Sgaglio's Marketplace

Jacqueline Vita

2024-02

Looking for the neighborhood market with fresh fish, produce, meat, and baked goods, then venture into town and shop at Sgaglio's Marketplace. I highly recommend taking a look at their prepared meals too. I picked up the most delicious carrots as well as potato pancakes. Add any of these items to your meal and reduce your turnaround time. Your guests will delight in seeing you join them at the table sooner. The old-world charm here is welcoming, and the bakery counter sure comes in handy! Definitely worth shopping here..

Orchard Hill Organics LLC

2022-05

I own Orchard Hill Organics farm in Katonah and we just had Scaglio’s 28 day aged Cowboy Steak for dinner tonight. It was perfect. Tender, juicy, tasty and super flavorful. Isn’t it great when a product is as good as advertised.

Tom Alexander

2024-02

Great meat market and deli. You'll pay more for ground chuck than at the supermarket, but it's top shelf. Just off I-684.

Cindy Beer - Fouhy

2023-05

Like having an Old fashioned neighborhood butcher with friendly, personal service. Best pork chops, ground sirloin ( ground while you wait), perfectly trimmed boneless chicken cutlets and… they will skin and cut chicken legs if you ask. And the brisket and turkey I’ve ordered for holidays— never disappointed! Wrapped in butcher freezer paper if you ask. I live half an hour away and come in once a month to fill our freezer. I come from a family of butchers and I feel like I’m one of their family every time I come to Scaglios.!

Alias Undefined

2023-06

Scaglios's Marketplace offers, in my opinion, the highest quality food, (prep yourself or let them do it), in N. Westchester. Our current favorites such as gazpacho, a diverse selection of pristine seafood, kabobs (ready-to-grill or call in your custom-order) make summer stay-at-home or invite-friends-over dinners no-worries wins. Staff welcomes you into their historic building and then, snap-snap, attends to your needs. What's not to love?

Dr. Jay

2023-05

I used to go often but stopped recently. It can take a really long time get out of there, especially when there's a line for the cashier (and none of the other employees step in to help reduce the line). There's an extra fee for paying with a credit card, which feels cheap in a nice place with some pricey items.I've seen regulars get priority service, like someone will start serving you and then try to multitask to complete another order, which never winds up being more efficient. I also don't like that they microwave things in plastic containers.

Pete

2023-05

Have had it with this place. I just got home from Katonah and stopped at Sgaglio's to pick up a sandwich. The chicken cutlet I got is shoe leather. Totally inedible., Will now throw away a $10 sandwich. And this is not my first bad experience. Few weeks ago I stopped in to get some produce, grabbed a container of spinach, got home and half of it was wet and rotten.At times we have called in sandwich orders and they have gotten the order wrong, mustard instead of mayo, etc. Done with this place, especially annoying at these prices.

Sadya Lashua

2021-05

I have been going to Sgaglio’s since I was a little kid! John has been there since the beginning. The quality is outstanding and they treat you like family. I order our holiday meats here, as well as non special occasion items. I’m fortunate enough to work close by so I’m able to get the sandwiches for lunch sometimes too. Love you guys!

Jay Durante

2022-05

I have just started with the new salad offerings for lunch. They are fantastic. A Cob Salad - taken out and chopped and dressed and then back in the bowl to eat at my desk. it was delicious!

Dee M Nelson

2021-05

At a stop along our bike ride, I got a cod fish fillet and my four friends got breakfast sandwiches. The vegetarian breakfast sandwich had the most meat bacon.pro tip: cocktail sauce

Jim Newhouse

2023-05

Our family have been going to Sgaglios for more than 25 years and I cannot think of any market that has better personal service. Stop by the next time you're in Katonah, you'll become a fan too!

Kevin Warren

2022-05

Get the best ingredients for your soup at Sgaglio’s. Veg, seafood, cream it’s all there.

Rosemary Vorel

2023-05

I like this local market, wholesome choices, but be prepared to Pay. It often smarts the purse.

Michael Kornreich

2023-05

Great meat, only adding a % for a credit card (believe it's 4%) for such a high mark-up business is distasteful ,

Nancy Steiner

2023-09

Been shopping here for decades! Best service and excellent everything!

Wylie Graham

2021-05

they've been fantastic through this pandemic, phone orders and curbside pickup without a hitch

Hans Morefield

2012-05

Great butcher, great service, great prepared foods. It is expensive, but worth it for the quality.

Kay Lix

2022-05

The very best of fatm fresh meats and seafood.

Melanie Vancol

2022-05

Great meat selection and helpful staff

Dylan Tucker

2023-05

Expensive, slow service, not what I ordered.

Andrew Haight

2017-05

Gourmet deli and butcher. High-end selection.

Lou Sorell

2023-05

Good sandwiches a bit pricey

Matthew Gutierrez

2023-08

Yum

Douglas Vicenzi

2022-05

Great market. Highest quality.