Duffy's Deli

Kathleen Cervon

2024-04

…More

Tom Cannuscio

2020-05

Update: Killer fresh blueberry muffins. Arrived early and had one fresh out of the oven. So good!Best breakfast egg sandwiches on the North Fork, for sure. Amazing craft beer selection, either on draft to go or in cans and bottles. Also, a great little market with all the staples.

Jessica Marcano

2023-09

The food was edible, but we would never go back, bread was stale and meat tasted weird. Cobb salad was fair at best, basically lettuce and chicken. Not typical consistency of a Long Island deli. Disappointed :(

Thore Foss

2023-05

Stopped into Duffy’s on my way to a job and asked them to recreate a sandwich I’ve had at se-port deli before. The sandwich was not only better than se-port but they FRIED my chicken no microwave! I go to a lot of deli’s and had to take a minute to review this one because it was so good. Great job guys. I will be back for sure

Jason Campbell

2022-05

Perhaps, in my opinion, the second best deli in America. The staff is wonderful. All of them. They are fast, friendly, and courteous. I also don't recall them ever making a mistake with my orders. The food itself is fantastic and the prices are fair. I would absolutely recommend Duffy's if you're ever in the area.

Diana Risell

2023-05

Bought sandwiches here for a picnic at Jason’s Vineyard and the food was outstanding! Bread was delicious — fresh and flavorful. Excellent, high quality food! Loved it.

sean pedersen

2023-06

ordered a crazy italian and let me tell you the amount of meat and fresh mozz they put on that bad larry just makes your toes wiggle, phenomenal performance by the workers behind the counter for stuffing me the way they did

John J Barile

2023-05

The best muffins on long island..I stop there every time I'm out east..Never disappointed..8 in my freezer right now!

Susan Kiefer

2021-05

I love Southhold & Cutchouge. People are friendly and accommodating. I loved Duffy’s Deli. The service was fast and the food was delicious. I go out east to meet my husband at his job for lunch often. I will return here for lunch for sure 💜

Vince

2020-05

Excellent place for breakfast and lunch and very reasonable prices, staff is very courteous and helpful. Rosalie is one of the most kindest employee that I've had the pleasure to deal with on a daily basis, my food is prepared EXCELLENT.Thank You Rosie for you uplifting personality every morning. ]

Sean Hanley

2022-05

Excellent!! Fast, not over priced like the rest of the east end, super polite. Everything a Long Island Deli should be. I hate that I've driven past so many time before stopping in.

Torre Moux

2023-11

Great Local Deli, Fresh Food And Some Pastries

sean gordon

2020-05

I have to change my review from a 4 to a 2 because the quality of the food has plummeted and at times it has been inedible also over the past year I'm noticing the staff no longer listens to what you order, when you tell them you dont want salt it seems the put extra on. I even had one of the staff lie to me and say they never put salt on anything even if you ask for it. At this point I will have to go to goldbergs at least they listen to what you ask for

Marc Cohen

2023-08

Eh... Good sandwich, but the store, eh...would go again.

Traci

2012-05

Duffy's is THE place to go if you're doing a vineyard tour and want a more substantial meal than oyster crackers and meat/cheese.All sandwiches are made fresh, so be prepared to wait a bit, but I promise, it's worth it. If you're coming from NYC, of course, it's cheaper to bring sandwiches in, but regardless, Duffy's is a must-stop for beverages, snacks and a full meal!

Joseph Beckelman

2018-05

The girls behind the counter we're very inviting and super friendly. The food was fantastic and the coffee was perfect. Will stop next time I'm in the area.

Rachelle Chills

2019-05

Went during the week during the day with no one there, waited over 20mins for two small salads. I saw two people working there. One other customer came in long after I placed my order. Would have asked what the hold up was but I almost fell asleep waiting.

Vincent Mata IV

2018-05

Avoid this place at all costs. Customer service is horrible and if you find a hard piece of plastic in your food like me, don't bother going back there to tell them. Very disappointed and will never return.

Maria Vasqez

2022-05

I go at this place all Sunday morning everything was good untill this morning I order some sanwish the guy was angry I think and give me the sanwish very cold and was nasty I never back at this place

Sean Andersen

2022-05

Fair prices. Made a good hero. Fast friendly service. Looking forward to tryin the other heros they make.

Henry Ramos

2018-05

Very good Deli friendly staff great food tables to eat inside or out with a good atmosphere and a clean restroom

LeeAnne Moore

2020-05

Excellent local Deli. Great Place to sit back and enjoy breakfast or lunch.

Johnny M

2021-05

Awesome breakfast sandwiches. Pretty impressed that they have kabowski as an option with the breakfast burrito!

Scott Nietupski

2021-05

The girls and guys behind the counter a great very friendly and they make a very good sandwich

Victoria Barlow

2018-05

Perfect vacation deli. Great sandwiches, lots of snacks, meals to eat waiting for the bus, friendly staff.

Alex Flansbug

2018-05

So wholesome, never had a bad sanwhich here, great service.

Christopher Colwell

2018-05

Great food and service. Best breakfast sandwiches around.

Susana Vidal

2018-05

A horrible woman screamed at my daughter for no real reason, I wished I read the other customer reviews first. We are never going back

Kathy Welborne

2023-05

Great service, good sandwichs

Wendy James

2022-05

Nice local deli. Good egg sandwich!!