2nd Time Around Consignment

4.8 (196)

123 US-20A, Leicester, NY 14481
(585) 382-5064
2ndtimeconsignment.com

Claimed
Consignment shop
Antique store
Furniture store
General store
Record store
Used clothing store
Video game store

From the business

  • Identifies as women-owned

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

Write a Review

D G

2024-04

Wonderful experience overall! Took a few items in to be looked at, they were knowledgeable and personable. The took most of my items off my hands, and for a fair deal as well.We also looked around and they have a wide selection of cool and interesting items ranging from old to new. As well as many snacks and candies(which we partook of!). We will be back!Definitely worth a look if you are in the area, and even if you arent!

everett fish

2024-04

Very nice shop. Stopped in with my mom and spotted some retro video games, they were priced fairly and I got a very nice copy of Kirby and the Crystal Shards

Tim Chapman

2024-04

Very friendly people that always interact with my children. We spend so much time in there looking at and “testing” all of the cool toys. One of our favorite places to spend time on the weekends, we always find something cool.

Beth MacIntyre

2024-04

One of the best organized and neat shops if its type that I have seen in years. A great inventory if interesting items. The staff was helpful and very nice.

Kansas Ceasr

2024-04

Pretty ok shop here. A bit of antiques, odds and ends, consignment stuff in back and general store in the middle. A nice stop if your in the area. Owners are friendly and give good deals on stuff. There is also another side where video games and other things are.

Neil Vanvalkenburg

2024-04

Nice store. Very clean and organized. Nice to stop in from time to time to see what new items they have

Eric Bertozzi

2024-02

Awsome place to find that different item, tons of different items to look at and the people that work there are wonderful friendly helpful. Nice drive than go to mount Morris to get lunch or dinner.

Tani Slater

2023-12

It's so much fun to walk through this store and even just look at what they have!Nerds and antique lovers alike will have something there for them!

Dan Gall

2024-02

A fun shop with a little bit for everyone. A great place for retro gaming and toys especially

Anne Nottingham

2023-10

This is the most amazing store if it's kind I have ever been to! The store is packed with everything from antiques, to household items, clothing, jewelry and collectibles. Very reasonable prices as well. One of the highlights of our vacation! We will be back next time we are in the area.

Lonny

2023-07

Loved this shop! The owner was a lovely lady with an adorable newfie. I got a few nicknacks for my friends. There was a wide variety of things that I haven't seen/my dad said he hadn't seen in a long time. Very clean, cute and welcoming. Absolutely will be back if I'm ever around here.

Jeremy Brown

2022-05

I honestly have no idea why I love this place so. It’s more of a well organized and friendly antique store than anything else which is something I can appreciate. As expected the inventory changes often which is great. If you are looking for a gift that is unique and you can’t find anywhere else be sure to check it out.

Phil Dutcher

2024-02

Always fun to explore. Owners friendly, wonderful folks.

Adrian Olear

2024-04

Lots of goodies here from years gone by. Very interesting finds

Bill Hursh

2024-01

Nice clean place to explore and find unique items. All priced fair.

Valerie VanDongen

2024-04

Cool little place with antiques and retro items.

Mark Bennett

2023-05

This shop has SO MUCH to offer! So many antique items and new things too! It is the perfect blend of modern and times past. Love it here, and the owners are super nice too!

Sludge Industries

2023-05

Awesome place to shop!! They have new inventory all the time. Prices are really good too!!Always keep an eye open for something really unique every time you visit!!The owners and staff are really cool and know thier customers.

Tim Fuest

2023-07

This is a very nice shop. They have a little bit of everything, which is very impressive. I feel their prices are very fair as well.

Luigi 7777

2023-05

The best consignment store around! The store displays an amazing variety of items , though I myself became particularly interested in their retro video games section. The owners are very friendly, they politely answered any question I had and were overall great to talk to. Their prices are fair and they even helped me if I had any issues whatsoever! I recommend 2nd Time Around 100%!

Dustin Haas

2023-05

Like a mini flea market! Every small town should have a good second hand store and this is one of the best I've seen. Don't worry over the passive aggressive signs hanging everywhere, the folks running the place are super nice.

Melissa Hughes

2021-05

Immaculately clean, welcoming and well-curated shop, with incredibly gracious, knowledgeable and friendly staff. Large enough to explore, but organized so that it's not overwhelming. Love the selection of pantry items and dry goods, as well. Will be back soon!

j- bangs

2023-09

So much good stuff to look at. For a 2nd hand shop its very well put together.

Tucker Johnson

2023-05

Wonderful place. All kinds of things for anyone out there from kids to collectors. Really blown away by the variety of the store. Will be going back soon.

Tina Veltz

2023-06

I love this store! I stop by to browse often and always leave with a new treasure or two!

Robert Mcafee

2023-05

Great place to find neat item's for sale with very reasonable prices owner also bring there puppies to work with them that is cool too

Roger Williams

2023-05

So cool and prices were great!! Felt bad about buying stuff because it was so well organized lol didn't want to ruin the scenes!!!

Sean Robison

2023-05

No hot women there. But I got some stuff so that's pretty cool. I would like to go there again.

William Leuer

2021-05

It's probably a good thing I live an hour away from this place because I would buy myself broke. There is ALWAYS something cool to buy - lisence plates, books, decoration beer tap handles... Staff is awesome and helpful. It's one of those hidden gems you find in small communities.

FISHN JUNK

2023-05

Loved stoping in here. I was interested mostly in the video games section, I did not get to go all the way in the back, I will check that part out next time.

Opening Hours

Monday 10 AM-5:30 PM
Tuesday 10 AM-5:30 PM
Wednesday 10 AM-5:30 PM
Thursday 10 AM-5:30 PM
Friday 10 AM-5:30 PM
Saturday 10 AM-5 PM
Sunday 10 AM-5 PM

QR Code

Scan the QR code to leave a review.

Pet Stores in the USA

Discover an extensive listing of reputable pet stores offering their products and services across the country. Find dependable solutions for all your pet care needs with ease.

Broswe by Population

Broswe By States

Browse by Alphabet