It really made me cry... She is one phenomenal young lady!!!!!! She made a very memorable experience💖👦💕

Georgia Orr

2021-05

My oldest child took my for ice cream. With. This grand dog and girl friend after a great dinner of ham and black eyed peas. Good good !! Cute place lots of parking. Big area to wait in line. Nice people. Ice cream was great. Thank you. Rob and Cheryl

Amanda Brooks

2021-05

I hope this place never closes! It's decently priced and has friendly staff. Worth every cent!

Ellyse Ducayne

2023-05

Great place with great prices, even after inflation has become a forefront issue for all of us, and huge servings. They have a lot of specialties that I've never seen other places. Oh and their soft serve is great!

Serena H.

2023-05

Good ice cream, but they stopped offering the soft serve black/red raspberry twist. Update on 6/17/22 the twist is back !! Portions are as generous as ever an service is good.

Anne Cali

2023-05

Great ice cream, great prices, and the owner is a super nice! Our first time here and will definitely be back!

Steven Oller

2021-05

Nice to see a local business open for service. The ice cream was good and the waffle cone fresh. I was a bit concerned that none of the employees or patrons were wearing masks despite the requirements.

Donald Ross

2022-05

Location is easy to miss on the east side of the convenience store. Iced cream is very good, attendants are excellent and prices lower than the more well known creameries..

Elsie Zimmerman

2023-05

Great soft icecream! The cones are quite large though.... a medium there is about the size of a large at any other icecream parlor

Denise Finan

2021-05

Good ice cream and price. Offers some not so run of the mill shake and sundae choices. Had a very good experience and will return.

Juanita Casey

2023-05

For a Lowcountry South Carolina boy, this sundae served up as more than two could handle…well, not quite. Yum yum! DO NOT MISS THIS PLACE. Bill and Nita

tom Jones

2023-05

Black raspberry on a sugar cone! Very nice!

Bryan Gonyou sr

2022-05

Love the ice cream and always friendly amd great costumer service, But wish they would clean up the outside sitting area and the outside of the place a bit looks bad and dirty..

Charles Goble

2019-05

The nicest people, and the best ice cream that my family has ever had. We are so happy to have them back this year.

Joshua

2021-05

The ONLY thing Lyons still has going for it. Excellent pricing. Excellent sizing and excellent ice cream. Did I mention it's excellent?

Kelly Gasper

2018-05

Have always loved getting ice cream here ever since i was a kid! One of the best places around!

Cass Sincerbeaux

2022-05

Great ice cream and great price I will go here over any other place. They even do dog bones on vanilla ice cream for dogs 👍👍👍👍👍

Panda Bear

2023-05

Great hometown ice cream shop. Friendly owner and staff. Another year of great ice cream!

JOANNE RIENHARDT

2020-05

Lots of flavors, hard and soft, and generous servings. Pumpkin in a chocolate and nut coated waffle cone - yum! 😋

Joe Bermudez

2021-05

Great ice cream nice portions, one of the first places to open up in the area, great quick service.

L Weaver

2023-05

Great ice cream! Highly reccomend! Servings are huge

Stephen Wise

2023-09

Best ice cream in town!

Tim Murray

2020-05

Pretty good, ice cream only. Not my fav place but does have a good menu decent prices food quality and service.

Chris V

2021-05

The hard ice cream is Perry's so we got the soft serve which was very creamy and delicious.

Opening Hours

Monday 12-8:30 PM
Tuesday 12-8:30 PM
Wednesday 12-8:30 PM
Thursday 12-8:30 PM
Friday 12-8:30 PM
Saturday 12-8:30 PM
Sunday 12-8:30 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet